Open Plan Not Your Thing? Try ‘Broken Plan’
This modern spin on open-plan living offers greater privacy while retaining a sense of flow
Cheryl F
February 28, 2016
Houzz Contributor. I'm a London-based journalist with years of experience writing for the UK's top interiors titles. I love shopping for quirky accessories, have a passion for rummaging through vintage stores and I'm ever-hopeful of finding that elusive perfect paint shade.
Houzz Contributor. I'm a London-based journalist with years of experience writing... More
Open-plan living has been one of the biggest trends in our homes in recent decades. Indeed, knocking down walls can create a sense of space, light, sociability and fluidity that many of us love. But open-plan layouts can reduce privacy and quiet spots, as well as useful walls against which to place furniture. You may also struggle to ignore that pile of dishes you see out of the corner of your eye during TV binges on the sofa (at least with a wall between you and the kitchen, you can pretend it isn’t there). Welcome, then, to a slow, steady move toward a compromise: broken-plan living. But what exactly is it?
Broken-plan means keeping the things you love about open-plan, but also letting your rooms retain an element of privacy and specific use.
By dividing your overall space more subtly — using half walls, smart shelving, split levels, internal windows and other clever tricks — and creating breakout zones for privacy and relaxing, it’s perfectly possible to hold on to an appealing sense of light and space, but also to escape distraction from the loved ones you live with (and the undone cleaning) when the mood takes you.
By dividing your overall space more subtly — using half walls, smart shelving, split levels, internal windows and other clever tricks — and creating breakout zones for privacy and relaxing, it’s perfectly possible to hold on to an appealing sense of light and space, but also to escape distraction from the loved ones you live with (and the undone cleaning) when the mood takes you.
Preserve the Light
One constant conundrum with non-open-plan living is how to preserve that lovely sense of flowing light. If you’re not careful, once you introduce walls and closed doors, you can be left with a series of dark, too-small rooms.
Broken-plan living offers a compromise. In this space, an open shelving unit allows light to filter through and helps to retain a sense of connectivity and flow between the adjacent rooms. An extra-wide door opening similarly adds to the broken-plan design.
One constant conundrum with non-open-plan living is how to preserve that lovely sense of flowing light. If you’re not careful, once you introduce walls and closed doors, you can be left with a series of dark, too-small rooms.
Broken-plan living offers a compromise. In this space, an open shelving unit allows light to filter through and helps to retain a sense of connectivity and flow between the adjacent rooms. An extra-wide door opening similarly adds to the broken-plan design.
Another way to boost light is to install internal windows. This is especially appropriate for a home office, such as the one in this modern home, since it provides quietness without cutting you off entirely from what’s going on in the rest of the living area.
See the rest of this broken-plan home
See the rest of this broken-plan home
If going radically open-plan means getting rid of narrow doorways and walls altogether, in a broken-plan scheme, a wide opening can be an effective compromise.
Go to Another Level
This impressive space makes use of different floor levels and different ceiling heights, which psychologically helps to increase the distance between separate zones designed for different functions.
The chic kitchen is physically kept separate from the cozy TV den thanks to the dividing wall, but both areas naturally flow (but don’t bleed) into the large dining and lounging area. The result is a space where a large family can easily be “alone together.”
This impressive space makes use of different floor levels and different ceiling heights, which psychologically helps to increase the distance between separate zones designed for different functions.
The chic kitchen is physically kept separate from the cozy TV den thanks to the dividing wall, but both areas naturally flow (but don’t bleed) into the large dining and lounging area. The result is a space where a large family can easily be “alone together.”
A large, all-in-one downstairs room, encompassing cooking, dining and living zones, has become a popular layout in many homes. But while the result can look spacious, it may mean the living spaces never feel truly relaxing, because they’re so connected to the bustle of the kitchen.
However, small tricks, such as having two or three steps between areas, can be all it takes to provide that crucial mental and physical divide. In this open-plan space, retaining a slab of wall on one side of the wide bookcase also subtly helps the living area to feel more self-contained.
However, small tricks, such as having two or three steps between areas, can be all it takes to provide that crucial mental and physical divide. In this open-plan space, retaining a slab of wall on one side of the wide bookcase also subtly helps the living area to feel more self-contained.
This is another chic example of a split level helping to divide a dining room and living area. Here, an unusual balustrade also helps to keep things separate, along with different types of flooring and shades of wallcovering.
If you have the room height, and an architect or a builder to help you plan properly, inserting a loft can be a smart way to fit another living area into what could otherwise be dead space.
In this abode, the lower-level lounging area is elegant and more formal, while the narrow upper-level seating area is reserved for watching TV and storing books and DVDs. The glass balustrade helps to create a flow between the two distinct areas and keeps the upper level as light as possible.
In this abode, the lower-level lounging area is elegant and more formal, while the narrow upper-level seating area is reserved for watching TV and storing books and DVDs. The glass balustrade helps to create a flow between the two distinct areas and keeps the upper level as light as possible.
