Plan Review Please
jenswrens
7 months ago
last modified: 7 months ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (14)
jenswrens
7 months agoRelated Discussions
Floor plan review please - Almost finalized - Yippee!
Comments (22)Hi everyone. Momto3 - This floor plan is indeed beautiful, as the pictures of the finished house show. And some of the suggestions given by others were little nuggets of gold to keep in mind! MyDreamHome, I love your laundry room - I have not come across one that is in that small a space and yet works as efficiently as yours does. The garbage bins for laundry are a wonderful idea! I too fold in my laundry in the laundry room as soon as items come out of the dryer - otherwise they need ironing, and I am not into that (unless it is part of my quilting - that is a different story). For those many people who were enquiring about how to make this large house smaller (I believe it is 5,000 square feet, give or take a couple hundred): some great suggestions were made about making some rooms smaller (ie - do you need a 30+ by 15+ playroom, and a 16+ by 14+ breakfast area? We would all like it, but...). However I have two other suggestions as well. This house, built as a single-story home, has a huge footprint. That means a huge basement or slab, and a huge roof surface. Furthermore, the roof will be quite high, simply because of the area it has to cover. So... You could consider moving some or all of the bedrooms upstairs, and while this may not reduce the square footage of the home, it will reduce the cost of building significantly (the cost per square foot will go down significantly because this area does not need its own basement/slab or roof). For example, if you put 1500 square feet of bedrooms/bathrooms upstairs, you will reduce your footprint and roof area by that amount - the size of a small-mid size house! With some interesting jut-outs, dormers and some sloped ceilings, you can make a very interesting as well as a light and airy second floor. In fact, a friend of mine did just this - they planned a large single-level house, and the architect suggested that with almost no changes to the roof other than a couple of dormers, they could put in a large master suite and two additional bedrooms and another bath on the second floor. They agreed, and then re-envisioned the main floor to keep the footprint the same size as before, giving them about 1/3 more living space for very little extra money. Just one word of warning: it will impact the layout of the roof trusses, and perhaps even the type of truss used, so that you have full use of the available height. So include this in the plan before you start building - even if you plan to finish the space later (another advantage of reducing the footprint - you can finish off the other levels later if money is an issue and yet you expect your family to grow). Similarly if you build the house with a basement and your land has just a bit of a slope to it, with some forethought you can have a walk-out basement with large windows and French or sliding doors...or at worst, finished rooms with large windows. Then you can put some of the bedrooms and the play room downstairs and still have them bright and airy. If you live where you have to do a basement anyway, you double the size of your (single story) house by utilizing the basement. A current trend in my area is for builders to use 9-10 foot ceilings in the basement to ensure that the area is not claustrophobic (and it allows for bigger windows if the house sits a bit higher). Often with a bit of landscape planning, enough of a slope can be created when the footings and the basement are laid down. Again here, if you plan to finish the basement (now or later), give it some thought so that you do not limit your options when you do finish it. For example, you may want to use longer or different types of beams to support the main floor to reduce the number of posts in the basement. And you may want to ensure that your posts are no closer that 12 or 15 feet apart - so that you likely won't have a post in the middle of where you would like to have a bedroom. It is also important to have a plan so that you can make the best use of windows, and put larger ones in if possible. Every bedroom must have an egress window (which is not very big), so don't plan on sticking a bedroom in the front of the house unless you are prepared to have windows at the front, etc. Plumbing is easier if it is roughed in now as well, although if you change your mind, it can be moved easily enough (but it costs $$). Has anyone tried either of these options? I would draw out a sample, but I don't currently have a couple of free hours - sorry... PS - sorry for the length of this post......See MorePlan Review Please
Comments (15)I agree that this is a very complicated, expensive floorplan -- at a glance, I think you have no chance of building this for $125/sf. You can lose the bump-outs and reduce the cost significantly -- with no loss of quality. Your pantry and the master closet near the bedroom both have the same problem: They're designed so that they require walk-in space . . . yet they give you storage only on two sides. If you dedicate the walk-in space, you should allot enough width for storage on three sides -- this is just getting the most for your money! I agree that you might want to consider a larger dining room. Since it must also function as a hallway to the kitchen, you're going to be limited to a small table. Of course, you might decide that you're totally cool with that: We are limiting ourselves to a small table, but we've carefully considered that choice, and our circumstances