Advice on pruning giant yew shrubs

9 years ago

Please bear in mind that I have no shrub maintenance experience whatsoever. I have read the FAQ for this forum, and done some internet research on pruning yews. In pragmatic terms, what I THINK it boils down to is this: If yard reclamation is the priority(it is), you can cut back yews whenever and to whatever extent you like.

I'm in SE Michigan. On the west side of my house are these two giant shrubs, which I assume are yews, although I've never seen any berries on them. They form a wonderful natural windbreak against winter winds and provide an excellent privacy screen. They were already quite large when I bought the house 25 years ago and I've never trimmed them or done anything to them at all, now they are taking over the yard. I'd estimate the height at about 25 ft. and some of the trunk branches are 8 in. diameter.

I've seen some internet videos about how it's safe to cut back yews right to ground level, but what I would really like to do is about a 50% cutback to preserve the windscreen and privacy functions. The other concern is the amount of wood to dispose of - I will have to burn the refuse, and I'll have to dry the wood over the winter so I don't get smoke complaints from the neighbors. Please note that only 0 cost options can be considered. So here are my questions:

1) Is a 50% cutback really a good idea, or should I bite the bullet and cut them back hard?
2) Is it safe to do the cutback right now(June)?
3) Should I just go around the shrubs and cut each branch back 50%?

Thanks for any suggestions, and if there are other questions I should be asking I'd appreciate hearing that too. Again, please keep in mind that my priority here is yard reclamation, but I also don't want to kill the shrubs.

(I couldn't find any instructions on how to post photos in this forum, I apologize if I have broken any rules)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱
9 years ago
Yes, they are yews.

To answer your questions...

1). Actually 50% is cutting back pretty hard.
2). Hard pruning of yews is suggested to be done in March in Michigan, but you can get away with it anytime before late July.
3). If you cut each branch back 50%, you'll have pretty bare naked trees. Although yours are pretty open with some green inside, if you look close you'll see 80-90% of the green is in that outer 50%.

If they were mine, I'd start with pruning off the horizontal branches at the bottom and then work my way around the trees taking the most protruding branches back to a smaller branch inside. As you do this, note how much you've cut off and make sure there is still 60% of the green you started with still on the trees.

Make sense?

tj
0
yewmonger
Original Author
9 years ago
tj,

Thanks very much, this sounds like a great idea! When you say 'pruning off', I assume you mean to cut those horizontal branches right back to their base? I could do that right now and it wouldn't be too much wood to dry, then I could start on the rest of it next March. 60% or so should be perfect.
0
Related Discussions
Pruning Overgrown Yew
Q
Comments (19)
Recently I bought a small 1941-built house. It has two landscaped areas fronting the foundation on either side of the front entrance. One side is attractively planted with two Purpleleaf Sand Cherry shrubs, Spirea Goldmound and Little Princess Spirea. The other side has two overgrown 10-foot-tall upright yews, which have a dead-as-vaudeville juniper in between them. These shrubs are fronted by various spirea that grow no taller than 2 1/2 ft. The real estate listing with PHOTOS is at http://tour.circlepix.com/tour.htm?id=571982&refurl= I'd like to replace the three offending shrubs with something to make this side of the front entrance more in balance with the other side, but I cannot. Besides being next to the foundation, they are directly over the gas line, the water main, and the sewer pipe leading to the street. I'm considering cutting them down as close to the ground as possible, tucking a couple of Nine Bark Summer Wine shrubs into the area behind the spirea, and hoping the new shrubs will live. Fortunately, there's unplanted space at the corner of the house, so I should be able to get at least one Summer Wine to survive. Will a yew that's more than 60 years old really grow back and look like a Chia Pet in a matter of months, as happened with Harry Shoe's yew? If so, is it unrealistic to think I can just keep sawing it down? I've read that yew wood is extremely dense, so trying to kill the stump with glyphosate or tryclopyr is likely to get me nowhere, right? (A chipper is not possible because of the underlying pipes.) Any suggestions, solutions, ideas for replacement shrubs, etc. are most welcome. If preferred, a personal response can be send to abuelita_gaviota@yahoo.com. Thanks. Here is a link that might be useful: House&Yard/Photos of my yews.
...See More
Thuja Green Giant Privacy Screening Project Advice
Q
Comments (36)
Thanks for all of the advice guys. @ davidrt28 - thanks for the advice and ordering info @ kato_b , tsugajunkie - the larger 5 gallon plants don't look as bad. there is still some green, but they don't look that great. I actually started planting the smaller trees further back from the road because I was worried about the salt spray. I think they're around 28ft from the road and have those hedges in between the road and small trees. I thought that would have been enough protection... also before they even started salting last fall, they were starting to turn orangish. @ davidrt28 - nope.. I didn't fertilize them @ tsugajunkie - thanks for that link, I may have to look into a different species what a discouragement ... it would have been nice to see the majority survive after all the time and money I put into the project I'm thinking the best thing to do is look for several species that's resistant to salt spray and add a mix of trees This post was edited by duke90 on Thu, May 2, 13 at 0:53
...See More
Plant/shrub to replace giant hosta
Q
Comments (8)
Can you post a photo of the area? That often helps me with ideas. If you can find a low-growing rhododendron, that would give you evergreen, structure, low maintenance, and flowers. I have a Rhododendron 'Checkmate' that stays at around 3 feet without pruning. It's a small-sized member of the PJM group (Weston Nursery), so it looks like them with sort of mahogany winter foliage and magneta spring flowers. It gets perhaps 3 or 4 hours of sun and bright shade the rest of the day, and stays tidy and dense without any effort on my part. There are also smaller Rhodies such as 'Purple Gem' or some of the series that include 'Yaku Prince', 'Yaku Princess' or 'Ken Janik' which all grow slowly enough to keep in check without much effort. You can use the search engine I'm giving you a link to below to look for others in your size range. There are other Heath family evergreens (all acid loving like the Rhodies) that stay low such as some of the dwarf forms of mountain laurel, Kalmia latafolia, such as 'Elf' or 'Minuet'. Leucathoe is another that is native and mine haven't exceeded 3' in over 20 years. Some forms have variegated leaves. There are a few forms of andromeda, Pieris japonica, that stay below 4', and there may be some smaller, though since I can't grow these I can't give you much information. It might be a bit shady for best color with a ninebark, and I definitely wouldn't want a full-sized one there, but Physocarpus opulifolius 'Little Devil' is supposed to stay in the 3-4' range. Mine is too young to know if it really will, but perhaps T2D will add her 2 cents since she has some that are older. Microbiota decussata (Siberian Cypress) looks a bit like an arborvitae but is much shorter (1'-2') and completely shade tolerant. Some perennials that might look nice with the shrubs include sedges/Carex - many are variegated or have colored foliage Hakonechloa macra (Japanese forest grass, hakone grass) - variegated or gold, clumping, looks nice (tan) for at least part of the winter Epimedium - flowers and can be clumpers or spreaders Astilbe - flowers in the white/pink/red range and ferny foliage Pulmonaria - flowers in the pink/blue/white range and spotted to almost entirely silver foliage (check out 'Majeste' or 'Samurai') Heuchera - evergreen, many different foliage colors and many have nice flowers that the hummingbirds enjoy Also look at other hosta - smaller, variegated leaves, longer blooming. Here is a link that might be useful: American Rhododendron Society database
...See More
Planting Thuja Green Giant Advice
Q
Comments (47)
Jim, your two photos above that shows a road right next to the trees. I am very curious how much growth each year these trees will do each year. Please keep us updated if you can. It appears you have some pretty large trees right next to or overhanging these small trees, so they must get a lot of shade throughout the day? I farthest from any tree expert here, but the more sun these guys get i think the more growth they show? I have some new ones i planted too that the sun will be blocked by other larger trees in the area during the middle summer months.
...See More
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
9 years ago
cut them to about 2 feet ...