This home study is separated from the main living area by three short steps and a half-height glass wall. These create a clear boundary that stops spillover between one function and another. Having different textures — the exposed brick wall, in this case — and different flooring (wood versus tiles) further adds to the demarcation.
Before planning your broken-plan space, think about what you miss in your current home and what works where; not everyone wants a study downstairs, for example.
Before planning your broken-plan space, think about what you miss in your current home and what works where; not everyone wants a study downstairs, for example.
Use Partial Walls
Many of us hanker after more space in our homes but, ironically, one problem with larger open-plan living spaces is that they can end up feeling too big — and consequently not always cozy.
Dividing a large room into smaller lounging zones could be an option if this is your issue. Here, a well-placed TV and fireplace wall does the trick.
Many of us hanker after more space in our homes but, ironically, one problem with larger open-plan living spaces is that they can end up feeling too big — and consequently not always cozy.
Dividing a large room into smaller lounging zones could be an option if this is your issue. Here, a well-placed TV and fireplace wall does the trick.
If you’re lucky enough to have a spacious bedroom, a broken-plan design can help you retain a separate area for lounging, studying or even crafting or doing other hobbies. It’s also a good potential trick for compact studio flats, where the sleeping and living spaces are one.
Here, a storage wall complete with integrated fireplace shields the living area, but the light from the large windows and the lovely view can still be appreciated.
Here, a storage wall complete with integrated fireplace shields the living area, but the light from the large windows and the lovely view can still be appreciated.
It might seem a bit old-school, but a half wall between a dining area and a kitchen creates a visual block from the chaos of cooking when you’re enjoying a meal with family or guests.
It also means you can keep the conversation going, rather than feeling as if you’re marooned in another room while you cook and they relax (or vice versa).
It also means you can keep the conversation going, rather than feeling as if you’re marooned in another room while you cook and they relax (or vice versa).
Sliding doors give the residents of this house control over the room’s openness. The tall chimney effectively interrupts the long living space and helps each room retain a sense of privacy, while simultaneously allowing a sneaky view through either side.
More
Touches of Cozy for Open-Plan Designs
8 Architectural Tricks to Enhance an Open-Plan Space
More
Touches of Cozy for Open-Plan Designs
8 Architectural Tricks to Enhance an Open-Plan Space
Related Stories
Modern Architecture
Tour Richard Neutra’s Iconic Kaufmann Desert House Gardens
By Colin Flavin
The well-known but rarely seen symbol of desert modern architecture opened its doors for Palm Springs Modernism Week
Full Story
Pritzker Prize Winners
Japan’s Riken Yamamoto Wins the 2024 Pritzker Architecture Prize
The architect is known for creating indoor-outdoor homes and buildings that foster a strong sense of community
Full Story
Working With Pros
6 Reasons to Hire a Home Design Professional
Doing a construction project without an architect, a designer or a design-build pro can be a missed opportunity
Full Story
Modern Architecture
How to Improve the Comfort of Your Midcentury Modern Home
By Colin Flavin
You can maintain the era’s signature style in your home while improving its thermal performance
Full Story
Green Building
The Passive House: What It Is and Why You Should Care
If you don’t understand passive design, you could be throwing money out the window
Full Story
Modern Architecture
Tour the House of Tomorrow and Elvis Presley’s Honeymoon Hideaway
By Colin Flavin
The recently renovated Palm Springs home returns to glory with spectacular geometry and indoor-outdoor connections
Full Story
Earth Day
12 Pros Share the Top Sustainable Features They’re Using
Design, building and landscape pros discuss the ways they’re creating comfortable, efficient and eco-friendly homes
Full Story
Bedrooms
7 Tips for Designing Your Bedroom
Learn how to think about light, layout, circulation and views to get the bedroom of your dreams
Full Story
Pritzker Prize Winners
Sir David Alan Chipperfield Wins the 2023 Pritzker Prize
The English architect is known for honoring history and culture while creating timeless modern design
Full Story
Working With Pros
10 Times to Hire an Architect
These pros help solve design problems, manage projects, build smarter homes and much more
Full Story
Agree about the dysfunctionality of split levels but like the idea of some divide between some rooms.
Not sur eif right area to ask this but here goes: We are thinking of doing a new build in the next few years and just wanted to ask a quick question on the design of an open plans space (not sure if an easy answer though): what do I have to keep in mind when thinking about the span of the open space? is there a maximum distance I can use before a wall support is required.? We were thinking of having a separate lounge/living area , adjacent to a dining are and a separate kitchen area (separate to dining by either sliding stackers or bifolds so if want a cinema experience or to keep warmth in the living area we can have them closed, but if big family function we an have them open and have a bit more space for dining and mingling. Worried that if when doors open then no support?
Purchased a home that uses partial walls as dividers between living, dining and a flex space. They don't go all the way to the ceiling and have space on either side to walk around. i really love that the house feels very open and has good light and sight lines but that I have these "floating" walls to provide some separation, a place for some art and a place to anchor some furniture. The center of the house also features a large fireplace that provides division/privacy from the entry. Now I have a term for my house! A broken plan.