Those pictures are way too close to be useful to us. Back up and show us the whole house - 99.9% of the people who see your house will see it from the street, not from 6” or 6’ away.

Front door faces south

Nice home but those shutters are not appropriate on your windows. The shutters on the 5-window wall look especially out of place. Toss them all.

Navy sounds like a good color for your door.

SW Peppercorn could be nice - since you have a black storm door I would want the door color to blend a bit - navy would also be nice

I’ve heard keep/toss shutters. Which ones exactly do I get rid of @littlebug?
Front pair of matching windows left of front door have window boxes under them that are temp removed.

la_la_Girl existing colors on shutters/door (including storms) are BM Black Forest Green. Thx

Get rid of all of the ones that don’t meet this criteria:

1. When the shutters are closed, whether they actually close or not, they should look as though they would cover the window. Shutters rarely belong on multiple windows.

2. They’re of a material sturdy enough to actually provide protection (i.e. probably not vinyl). That’s the purpose of shutters.

I don’t think I’d go with gray.
I think black or navy for everything is more appropriate

Shutters, whether decorative or functional, should each be half the window’s width. Definitely not on your large, 5-section window. This might be helpful.

https://www.lifeofanarchitect.com/residential-architecture-101-shutters/

I think navy or black would be great with Revere Pewter and White Dove.