skip to main content

Learned something about climbers...

11 years ago

This forum and the Antique Rose Forum are fantastic - I am always learning new things. A new piece of information was posted inside of a thread on the Antique Rose forum lately that I think is important enough to repeat here.

There are frequently threads started here along the lines of "why isn't my climber climbing?", "how can I get my climber to climb?", "I must have gotten the bush form, not the climbing form of this rose, because it is not climbing.", etc. etc.

Well, what I learned, thanks to Anita passing on a comment from Anne Belovich, is that some climbing roses won't climb unless they are tied up to, or at least touching, some sort of support. If they can't perceive a support, they put out fatter, stronger, and shorter canes, to provide the support they need themselves. (Think of a picture of a large mounding rose in the middle of a flat meadow.) If they perceive a support, they put out longer, thiner climbing canes. This makes so much sense from the perspective of how climbing roses evolved in the wild - if you find a tree or bush, climb it to get more light. If no tree or bush is handy, make yourself higher by creating an internal structure.

Just wanted to pass this along on here in case folks hadn't seen it -

I can think of several examples where this was going on in my garden and I didn't realize it. One example - I planted a rooted cutting of Cl. American Beauty in a sunny spot about 3 feet away from our house about 7 years ago. It grew to about 2 1/2 feet tall, and stopped. Last year in frustration I took a new still growing cane that was just long enough to reach the house and tied it horizontally, so that maybe the final 6 inches were up against the house. Now that cane has gotten 3 feet longer, and two more long canes have emerged from the base of the plant, both of which I have tied up to the house.

Just another example of the great stuff folks learn on these forums - I have never seen this mentioned in books -

Jackie

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

zjw727
11 years ago
I love this forum, and I read every post- whether it relates to my garden or not. You never know when you're going to come across a real gem of useful information (like this post...I've never heard this theory before and it makes perfect sense)!
User
11 years ago
yep - it has a cool name too - thigmatropism. You can try it with passion flower tendrils which will start to twine within 20 seconds of touching the tendril with a finger.
Related Discussions
Learned something new about my GE Adora today
Q
Comments (23)
Our GE Adora washing machine has been a constant source of trouble for several years now. It cannot be "balanced" no matter what we do and now the front of the cabinet has "rips" in the metal from shaking so violently. The door leaks, the front control panel shorts out and the exterior cabinet is rusting through in the front lower corners. This washer has many "known issues" and GE refuses to acknowledge them. Since we're out of warranty, I'm not going to try anything else to keep this hunk of junk running. We use only HE detergent and when we add bleach to the dispenser, it simply runs out immediately on the clothes... Clothes are now being torn but we can't find anything obviously damaged in the tub, so we don't know what's tearing the clothes. We leave the door open when the washer is empty so we don't get the moldy smell that so many others have experienced. This is by far the worst appliance we have ever purchased and we'll never buy a GE product again...
...See More
Learned something about paint today
Q
Comments (7)
I seem to have the worst luck possible with paint of all kinds. I've bought a Wal-Mart brand latex primer that looked like thick marshmallow sauce, went on great, bonded to the old plaster great, and when it dried had little bits of solid pigment streaking the wall everywhere. Went to a very expensive oil based primer for a different room and got fewer similar but more noticeable little mushy blob results. Mixed that paint again today this time using my drill and agitator for 10 minutes and wound up with bigger, softer, blobs and the paint seems sticky right from the can. I guess that is progress of a sort. Will repeat tomorrow. My first message contains the answer to your question.
...See More
Learned Something Today About Pudding
Q
Comments (7)
mustangs81- Thanks for the up-date. It's been a long time since I purchased instant pudding. They must have changed the instant pudding formula if they suggest fat free milk. I'm sure it once stated to use 2% milk because I did a pumpkin pudding recipe at the public library with kids (along with reading books about pumpkins) and I had to be sure to buy 2% milk or the recipe wouldn't thicken properly. Decades ago I had a home-based business and sold whey-based milk substitute (fat-free) and it wouldn't work unless I made double-strength powdered milk (twice as much powder) - so it had more milk solids by doing that. That was a trick for making yogurt with powdered milk. I found "fixes" on-line that included reducing the amount of milk (1-1/2 cups instead of 2 cups) and adding 2 t. cornstarch. Did you try that, and if so - did it work?
...See More
Something I just learned about my Corian countertops...
Q
Comments (51)
I refinished the tops in a 5th wheel today. The RV industry is famous for not following the manufacturer's instructions to NOT put a high gloss finish on countertops which is what they did in the first picture. Of course every scratch showed. With a color this dark you've got to have at least a semi-gloss finish as in the second picture. Note how much more "fuzzy" the reflections. She was delighted.
...See More
jacqueline9CA
Original Author
11 years ago
Thank you for the name! That is very cool - I will have to look it up when I have more time. I have noticed vines like clematis which have tendrils reacting to touching potential climbing supports, but had no idea roses do that too.