aren't particularly typical. Too many doors in the "nicer" master's vestibule. I'd lose the small closet . . . and instead make it a set of built-in bookcases. Too many doors in the master bathroom too, though most people would disagree with that. I'd consider a sliding door in the master bedroom. It's more convenient to leave open at night (because it doesn't block one person's ability to walk around the bed). If you didn't have this back door, I'd be concerned about you getting large furniture into the bedroom -- the small hallway requires a sharp turn. So don't lose that back door! Definitely plan on good insulation between the master bedroom and the great room. This isn't an expensive item, but if you ever end up sharing this house, it'll mean a light sleeper won't be annoyed with someone else watching TV or listening to music in the great room. I definitely think you'd be wise to add a closet to the den so that you could call it a bedroom -- sure, you don't want it now, but it'll allow for versatility in the future. If you don't want it to LOOK like a closet, you could leave off the door and make it an entertainment system /shelves . . . and then if it's ever needed, it'd cost very little to simply add a door. Of course, that leaves you without a convenient bathroom for that bedroom. I'd consider moving the den /possible future bedroom over to the garage entrance area (so it can share the other bath) and bring the laundry over to the master bedroom. I'd lose the little end cabinet in the laundry room. Those corner cabinets are expensive, and they're inefficient. You'll have just as much storage if you go with a simple, straight cabinet for the laundry. This isn't a place to splurge on expensive cabinetry. You're a single guy . . . and your plan includes three toilets. Two would be planning for "future expansion"; three is overboard. I'd consider losing the powder room and opening the secondary bathroom to the hall so that it can serve as guest bath AND powder room. I like the kitchen. And its location. Good windows -- you'll have great views of the lake. The foyer is very, very generous. Not really where I'd "spend" square footage....See MoreHouse plan review please?
Comments (38)Hi spammie, I read your comments this morning on the plane but decided to wait till I was back in FL to respond. I’m interested in your comment that it seems cramped, since as shown (without large walkout lower level) this is basically a 1400 sq. ft. one-bedroom house – and I’m interested in making it smaller! It's not the size but how the rooms are laid out. The one that really feels tight is the living room. I just can't see more than a few people at a time there. Your dining room Powder room: The entry is 8’ wide with a drop/landing zone to the right (on the diagram) so I’m thinking the powder room won’t be the focus when you come in although changing the front door swing would help; not sure where else to put it that doesn’t open directly into a room. Yes it is probably the only place. Flip the door swing. The stairs from the lake will lead to the lower level walkout before turning & heading up to the main level, so I’d be surprised if anybody would bypass the lower level bathroom & go all the way upstairs to get to the powder room. You have everyone coming back from the lake and two people have to go NOW. Of course that would be a problem even in my house. However you're assuming everyone will come into the house from the ground floor and not climb the outside stairs. I never assume anything because when I assume, my assumptions are usually wrong. LOL. Living room: Yes, there will be large windows & yes as shown seems too small for enough furniture for more than 5 people. I just flipped the furniture in my mockup to look towards the view. Notice now how it's encroaching into your "hallway"? This is the problem there. Your living room needs to be larger. Mudroom/laundry room/storage: When we build garage it will be the mudroom and yes, when coming up the stairs you’d see the door. We plan tall storage cabinets along one wall of laundry room + tall pantry cabinet(s) in kitchen. When I come up a stairs, I like to see something that wants me to climb further. While your landing will be lovely, your entrance to the main floor will not be if all you're seeing is a door. Kitchen: We haven’t started kitchen design details yet so yes, it will need work & L-shape is under consideration. I’d appreciate your thoughts on why that would work better! See my very rough idea although I can also see the sink staying on the perimeter. A U shaped kitchen means you'll have two corner cabinets or two dead corner cabinets. Corners are just not as efficient, even when you do like I did for my one corner and make it corner drawers. I personally would rather have a longer island with storage drawers in the island than wasted corners. Bedroom closet: We’re considering built-in wardrobes as shown along right wall. The problem with that is now you've basically eliminated windows on two walls. Yes I realize that is not the pretty view but even high windows are better for letting in light and cross ventilation. One other thought. Are you and Hubby on the same wake/sleep schedule? If not, will the bathroom and closets opening/closing be a problem? Also what happens when one of you need to use the facilities in the middle of the night, goes into the bathroom and turns on the light? Two other things. I'm not a fan of walking into a bedroom on the side of the bed and I'm not a fan of one partner having to walk clear around the bed in the middle of the night to use the bathroom....See MoreFloor plan review please!
