Screening Shrub advice and questions

11 years ago

I've posted in the landscaping section as well but thought I might try these waters as well.

I moved into a house and need some privacy that a fence won't accomplish. I've attached a photo of the space in question and since this is winter and this photo is taken from my dinette, an evergreen shrub is pretty much all I will consider (unless someone can educate me otherwise!)

The twiggy tree/shrub to the left I believe is a lilac and the only other thing back there is a little weeping japanese maple....I've ripped out everything else (ground cover).

At first I was considering a Leyland Cypress since its fast growing and dense but then the height I think would be too much for this little garden. I've also considered Rododendrons and Moutain Laurels but they are too slow growing for what I am after (still contemplating a B&B of this though). Others I have consider were a Hicks Yew, but I run a home daycare and I'm too nervous to put that in. Finally, I'm contemplating a Redtip Photinia but read they are hardy from 6-9 and I'm barely in zone 6 (I'm in the Niagara/ St. Catharines region) and am wondering if I can pull this one off.

The garden is in the south behind the house. It is blocked between a small shed (west) on my property and a shed (east) on my neighbours but is open to the south and north. The area gets mostly shade as there are a few large mature trees in the yard that block the sun but it does get sun in the late afternoon once the sun is in the south where the road faces. The soil around here is also heavy in clay. There is also a dip in the land where the tree/shrub would need to go. It never has standing water though. Ideally I would like to keep the Japanese Maple.

Any help is greatly appreciated!!

Comments (9)

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author
11 years ago
Here is a photo of the same garden from the back deck where the outside dining is, a better view of the jap. maple
lola-lemon
11 years ago
I doubt the Photinia will work. It'll get killed down and look ratty.
You have some challenging conditions. Soggy clay, nearly full shade and you want fast growing evergreen in zone 5.

the little maple will keep growing too. Probably not get past 5 feet wide in the next 6 years though- but something to think about.

I guess to me, the obvious choice is an arborvitae. They are really common around here in the Home Depots/lowes in the spring so you could buy them already 6 feet tall for $30 or $40 bucks a piece. they tolerate some shade, like to have water and accept some clay.

To answer your zone and sunlight questions:

planting below your zone by 2 will either result in a plant that loses all it's foliage or dies over winter. It will prevent it from getting anywhere growth wise at the very least.

The sunlight question is that if you plant a full sun plant in shade it probably will dwindle. Get lanky. Not fill in with foliage. Eventually possibly die. It won't bloom if it is a bloomer.

This post was edited by lola-lemon on Thu, Feb 14, 13 at 20:51
Related Discussions
Advice on pruning giant yew shrubs
Q
Comments (7)
Wow yewmonger, I've never seen yews that big. I didn't even know they could grow that tall. I had some really old ones in front of my house when I moved in over 15 years ago. I always sorta kept them pruned down to about 3.5 feet but they increased in girth every year. I started hacking them back two years ago so that I could get between them and the house. Then I decided to take them out because they were > 50 years old and growing in prime sunny location (what a waste, one of the few conifers (only?) that can tolerate shade and they were taking up full sunshine space. So I cut them back to 1 foot stumps and left them that way all winter until I could find someone who would dig the roots out. I was sad to kill healthy plants but they really were ugly and a maintenance nightmare. I'm telling you all this to say that, yes, some green sprigs appeared here and there this spring but I can't imagine how long out would take for them to fill in (probably never). So, as you're doing, don't take off too much. If you can wait, take some off and see how they do. Prune more next spring. Just my two cents. LOL ken_adrian about leaving the stumps at two feet so you can dig them out when you're tired of looking at them. That made me laugh.
...See More
Screening Tree/Shrub Advice Needed
Q
Comments (11)
I have to agree with T'John that part shade won't give the very rapid growth you want, so you may be out big bucks to get bigger trees to start with. The magnolia, unless you paid for big ones, would be slow growing, esp. in shade - they mostly like sun, so may not do well at all in mostly shade. The sweet bay, M. virginiana, does OK with shade. Height might be iffy too - you would have to pick a cultivar carefully. Again, you would have to chose carefully, since they are shrubby when young and might need limbing up, but a vibunum of one kind or other shouldn't get too tall, and will flower. I don't know about fall color. Redbud, a native, would do, maybe as a mix of the green-leaved and the purple-leaved-in-spring-and-early summer Forest Pansy, to give early spring flowers. Franklinia is another native possibility, and would give summer flowers, but might end up too tall. Davidia, while possibly hard to find, is another summer-flowering tree, and Carolina Silver Bell (also native) is another spring flowering. Service berry or Juneberry (Amelanchier) is another native with spring flowers. Mayhaw would give flowers and berries, and is another native. And one or another of the clumping bamboos might be a thought. Hope this list gives you a few to look up and think about.
...See More
Screening Trees and Large Shrubs
Q
Comments (33)
ejr: You probably realize this (& it's most excellent Weston is guaranteeing to replace those that don't survive), but you are planting quite late. Even here on the coast in Lynn we are now getting freezes. The ideal time to plant in the autumn is in September, which gives the roots a chance to develop while the top is slowing down and preparing for winter. In any case, water, water, water, water, water! Mulch, mulch, mulch, mulch, mulch! The watering will help give the plants a bit of water in their tissues that they will need for the winter, and the mulch will help stabilize soil temperatures underneath them. That fights "heaving" which can happen when you plant late, for the soil in the planting hole will have different physical characteristics than the surrounding soil, and so as the ground freezes and thaws during the winter days the planting hole soil can get shoved up above the rest of the soil (hence "heaving"). That rips the roots of the plant out of place and sets them back very badly (or can even kill them). Those are the two usual pieces of advice for fall planting anyway, but they will matter even more for you. Make sure to carefully note whatever advice Weston offers you and follow it well. Doing so will help ensure that they honor their guarantee. Not following the supplier's advice in such a situation can lead to the warranty becoming void. (Check to see if there are any disclaimers in the guarantee. Don't be surprised if there are.)
...See More
Best shrub/tree for screen/hedge
Q
Comments (33)
That is Hydrangea paniculata 'Quickfire', and it blooms from about the first week of July until a hard freeze in the fall, changing from that bright white to a deep rosy pink. There's a fall photo of it in the thread I linked above. I'd plant a couple of small to medium sized shrubs (there's a Hydrangea 'Little Quickfire' that might well work for that) in front of the hawthorn to fill in below the tree's branches and the break up the straight line. In planning how close to plant, I look at the ultimate width of the plant and divide by two. So with your Diablo ninebark, leave 5-6 feet on each side (12/2=6). I like to plant some a bit further forward and some a bit further back so that visually they overlap more even though there's still enough space between them.
...See More
tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱
11 years ago
I want to be clear on what you're blocking and from what angle(s). Do you want to block the lights of traffic coming down the road? From both angles of your pic?