Jackie
TNY78
11 years ago
ooooh....I learned something new today too! Thanks for sharing! Now that I think about it, my young climbers that I have tied to my fence are doing much better than the ones that I'm kind of leaving to their own will..hmmm

Tammy
harborrose_pnw
11 years ago
I'm always wanting my climbers to be shrubs, so it makes sense then that keeping them away from a support will help. I missed that thread, Jackie, thanks.
nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
11 years ago
This is all very interesting. I've got a shrub rose, Blueberry Hill, that wants to be a climber. It grew so big last summer that one large cane started touching the house. That one cane began growing up the house quite quickly. Once the warm weather starts this spring in earnest, it will be interesting to see if it continues to climb. It looks pretty funny right now. Diane
mendocino_rose
11 years ago
Another interesting climber thing that I learned is that if you take a cutting from a lateral on a climber that rose might not climb.
bethnorcal9
11 years ago
Another thing about climbers that I've found is... Climbing sports of bush roses generally do not repeat bloom as well as the bush form. They apparently spend more time trying to climb, taking energy away from blooming. That's why I only use climbers that are just climbers.

And Campanula, it's funny you mentioned the thing about the passion flower vines. I used to have one, and everybody at my work wanted cuttings. I always remember one of the girls telling me how when she took it home, she had the cutting in a little plastic container of water on her dashboard. It was a fairly long piece of stem I gave her, and one of the tendrils had reached up and grabbed her passenger-side visor and was happily hanging on til she got home. I always thought that was so funny.

Related Stories

FUN HOUZZ Everything I Need to Know About Decorating I Learned from Downton Abbey

Mind your manors with these 10 decorating tips from the PBS series, returning on January 5

INSIDE HOUZZ For Houzz Pros: Learn About the New Affiliation Badge Program

Enhance your professional profile with badges showing your schools, associations and more

MOTHER’S DAY What We've Learned From Mom About Home

By Vanessa Brunner

Share cherished memories as Houzzers recall the special traits, insights and habits of their mothers

GARDENING GUIDES Learn the Secret to Bigger and Better Roses

By Noelle Johnson Landscape Consulting

Grow beautiful roses using both ordinary and unusual soil amendments

VACATION HOMES Houzz Tour: Rock Climbers Create the Ultimate Mountain Getaway

By Emily Hutchinson

Two friends build a vacation home in Australia’s Blue Mountains, where they can relax with others after a day of climbing

CONTRACTOR TIPS 6 Lessons Learned From a Master Suite Remodel

By Ventana Construction LLC

One project yields some universal truths about the remodeling process

DECORATING GUIDES What We Can Learn From the Minimalists

Discover the power of simplicity and how to employ a less-is-more approach in your decorating scheme

INSPIRING GARDENS What We Can Learn From Longwood Gardens’ New Meadow

By Benjamin Vogt / Monarch Gardens

Sustainability, ecology, native plant communities ... this public garden is brimming with lessons on horticulture for home gardeners

KITCHEN CABINETS Learn the Lingo of Kitchen Cabinet Door Styles

By Ventana Construction LLC

Understand door types, materials and cabinet face construction to make the right choice when you shop

KIDS’ SPACES 5 Ideas for a Great Home Learning Zone

By Catherine Funkhouser

Get your child off to a good start this school year with homework areas and strategies that reduce the frenzy

Sponsored

More Discussions

Thierry Marx is not happy!

23

Why? Heirloom Roses! WHY?

66

A few of the early blooms for 2024

13

What might cause a rose to have two colors?

6

Which of these fragrant shrubs should I get as a replacement?

7