so that in two years.. when you are so tired of looking at how horrible they still look.. you can use the stumps to dig them out ...

IMHO ... GET RID OF THEM ... [or at least write us back and tell us when you become overwhelmed with how it all worked out ]

dont forget.. in MI ... you have a very limited growing season ... and peeps in warmer zones ... do this type of thing.. but with the significantly longer growing season ... the plants actually recover ... with our 5 months of active growth ... i dont have much faith in all this ...

live and learn.. good luck with what ever you decide ...

ken
0
tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱
9 years ago
Yes, prune the horizontals back to the base.

Ken was traumatized in his youth with pruning yews, so take his comments with a grain of salt. He is correct, however, in that it will be quite an undertaking, but since you value their windbreak and privacy attributes, whether it is worth it will be up to you.

tj
0
yewmonger
Original Author
9 years ago
Yes, I understand it will be a daunting task involving great pain for both me and the shrubs, but I will move ahead and take tj's approach. Thanks very much for your help!
0
seagreen_turtle Z5b/6a SE Michigan
9 years ago
Wow yewmonger, I've never seen yews that big. I didn't even know they could grow that tall. I had some really old ones in front of my house when I moved in over 15 years ago. I always sorta kept them pruned down to about 3.5 feet but they increased in girth every year. I started hacking them back two years ago so that I could get between them and the house.

Then I decided to take them out because they were > 50 years old and growing in prime sunny location (what a waste, one of the few conifers (only?) that can tolerate shade and they were taking up full sunshine space. So I cut them back to 1 foot stumps and left them that way all winter until I could find someone who would dig the roots out. I was sad to kill healthy plants but they really were ugly and a maintenance nightmare.

I'm telling you all this to say that, yes, some green sprigs appeared here and there this spring but I can't imagine how long out would take for them to fill in (probably never). So, as you're doing, don't take off too much. If you can wait, take some off and see how they do. Prune more next spring.

Just my two cents.

LOL ken_adrian about leaving the stumps at two feet so you can dig them out when you're tired of looking at them. That made me laugh.
0
prairiemoon2 z6b MA
9 years ago
I had a huge, really old yew in my front foundation bed and I wanted to get rid of it in the worst way, but I just never got the opportunity to do it, so I was so sick of looking at it I decided to prune it and get it smaller and healthier again while I was waiting to get it out of there.

I took 3 years of pruning it moderately and making sure I left enough greenery on each branch. Trying to make the bottom of it wider than the top so the sun would hit the lower branches. It responded beautifully. And just last week, one of my adult kids was here for a visit and remarked how good it looked.

I plan on pruning it more this year too and I guess I better get to it before it's too late for the season.

Good luck!
0

Advice on pruning giant yew shrubs

Comments (7)

tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱

yewmonger
Original Author

Related Discussions

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱

yewmonger
Original Author

seagreen_turtle Z5b/6a SE Michigan

prairiemoon2 z6b MA

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Advice on pruning giant yew shrubs

Comments (7)

tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱

yewmongerOriginal Author

Related Discussions

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱

yewmongerOriginal Author

seagreen_turtle Z5b/6a SE Michigan

prairiemoon2 z6b MA

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

yewmonger
Original Author

yewmonger
Original Author