Floor finisher put poly over shellac & ruined my floors! How to fix?

26 days ago

last modified: 26 days ago

I am really at a loss. I am a first-time homeowner and after buying my house, I wanted to protect my investment so I decided to spend a considerable amount of money getting the floors a new buff and coat before I moved my stuff in. Less than a year later, the floors were bubbling and peeling up all over the place.

Setting aside the fact that the floor person refused to do anything about it (it was less than a week beyond his "one-year warranty" period), and all the steps it took for me to figure out what the cause was:

I believe that the previous owners applied amber shellac to all of the floors, and the floor person I hired did not identify this and foolishly applied a satin-finish polyurethane atop it, which is now causing the layers to separate.

<weeeeps> So what do I do now? I have three questions:

How do I fix the areas that are bubbling up and peeling? (See pics below as examples.)
How do I prevent this from happening everywhere else in my house?
I pulled out some old kitchen cabinets, so I have some areas of flooring I now need to patch in with this same wood to match. How do I match the existing color of the amber shellac, which now also has the look of the coat of satin polyurethane atop it, without getting myself into this same mess with the new boards? In other words, how do I reliably create a satin finish with an amber shellac?

Thanks in advance for your help! I gave been losing sleep over this! 😩

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

dani_m08
26 days ago
Please pull up the last comment I added on another thread earlier this afternoon. I explained how one year warranties do not cut off your recourse against a contractor/professional I'd rather not repeat the entire comment.

Basically, a one year warranty does not matter. If the floor refinisher is the expert - and should have tested the floor to determine what type of finish was used - then it's on him. I even know how to test wood finishes in order to tell if it's oil vs. poly vs. shellac.

You may have a negligence claim against your floor refinisher - I assume that not determining the type of finish before doing work on the floors (unless removing all of the prior finish) = negligence.

When there is litigation re: something like this, it's rarely based upon a breach of warranty - it's usually a breach of contract or negligence claim - and the one year warranty language in your contract has no bearing on limiting your recourse against your floor refinisher.
littleetoile thanked dani_m08
littleetoile
Original Author
26 days ago
Oh, wow, thank you! This is fascinatng and very helpful, @dani_m08! Just found your comment on the other post.

