I'm doing the same thing!! I wish people would comment because it's a big decision:). I've been researching gray's...pussywillow by SW, Benjamin Moore galveston gray (too dark for my taste but people say it's a good one), Harbor Gray...good luck to you

I would need to see the house.

My house is Shoji White. It's very soft and reads more creamy. I would say SW Alabaster is more of a soft but true white. My interior cabinets trim doors and ceilings are Alabaster. Alabaster Shoji I'd grab samples of both and go from there....

I am not sure of color but that awning needs to go use solar shades for light and heat control, what are all those wires around that window? IMO gray and Florida do not work in my head . Why not just match the white from the new gables and then please do some landscaping to bring this house to life . I would use this for inspiration since the front of the home is very MCM frond oor and garage door would be abig improvement too.Similar to the pic.