Fescue vs. Kentucky Bluegrass

11 years ago

I live in Lincoln, NE and this summer was a drought that also had water restrictions for our city, so my backyard and frontyard have turned to a brownish color rather than the normal, healthy green.

I am going to plant some seed this weekend, but had a few questions.

Should I do fescue or Kentucky bluegrass? I have no kids and 1 small dog.

Which grass is it that is the soft kind when you touch or lay on it?

I don't own a tiller or aerator. Can I still lay the seed?

Should I water the yard before I rake up the soil?

Do I need to buy top soil or what kind of soil do I need?

I have quite a large backyard. Would it be harmful to just plant all across the yard, even on some areas that don't need seeding? Should I apply more seed to bare spots and thin spots?

I really am not sure what type of grass I currently have. Will it hurt my grass if I plant 2 different types?

Does fescue give a nice look to it like KBG?

Featured Answer

tiemco

11 years ago

last modified: 9 years ago

I will try to answer your questions since Goren has given his usual stock answers that are misleading and awkward to read.

Should I do fescue or Kentucky bluegrass? I have no kids and 1 small dog.

This is a questions that doesn't have a simple answer. They both make nice lawns in full sun, tall fescue does much better in shadier areas. Tall fescue is quick to germinate and establish, while KBG takes longer, and time is not on your side at this point in the summer. Tall fescue doesn't really spread all that much, KBG can spread to fill voids in the turf. Tall fescue can tolerate heat better and can go longer without water, but has a short dormancy, then death occurs. KBG can go dormant for long stretches, returning to green when the weather cools and the rains come. As you can see they have their strengths and weaknesses. Since you are seeding late in the summer, I would either go all tall fescue, or a tall fescue/ Kentucky bluegrass mix.

Which grass is it that is the soft kind when you touch or lay on it?

KBG is very soft bladed. It makes the finest turf in most cases. The newer tall fescues are soft as well, but not as soft as KBG.

I don't own a tiller or aerator. Can I still lay the seed?

Yes, you don't need to till or aerate. If you have a lot of dead grass and thatch you can use a power rake to remove the dead stuff and expose the soil.

Should I water the yard before I rake up the soil?

It will keep the dust down, and soften up the dead stuff, but it's not necessary.

Do I need to buy top soil or what kind of soil do I need?

No, unless you have no topsoil in your yard. If your topsoil is lacking, or you have some leveling to do you should. A good weed free loam (40:40:20 sand, silt, clay) makes a good topsoil.

I have quite a large backyard. Would it be harmful to just plant all across the yard, even on some areas that don't need seeding? Should I apply more seed to bare spots and thin spots?

Yes, you can do that without harm. You want to use the overseeding rate on areas of grass, the new seeding rate on bare areas. This is easy to do with a spreader.

I really am not sure what type of grass I currently have. Will it hurt my grass if I plant 2 different types?

It won't hurt, but you might end up with an inconsistent lawn.

Does fescue give a nice look to it like KBG?

Yes, the newer turf type tall fescues are dark green, fine bladed, and thick. Here is a link to another thread with pics of my lawn last year. http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/load/lawns/msg0621330425292.html

I hope these answers help, and if you have more questions don't be afraid to ask them.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

goren
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Since you mention the use of Kentucky Blue I'm going to assume you wish to use a 'cool season' type grass.
Generally, if a type of lawn turf has problems....i.e. turns brown when water is at a premium, or tends to die out during heat spells, or some other problem that is perplexing a homeowner....the usual advice is to try to overcome the problem by planting a seed that is not affected by what troubles the one type....so, and I'm sure the seed dealer will agree, plant a combination of grass seeds so that each can give its best when times are tough on one.
A good combination for cool season type grass is 40% Kentucky Blue, 30% perennial ryegrass and 30% red fescue.
Combinations approaching those percentages are found anywhere and everywhere so you shouldn't have any trouble finding.

Its generally agreed that before you overseed an area that has already a lawn, correct any imperfections the ground might have...i.e. fill in with topsoil any depressions, any mounds that can be rolled and thus levelled, any bare patches that are best fixed with plugs....etc etc.
A toplayering of 1/2" to 1" topsoil or compost or triple mix...you decide...is laid either before, or after the scattering of the seed.
Sometimes seed is administered with the fertilizer spreader...a starter fertilizer can be considered and applied with the seed.
Scattering by hand is easy as long as you apply a generous amount to the area. Seed is not inexpensive....but for a good turf it is recommended that you apply the best seed you can afford...it pays dividends in the end.

If you are having to buy the topsoil...and your area is large...you can trust this formulae to find out exactly how much soil you would have to purchase.
If the amount is large, then buying IN BULK is the least expensive.
Measure the area you intend to work...length times width...
IN FEET. That gives you square feet...multiply that times the depth IN INCHES....then multiply that figure times 3....and divide by 1000.
That results in the number of cubic yards of soil you have to buy to cover the area.

example...if the area is 25 feet by 50 ft..equals 1250 sq ft
times depth..1" = 1250 X 3 = 3750 divided by 1000 =- 3.75 cubic yards of soil.
Such amount is best bought in bulk...delivered by truck to your driveway--then by wheelbarrow to the area.

If the area is wanted to be leveled first, then rolling can be done. Rolling can also be done AFTER the seeding process to better put the seed into contact with the soil.

Overseeding is ..for me anyway...a ritual I follow every fall. It encourages strong turf that stands up to adversity...disease and pests.
Generally, if you follow a regimen of fertilizing...the high nitrogen content can speed up filling in bare spots and greening up.
Going cheap on the feeding program encourages weak growth...and if winter throws a hard freeze early, it can make for spring problems.

