If that is brick or stone next to the front door I recommend choosing a color from it for the siding, keeping in mind your roof color as well. Post a closer up picture of the door so people can see what it looks like.

Looks like roof is grey? I would explore a white that leans grey like SW Shoji or a green that leans grey like these

I would choose SW Inkwell

I think I'd use the bark on the tree in your front yard for color inspiration. Something along these lines.

Yours is a contemporary home and IMO would look best in an earth tone color. The blue doesn't do a thing for the other finishes on your home.

BTW if the house is wood then NO PAINT. A stain should be used even if it has to be full opaque stain.

Replace the light pole with a bollard like like you see below. Casts light on the driveway surface.

Here is a close up of the front door area and roof. The roof is greyish black.

We didn’t pick the blue and now that we have the inside done are moving to the exterior.

We agree more earth tones.

Any suggestions for doing something other than painting/staining it all one color?

@PaulF what program are you using to change the color on the house?

Photoshop

Wow, your photoshop mask skills are really impressive!

Thanks! Bollards?

What does Bollards mean?

I wish we could change the light out but it’s standard for the neighborhood HOA.

@midcentura Ha, Beverly suggest Brian change his outdoor light to short squat lights called bollards. I was just showing him what that might look like. Damn HOA!

Bollards and brown make it look like a visitor center at a national park. :)

I think the others all have the right idea on picking earthy colors from your stone. When you are done, plant a tree in front of the garage.

Funny, but the brown is from the stone. Not my favorite... I like the bark grey tones.

Remove the window boxes from underneath the upstairs windows. They are a water problem waiting to happen. Landscaping will be your friend after you finish painting. I like the brown/gray tones from your stonework. Love your front door, although it might require refinishing to bring back the depth of color in the wood. Lovely home!