watering advise needed...please help

10 years ago

I'm having real difficulty in determining the proper amount of water to use on my plants; this is my first venture with containers. I'm sure that some would say just use your common sense but so much of that is developed from past experiences, don't you think? And those experiences were with packaged potting soil which got sloppy wet if you weren't careful. With Al's gritty mix and it's emphasis on aeration and drainage, I know the plants are going to thrive if they're properly fed and watered. For me the watering is a whole new ball game.
My gritty mix is equal amounts of fir bark, Turface and grit, all screened to be 1/8" - 1/4". I rinsed the mix and soaked it thoroughly overnight. In the days since planting, I've waited until the skewer came up with practically no dampness before watering again. I really doused the plants until water was pouring from the drainage ports. Easy, huh?
But while rereading (which I find myself doing a lot) many of Al's posts on water retention, trees in containers, etc., as well as the resulting threads, I read about a good method to use for watering. It goes something like this: Water slowly until water begins to seep from the holes. Wait 15 or so minutes. Then resume slow watering until the draining water is at least 15-20% of the total applied. (If I've read this wrong, please correct me...please!) So I gave it a shot. I tried it on 7, 5 and 3 gallon containers. I followed the steps as listed above, and came out with the same results in every case. After the first watering, one-third of the water drained away. After 15 minutes, I resumed watering very slowly; a higher percentage drained away! In one instance, 3 oz. out of a half-cup (4 oz.) drained. Other times it was 2 oz. out of 4 oz., 6 oz. out of 8 oz. (also, 5 oz. out of 8 oz.). I apologize for being so long winded. The point I'm concerned about is that, right from the beginning, much, much more than 15-20% of the water drained away ... and the percentages only increased as I watered more. Can I be watering too much? In this experiment, when I watered the tree in the 7 gallon container, I initially poured in three cups of water; one third drained away! Was three cups too much?
Please tell me if I'm misreading or misinterpreting the 15-20% advice. Better yet, will someone give me an estimate of how much water should be used for 7, 5 and 3 gallon pots? I know it must sound as if I want my hand to be held and, maybe to a degree, I am. ;-) I'm just asking for your advice where I went wrong so I can correct it.
Many thanks.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

hexalm
10 years ago
A couple of thoughts:
1) Last time I checked on Al's current practices, he doesn't even screen Turface to that size (some folks do, but it's not strictly necessary). What I do is use a strainer to get just the finest particles out. I initially did screen to 1/8 in, but a) you get very little of it to use and b) things dry out pretty quickly (I could see that being useful for rot-prone succulent in plastic pots, but I doubt it's that much help compared to just watering less frequently).

2) If the mix is retaining moisture as you would want/hope/expect, I wouldn't worry about what percentage of water is draining out. When I water, I don't even go back after 10-15 minutes usually, I just water once with around a half-strength fert solution. This hasn't caused any problems, so far. In cases where I do go back for a second watering, pretty much water will start coming out immediately and most of what goes in will come out.

I believe the main reason for going back though is to allow for better fertilizer+moisture retention, as you've already thoroughly wetted the mix and overcome any hydrophobic resistance to moisture. And you're not just dumping fertigation water with fertilizer you spent money on. If you have no trouble wetting the mix well and aren't worried about wasting small amounts of fertilizer, I wouldn't bother.