Watering is also not cheap. But again watering is necessary for the grass roots to grow strong...so the usual recommendation of 1" of water (rain notwithstanding) per week is the norm and helps grass grow lushly.
Only by experimenting with how you apply water can you learn about what your lawn needs.
Related Discussions
Advice for Kentucky Bluegrass
Q
Comments (18)
Well. at the risk of seeming fickle, I have decided to go with the Midnight II, Moonlight and Bedazzled mix used by Turf Toes. Essentially, I was able to convince my wife that going darker was better. She just wants me to move on it and get our lawn back to something other than dirt. At some point, I will post pictures of the renovation. Bestlawn & others, I appreciate all the advice you have given, and I gained not only from this string, but others you have posted in Gardenweb. I have read many - many of them. I used an older list Bestlawn published of a bunch of suppliers, and visited many of their web sites and/or called them (though not all of them). The only two I could find who have all three varieties in sod quality is Steyer farm and Williams Lawn Seed. Steyer called me back but did not have the price in hand - he will Monday, but it only comes in minimum 50lbs. WLS did not have the price Friday but will Monday as well, I do not know about the minimum quantity. Rose Agriseed no longer caries Bedazzled. By the way, they also do not carry Brilliant nor Serene. Also, their Galaxy is not sod quality. I did not want to go with their Galaxy mix as it has Prosperity and I do not want to replace Bedazzled with something darker. My next challenge is finding the mix in sod quality, without having to purchase a large quantity. I probably only need 15 to 20 lbs. I know I could go with non-sod quality from a place such as summitseed.com, but I understand that it may introduce a lot more weeds than sod quality. If I have to, I will go ahead and buy the larger quantity and then try to sell what I do not use. Any idea how long seed is good for, assuming it is kept fairly dry and cool? No matter what, I am purchasing tomorrow 5/16/08. Thank you all again. David
...See More
Perennial Ryegrass Getting In My Kentucky Bluegrass
Q
Comments (5)
Hard to say, identifying grasses from pics is never easy, and yours aren't the best. There are plenty of websites that can help you with IDing grasses and weeds. Anyway here are the basics of the three cool season grasses (there are some other characteristics that aren't as obvious such as ligule shape and form, rolled or folded leaves in sheath, etc). Tall fescue: Pointed tip, prominent veins, no obvious midrib. Edges are serated, but in turf types it isn't as prominent as in wild types. Perennial rye: Fused speed boat tip, veins visible, dorsal midrib, front side dull, back side shiny. KBG: Boat shaped (canoe) tip, no obvious veins, dorsal midrib, leafs are smooth and soft. Poa triv and poa annua have the characteristics of KBG, but can be highly variable in appearance.
...See More
Can I overseed with kentucky bluegrass and tall fescue?
Q
Comments (2)
It won't cause any issues but the chances of establishing KBG via overseeding into a mature stand of TTTF are slim. KBG takes a long time to germinate (up to 3 weeks) and it will have a hard time competing for sunlight and resources against the mature fescue. You will also trample all over it when you have to mow by week 2 - the fescue will greatly enjoy all the water and starter fertilizer too. Personally I think it can only be done in one way: apply a double dose of Primo Maxx to the turf one week before seeding, then at seeding time scalp it - cut it as low as your mower will go. Between the PGR and the shock of the low cut that may stunt its growth long enough to establish the KBG.
...See More
When does kentucky bluegrass become agressive
Q
Comments (5)
yard: If I had a boarder I'd charge him rent, even if he does keep my KBG at bay. :) Wrong again manure breath. It derives from the European farming method where they broke up the field with grassy strips called alleys or "boarders" (because the alley was taking up space and food normally allocated for cash crops, like a boarder in the home.) Lol. Good catch daniel. I've corrected it. dchall., I can't say if that would happen everywhere with KBG. I figured, what the heck, I'll try it. If it didn't work, or I didn't like the look, at worse, all I needed to do was replant the strip. Sometimes the local experts know of which they speak. :)
...See More
grass1950
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Nice reply tiemco.
PW25
Original Author
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Thank you for your responses! You have given very helpful information and I greatly appreciate it.
PW25
Original Author
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Here are a few pics of my current lawn situation. Suggestions?

http://i1137.photobucket.com/albums/n520/kylegraham25/19CF8F5A-35D4-420B-B57D-151E35A310BC-797-000000D2B9F1FE84_zps429ae099.jpg

http://i1137.photobucket.com/albums/n520/kylegraham25/D13B6989-A4FE-439B-B3DA-21371E2DC6E6-797-000000D2B4880849_zps24611184.jpg

http://i1137.photobucket.com/albums/n520/kylegraham25/E78CAB05-24AF-4137-B218-331028EC9EC1-797-000000D2AD4BF398_zpsa5f866d2.jpg
tiemco
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
If you want to seed those areas, you have to get that dead grass out of the way so the seed can lie on the dirt. I would power rake the whole yard to get all that removed before seeding. I can't tell the grass type however, you need close up pics of the blades for that, and they have to be clear pictures, not blurry.
PW25
Original Author
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Okay. Yeah it was taken from my phone. You give me a good idea of what I need to do, though. Thanks.
Bert9999 J
6 years ago
why not post some newer pics of your new lawn and did you go all fescue or a fescue kbg blend

Fescue vs. Kentucky Bluegrass

tiemco

Comments (8)

goren

Related Discussions

grass1950

PW25
Original Author

PW25
Original Author

tiemco

PW25
Original Author

Bert9999 J

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Fescue vs. Kentucky Bluegrass

tiemco

Comments (8)

goren

Related Discussions

grass1950

PW25Original Author

PW25Original Author

tiemco

PW25Original Author

Bert9999 J

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

PW25
Original Author

PW25
Original Author

PW25
Original Author