So sounds like that takes me down the path of legal action, which I'm not ruling out now that I've ready your very useful comment (thank you again!), but unfortunately in the meantime it doesn't address the three things I listed that I'm trying to figure out, so would be great to see if anyone has ideas for those elements! For example, to redo the floors completely would require me moving out of all three floors of my house, which sounds like a nightmare I'd like to avoid if possible! At the very least, would be great to figure out how to repair the worst damaged areas, and match the patches I'm putting in the kitchen.
Related Discussions
How many coats of Waterlox needed over Shellac
Q
Comments (5)
Flint2013, I did call Waterlox, they were not at all helpful or friendly. Their phone rep kept telling me that I should use waterlox as the sealant and all layers. When pressed why his response was only that it is "the best sealer on the market." My attempts to convince him that I wanted to use garnet shellac because I like the look didn't phaze him. Then he was trying to convince me that waterlox anchors into the wood fibers creating a better seal through all the coats. Not exactly an accurate description of how oil based varnishes work. I tried pressing him on how well the 1mm dried coat performs on a purely resin base, but all I got was marketing. Not helpful to what I actually wanted or was looking for. If I hadn't already started with the waterlox, I would have considered returning it and using Bona Traffic based on how demeaning the guy was on the phone.
...See More
Learn from my mistake: oven cleaner ruined my floor
Q
Comments (9)
Oh, I am so sorry. That happened to me, too, long ago, but we lived with the floor. I always put a lot of newspaper down, but one time I didn't. So thoughtful of you to post this. On a related vein, our 50 year old oven is not self cleaning. And for the 33 years we've been in this house, I've been spraying oven cleaner. BEWARE. I have bad lungs now, and in my heart of hearts, I know (or feel) it was all those years of oven cleaner fumes. In later years, I had the brains to leave the room, but still the fumes were there when I sprayed the oven. If I could smell it so strongly, and it made me cough, I think it was penetrating my lung tissue. I think my throat was affected also. I have a couple of diagnoses, take meds, activities are limited, and see a pulmonologist. I've given it much thought, and oven cleaner always comes up as the culprit. Other cleaning sprays may have contributed, but oven cleaner was so strong and it's such a toxic burn. I should have worn a paper mask. A stupid clean oven was my priority and until the last few years, I was stupidly proud that my old oven still sparkled. Please friends, learn from me. It's your wood floor, can be fixed or replaced, and your lungs, which cannot. So sorry.
...See More
Shellac over hardwood floor? LVP over hardwood?
Q
Comments (0)
I am thinking about using a shellac finish and sealer on this hardwood, which will be the floor for a kid's room. This Bullseye traditional finish and sealer product from Zinsser seems widely used and well liked: https://www.lowes.com/pd/Zinsser-Bulls-Eye-Clear-Shellac-Actual-Net-Contents-32-fl-oz/3449840 This particular product says it is clear, and I think there is an amber tinted version. Can shellac be applied without problems to hardwood? I believe I could put poly on top of the shellac and be done. Is this right? Any tips or warnings? There is also this Sealcoat by Zinsser, which does not appear to be shellac based. https://www.amazon.com/Rust-Oleum-Zinsser-854-Sealcoat-Universal/dp/B000C02BXW/ref=sr_1_3_mod_primary_new?dchild=1&keywords=zinsser+shellac+sealer&qid=1610393849&sbo=RZvfv%2F%2FHxDF%2BO5021pAnSA%3D%3D&sr=8-3 Would the Sealcoat be a better option to just put over the hardwood? I have read elsewhere that shellac can be applied over poly, which is good since I don't know what is on the existing floor. Other places say shellac could be sanded after application, so when we have a chance to completely sand and refinish this floor, I would probably want to do this. Does this sound like an acceptable temporary fix, or is there something I should consider before proceeding? Would shellac ruin or damage the hardwood. I am also thinking about LVP, but I am concerned this hardwood floor is not flat enough for that. I understand the subfloor for LVP must be 3/16" within about a 1 foot diameter to work. Any ideas about this? Is there a way eyeball this floor to determine whether click LVP could be put down? Thanks!
...See More
How do I fix over-bleached red oak floors?!
Q
Comments (6)
classychic563 I realize this is an old thread but I was out of town and just checking old posts now. I saw that you're thinking of getting stain pens? as in those felt tip markers? I hope you didn't. they won't penetrate the top coat, the area is too large and besides, those pens are total crap. I can never get them to match, even for tiny scratches. don't think about topping it with gel stain either. it will never look right. I am a somewhat experimental DIYer willing to take some risks, and even I would not attempt to tackle this project myself, not on fresh new floors. you had a question on where to find such good, artistic woodworkers -- I don't know. here's where I would try: google "wood restoration" in your area and ask them if they do floors and if they don't, ask them for referrals. vet them carefully. ask to see before and after pics of their work (specifically, pics of spot repair where they did not redo the entire area). ask friends and neighbors for personal recommendations too.
...See More
cat_ky
26 days ago
You need a flooring person (a reputable knowledgeable one) to match in your floors and make sure its an identical species as to what you have there already and make sure the patches are put in, so they are staggered and not just square type patches.
littleetoile thanked cat_ky
littleetoile
Original Author
26 days ago
@cat_ky I had one room with carpet already ripped out and the flooring replaced by reputable experts. I know the wood type, so thankfully I am covered there, but even the experts weren't able to exactly match the color because at the time I hadn’t figured out that the original floors had amber shellac on them, and that’s what provided the color. Now that I know that, I just need to figure out the answers to the questions I posted here! ^^^
PRO
G & S Floor Service
26 days ago
You can manually scrape the flaking finish off with a plastic scraper. Then do a deep cleaning to remove contaminants before buffing or lightly sanding for a recoat.

Floor finisher put poly over shellac & ruined my floors! How to fix?

Comments (5)

dani_m08

littleetoile
Original Author

Related Discussions

cat_ky

littleetoile
Original Author

G & S Floor Service

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Floor finisher put poly over shellac & ruined my floors! How to fix?

Comments (5)

dani_m08

littleetoileOriginal Author

Related Discussions

cat_ky

littleetoileOriginal Author

G & S Floor Service

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

littleetoile
Original Author

littleetoile
Original Author