I think if you used darker pillows on the sofa and a bigger tray on the ottoman the colorful rug would work very well. Try transferring your camel-brown pillows to the gray chairs after you've tried darker fabrics on the sofa.

Just some examples of colors I would bring onto the sofa and chairs

I think the new rug looks very nice, and wouldn’t change a thing! Nicely done!

(I also think you could bring some small touches of blues into the room for color, especially some blue pottery, but also some pillow patterns

I'm not suggesting ALL these pillows at once -- just saying layering in a few darker shades here and there and a touch of blue will create depth

I like the new rug.

The art above the sofa might look better with the rug if the mat was changed from green to ivory or white.

The two small art works to the left of the hutch might look better if the frames were changed from white to wood or something else that coordinates with the other wall frames.

Edit - a different cocktail table/ottoman or using a larger tray on your ottoman as suggested by @mytwo cents would have a big impact.

Haha. See discussion on neutrals.

I don’t think if that rug as colorful. I see it as a pattern of neutrals. It makes the room much more interesting than the solid rug, so I much preferred it to the solid no matter what you else you swap around.

One if the best ways to do this is with art , something that you truly like, is even generally in your colors, but, being art, can go off the rails a bit with extra colors or an unusual theme. Something really interesting to look at and not to motel- worthy.

Or books, but only if you read and ones you love. Or some pottery or plant pots in a different color. The color (s) should be one you love ( well, hard to control that with REAL books, not ordering a set if “ blue books online. Although since I had a large collection, I was amazed at how many of the actual bindings “ went” with much decor, and I could organize/curate if I wanted to) and is ok to be at home with your other colors in some ways—so fine to say, fluorescent pink isn’t the one, but maybe purple , red, some types of orange.

I'd rather use cheap pillows from Target than what gets called ''árt'' from the crank out the blobs splotch vendors or in posts from this site.

Of course put anything into your house you love and if you want to read a book don't hide it. And don't rule out flourescent pink.

That rug is far from "too colorful", and works well in your room.

The mat on the artwork above the sofa is perfect.

I agree with choosing a couple of pillows, or a perhaps a throw, that brings something other than gray/beige/cream. The room is very well coordinated now, and the golden tan pillows are good - but you just need a bit more contrast to perk it up a notch. How about dark blue to flow with the blue-ish gray of the chairs, or a green that flows with the matting on the picture (I can't really see the rug colors well enough to tell if there is blue or green in it.)

The new rug is nice. Try adding a black pillow or two on your sofa, and see if you like the rug better than. Could be two solid black pillows, or you could even mix it up - and use a solid black and a black patterned pillow, such as a stripe, etc.

I just scribbled here on this visual - but hopefully it gives you the general idea.

I would try darker blue pillows on the sofa to pull the blues out of the rugs and tie the room together. Overall, I love the rug though!

I like the suggestions of adding black and larger artwork. The starker contrasts adds dimension to the room.

This would be a bold and beautiful change.

The new rug is perfect and some of the suggestions about larger art are right on. It’s a very nice room!

Perfect rug now .

What do you guys think about this new find?

I like that black rug, too, but would get a sample before ordering a big one.

It does have a bit of a faded look to it, which may or may not matter. This is a good pic of it (in good lighting) in a reviewer’s room:

ETA: Just making sure I have the right one, it is this one?

https://incrediblerugsanddecor.com/products/karastan-estate-somersby-black-area-rug

ohhhh it looks way more faded our doesn't it? hmmm Thank you Jilly!

I do like the black rug - I have one that is similar in colors (not so much in pattern) that I used on my kitchen floor. It is a flat weave, all wool, so cleaned beautifully.

I don't mind that it appears slightly faded - that's a softer look

You just need that larger artwork - with a black or very dark color frame- for it all to be pulled together nicely. Perhaps you could also find a less bulky & smaller end table to replace the one that is in front of the bookcase (on the right) so that area doesn't seem so crowded.

I don't know where you live, but maybe the original pick for the summer and the black for the winter.

Do you like the art ? There are really no rules about how big art has to be over a sofa, etc.... But if you want bigger, you can use a larger mat and larger frame. Or even better - flank the art with some wall sconces. You could use plug in sconces; but there is also a way to adapt hardwire sconces so that you don’t need to have the electric setup.

I like both of your rug choices. I just used another rug above to show a different look. I love this rug. Every picture i see shows a pink cast - at least on my phone. And I actually like the pink! But all the descriptions say that the rug is camel and grey. Pretty much sold out at Rugs Direct, but here it is on eBay - and also available from Bed Bath & Beyond, Armand Flooring and maybe some other vendors have it, too.

Adapting sconces with puck lights:

https://ourhammockhouse.com/how-to-make-your-own-wireless-sconces/#:~:text=Essentially%2C%20you%20buy%20a%20normal,Voila!

Just a thought, but I would find an area rug that has the same accent colors in it as the matt of the picture over the couch or even an area rug that is predominantly that color. I think you need some accent colors in the room and the first rug you displayed just kind of blends in with the rest of the room decor. You could also add accent pillows on the sofa the same color as the matt or even get a nice throw in that shade. I would also consider painting the shelving you have in the room a nice sage or the color of the matt. Would look really nice.

I am surprised nobody mentioned furniture placement. you should not put evething alone the wall. Also cabinets need they own areas not to be mixed with seating area. if you will provide room size and layout it will be easier to figure it out.

sofikbr I struggle with the furniture placement. It's a small room with too many entries or closets.

This placement was done by a salesperson that sold me the couch. The bookcases are vintage Scandinavian teak 35" wide I've had since the early 70's and the black walnut end tables are vintage also. Both sentimental to me.

The door at the top of the room is the entry from the front living room. Counter clockwise is a closet, entry into the laundry, then a set of french doors to the backyard. The left wall has the companion teak console 41" wide with a TV on top. I'd love it someone could come up with a better alternative. Thanks for your input.