tj
flora_uk
11 years ago
From the second picture it looks to me as if it it would be best to move the maple and put your evergreen in its place. Trying to put something between the lilac and the maple would-be too much of a squeeze.

I can't help on zone appropriate plants but if you're concerned about the toxicity of yew you need to check anything you put there. Both rhododendron and Kalmia are toxic. As are a great many other plants, albeit it many only mildly.
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
11 years ago
can you link us to your landscape forum post.. did they come up with anything???

ken
Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author
11 years ago
I've attached a link to post in the landscaping section...not much help there. I've gotten a lot of good feedback from this post, so thank you all.

I think my final decision I am working with is conifers (different colours, sizes and shapes), starting with a row of Emerald Green arborvitae in the back to build a privacy screen. The arborvitae suggestion brought on a bit of love for the conifers which I initially didn't have. Further research into them made me discover some that I can't resist not having in my yard including but not limited to: Chamaecyparis Rubicon and Spirited, Juniper Gold Cone and Picea Abies Rydal. There are a couple other areas in my yard where I need privacy and I think the conifers is a good choice since I think they will do well in my zone and they will add winter interest. Plus I have a large evergreen tree in my yard already so adding the conifers will just add some unity.

I'll move the japanese maple if I need be...and it does seem a though I will need to do it, which is fine. I just hope I don't kill it!!

I am going to post in the landscaping forum post with some pictures of the whole yard and a quick birds eye view of what I want the shape of my gardens to look like...If any of you have time please take a peek over and add any inputs on shrubs!

Here is a link that might be useful: Post in Landscaping section
lola-lemon
11 years ago
When I first bought the home I am in now, I also had a bias against Arborvitae (thuja). There was a row of them separating my yard and my neighbors for privacy.
the neighbors also have arborvitae on their side of the fence. Over the years I have come to love these beautiful shapely healthy arborvitae I have. they are a lush green wall of life and always look good. In the shade at their feet I have a selection of variegated Hosta and then Hellebore creating a nice contrast.
I keep my arborvitae looking good by pruning them lightly each year for shape and topping their size and cleaning out the dead foliage that collects in their centers so they don't spread apart.
My neighbors have not taken care of theirs and theirs have grown to different sizes, some too tall so snow has caused several to bend over, or split into two tops--they are scraggly shaped and ugly. 15 minutes of attention per plant year can keep them pretty.
the Emerald Greens are a great cultivar too- just the right size and shape. Take little work to keep nice looking.
Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author
11 years ago
You know...I was nearly 80% sure that the Emerald Green is what I was going with, but now your post has made it final. Thank you!
edlincoln
11 years ago
How much patience do you have? What is the soil like?

Might be too slow growing for you, but my thoughts are American Holly or Eastern Red Ceder.

White pine isn't very dense, but does grow fast.

Screening Shrub advice and questions

Comments (9)

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author

lola-lemon

Related Discussions

tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱

flora_uk

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author

lola-lemon

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author

edlincoln

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Screening Shrub advice and questions

Comments (9)

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)Original Author

lola-lemon

Related Discussions

tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱

flora_uk

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)Original Author

lola-lemon

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)Original Author

edlincoln

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author

Erin Farr (Niagara Zone 6)
Original Author