Comments (18)Overall pretty good, some little bugs to work out. I would agree with the garage depth, 19'-2" is shallow, requiring you to shimmy by only one end of a family-sized car. So if you want to empty the trunk, you have to pull forward all the way to wall. Then next day you have to walk around the back of car because the front is blocked. The Master bath looks like it can be bumped in line with the other wall to gain another foot or so. I like to align things. Did the same by the outdoor area with the column and solid Living wall. Also the same with the Dining window. The circulation to outside is only at the Living? Is there access thru the Dining Room requiring more space around the seating? The entrance vestibule to the Master, although you don't want it too prominent, looks very tight. The stair is dynamic, however continuing the handrails down on each side might kill that dynamicy (new word I made up) of the waterfall stairs. The Powder Room, is a changing seat/counter/enough room for that important to have? There are rectangles shown in the Foyer, Living, Master bed, Master vestibule, and Master hall. Are these representing rugs? If they are representing tray ceilings, it would be nice if they aligned with things and considered the demarcation of space below them. Pool equipment and storage is good to plan for now, as that side of house is all windows. Edit: forgot South Florida has exterior doors swinging out...See Morejenswrens
7 months agoMrs. S
7 months agojenswrens
7 months agojenswrens
7 months agomillworkman
7 months agocourse411
7 months agoHU-918119203
7 months agolast modified: 7 months agojenswrens
6 months agolast modified: 6 months ago
Related Stories
ARCHITECTUREThink Like an Architect: How to Pass a Design Review
Up the chances a review board will approve your design with these time-tested strategies from an architect
Full StoryARCHITECTUREOpen Plan Not Your Thing? Try ‘Broken Plan’
This modern spin on open-plan living offers greater privacy while retaining a sense of flow
Full StoryGARDENING AND LANDSCAPINGNo Fall Guys, Please: Ideas for Lighting Your Outdoor Steps
Safety and beauty go hand in hand when you light landscape stairways and steps with just the right mix
Full StoryDESIGN PRACTICEDesign Practice: The Year in Review
Look back, then look ahead to make sure you’re keeping your business on track
Full StoryPRODUCT PICKSGuest Picks: 21 Rave-Review Bookcases
Flip through this roundup of stylish shelves to find just the right book, toy and knickknack storage and display for you
Full StoryBATHROOM DESIGNUpload of the Day: A Mini Fridge in the Master Bathroom? Yes, Please!
Talk about convenience. Better yet, get it yourself after being inspired by this Texas bath
Full StoryHOME OFFICESQuiet, Please! How to Cut Noise Pollution at Home
Leaf blowers, trucks or noisy neighbors driving you berserk? These sound-reduction strategies can help you hush things up
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDESPlease Touch: Texture Makes Rooms Spring to Life
Great design stimulates all the senses, including touch. Check out these great uses of texture, then let your fingers do the walking
Full Story
Mark Bischak, Architect