Nothing in your post sounded like a real problem, per se (correct me if I missed something), so I think you may just be finding 'problems' to worry about for no reason. As problems go, that's way better than, say, spider mites or a root-rotted Home Depot plant that you didn't repot for a year. :)
ynot
Original Author
10 years ago
hexalm
I appreciate your explanations and advice. Yeah, I suppose I am a worrier, especially the first time around. Just trying to 'get it right' and am discovering there's more than one way to do so. ;-)
I remember Al commenting on screening the Turface with only insect screen; otherwise, too much was lost. (I found that out the hard way.) In this first trial run,I was just trying to follow some very early comments recommending keeping all three components about the same size (1/8"-1/4"). After reading about the many different adjustments growers have made in their mix, I'm sure I'll be doing the same. But I wanted to use the basic mix first to actually see/experience the improved drainage.
BTW, along with all that excess Turface, I have loads and loads of ReptiBark left over: it was larger than 1/4 so I didn't use it. Can I except a decent mix if I use this smaller Turface and larger bark in my next mix? (I assume the smaller size Turface would increase water retention a bit; would this be offset by the larger size fir bark?)
Related Discussions
Complete Water Ban! Bermuda advise needed..
Q
Comments (6)
Don't worry about the grass it will survive and revive with wetter weather. Can't say the same for other grass types, shrubs, or trees. What do your cool season grass neighbors lawn look like? Dead I assume. You were spot on by quiting fertlizer apps during drought conditions when you cannot water, so just hold off for now. A little late to raise the cutting height now, but it will not hurt one thing if you do, and will do some good if a little rain comes your way. Raising the cutting height is a good idea as hotter dryer weather approaches to conserve soil moisture. However doing so after it has dried out, well...
...See More
Plant ID and advise needed please
Q
Comments (3)
It's definately Calathea, a type of roseo-picta. This species of Calathea needs a little more light, 'not direct south or west summer sun,' than other Calatheas. They also need humidity and fresh air. Soil should be watered thoroughly, but dried a little between waterings..less water is needed in winter. If you have a sprayer, mist daily, and offer a shower once week, Toni
...See More
Tile Expert Advise needed please help!!
Q
Comments (11)
Since there were no pictures available, here's what I did and I hope you don't mind. Just wanted to show you how the decorative border and the bullnose would look. Please ignore the size of the listello on the outside wall and the one on the tub side wall because they are not the same ones. Basically showing how I picture it to be - is this right and does it look right? I'm really sorry but I'm getting so stressed over this all over again. We hired a new contractor to replace the one who ran away with my money and this new guy says this set up will not look good. Either I'm making another mistake by hiring someone without experience or he just does not want to do the work. I'm doomed!!! Really need your help, PLEASE!! THANK YOU!
...See More
Well water quality problems....solution needed, please help.
Q
Comments (6)
Lurker-- Thanks for the help.....i think you helped me when I got my softener a few years back...hopefully you can help me fix my mom's water.... Retested the water..... results are still the same. Low Ph, High Iron. No bacteria. Let me ask a quick question upfront: Are there any health hazards to continue using this water as is? I understand the high iron can cause staining on surfaces (it already has) and the acid can ruin copper pipes (although most of her pipes are PVC or some sort of plastic), but can it cause health problems? Also, this condition of high iron is recent. Over the summer, the water from all taps started sputtering, seemingly cause of air in the lines. The plumber/well guy came out and tried the simple, cost effective solutiuons first. 1. Compressed air in the well to clean the well screen. She has a shallow well. He did this quite a bit. The screen was dirty and we thought that solved the problem....Nope. 2. Changed the pump, retention tank. Nope. 3. Then changed all the piping from the well to the retention tank. The problem in the end was a collapsed pipe that ran from the well to the tank. Could the repeated use of the compressed air down the well (in order to clean the well screen) caused some sort of change in the water, like an influx of iron? The iron (at least to the naked eye) has decreased somewhat since the summer, although it is still there as evidenced by the water test. A couple of months ago the iron would settle out of a cup of tap water within a week....now you put a cup of tap water on the counter and the orange iron sediment settles out in a few weeks. But the water still smells like a cup of loose change....the metal smell. She's had some estimates so far. One local guy came to the house, tested the water and said a "neutralizer and Conditioning system" would be about $1900. CAI online suggested a "chemical injection system with a downstream carbon filter." About $1000 for the equipment, plus the cost of labor for a plumber to install. Like I said in my original post, unfortunately, she doesn't have much disposable income right now. The quotes of $1000 plus caused her some sticker shock....and some serious agita. Pllus, on an aesthetic/practical side, the local guy said he would have to install it in her kitchen pantry (where the water heater and current sediment filter is) and it would cause her to have to remove almost all the storage/food shelving in there.... Ugh. I've gone on long enough. So does she have any options here??? Thanks again. If you need any other info, let me know. mike
...See More
ynot
Original Author
10 years ago
hexalm
oops! I just discovered that you had already responded to my question (see above) about using the larger bark on another thread of mine. I hadn't checked it since Thursday. My apologies.
I experimented with some pine bark(as opposed to ReptiBark) yesterday. Sifted out the small stuff ( 1/4"). There was a pitiful amount that fell into the desired range. Sooo ... I put the large left over pieces through a food processor (which I confiscated from the stuff that was ready to go to Goodwill): two quarts produced a very small handful of usable bark!! Man, I hate to spring for more Reptibark. Only 30% of what I buy at the local PetSmart is a usable size (and I have six more trees for six gallon containers. What ... me "worried"? Nah. :) :)

watering advise needed...please help

Comments (3)

hexalm

ynot
Original Author

Related Discussions

ynot
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

watering advise needed...please help

Comments (3)

hexalm

ynotOriginal Author

Related Discussions

ynotOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

ynot
Original Author

ynot
Original Author