How to improve the heating of an old house (Ottawa)

2 years ago

Hi!

I'm currently living in a century-old house in Ottawa, with central air heating (heat pump + gas furnace when temperatures starts going below -20°C). The house has one basement, ground floor + 1st floor, each around 30/40 m². My problem is there's only one air vent blowing on the ground floor and when winter hits, it gets pretty cold: that air vent is in the ceiling, right by the stairs, and there's a beam between that vent and the rest of the living room. All of that sounds very much not ideal. Same deal in the basement, only one air vent at the bottom of a wall. This is less of an issue, though, the basement isn't a space we use a lot.

I'm going to have my kitchen remodeled in the next months, going from a walled-off kitchen to an open one, which will help with heating the kitchen at least and could be the right moment to adjust the heating situation.

How can I improve the heating of that floor? I don't particularly like forced-air heating (dry air, stratification, draughts, noise of blower are the issues I can think of off the top of my head).

I was looking at wall-mounted inertia radiators (something like this (https://www.confort-sauter.com/Chauffage/radiateur/hekla-horizontal-radiateur-electrique-autonome-connecte-et-lumineux-a-inertie-double-corps-de-chauffe-fonte-facade-chauffante/hekla-horizontal-blanc-2000w#id-filtre-0) or this (https://www.mazdaenergy.fr/radiateur-Inertie-ceramique-resistance-surfacique-PALACY)), but I haven't had much luck finding that in Canada.

I also have a noticeable temperature difference between ground floor and first floor, with heat moving up, which is an issue because with telework one person is working upstairs and one on the ground floor, so it's hard to find the right balance.

Any advice on how could I improve the situation?

Thanks!

Featured Answer

fsq4cw

2 years ago

I would advise exploring either an Air-to-Water heat pump or even better a Geothermal Liquid-to-Water heat pump for heating and cooling with domestic hot water; no gas, no ductwork.

Hydronic distribution could be hydronic in-floor radiant, low temperature radiators or fan coil units. No ductwork, no gas, no draughts, little to no noise, easy zoning - everybody comfortable no matter where they are (as long as they are in different rooms) or what temperature they want to feel!

This is just technical advice - not financial advice!

Often the best active solution for old heritage homes that are leaky and expensive to heat.

Nordic Air-To-Water Heat Pump (Designed & Made In Canada)

Nordic Liquid-To-Water Heat Pump (Designed & Made In Canada)

IMPO

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

PRO
Charles Ross Homes
2 years ago
I agree that hydronic heating is a good option. It can be easily configured to provide independent temperature control on each level and domestic hot water, too.
Related Discussions
Help! At a loss about how to improve heating (and add cooling)
Q
Comments (9)
Leaks in supply ducts depressurize the building. Leaks in returns make the pressure positive. That sucks outdoor air in, and blows it out, respectively, through any air leak in the house. Note this is for "outdoor" ducts only. If you create fur-downs inside the house envelope, you can tolerate duct leakage. Sucking air in randomly causes a lot of problems in my climate where condensation can readily occur. Central ducted AC systems also tend to cause pressure differentials between rooms unless there is a return in each room. Keep in mind that you will have to undercut each door halfway to your knees unless you have a return in each room or install jump ducts of some sort. Ducts in conventional attics pick up a lot of heat in the summer too. These are all reasons that I installed 7, high wall units in my home in the hot, humid South. Keep in mind that there are other types of mini-splits that do involve shorter duct lengths that might be more easily accommodated by fur-downs. There are also ceiling cassettes.. FSQ4CW, do Al and Fe radiators "require" different temps or are they just sub optimal on the same loop? If the latter, how bad is it really?
...See More
Ideas for improving the exterior of my old, ugly house?
Q
Comments (15)
Congratulations on your new home!! What fun this can be, taking a nice solid house and making it express your personality! Yes, how much maintenance you want to do outdoors is a key question. But there is a lot you can do that really, once established, won't require a lot of time. I have large garden beds and with good mulching and good plant selection spend very little time in maintenance. Mowing is far more time consuming. I would start with an attractive storm door/front door in a color that complements both the brick and the gray roof(I personally hate orange brick, and I might be picking out a color to paint it, but a whole lot of people must have liked it back then! But with good trim color selection, though, it can look good even to me!) Use that color around the window, too if you can. The idea for a porch or portico is a good one. I think that I would build a nice large patio or deck with a shade structure (can't think what they are called) between the front door and the driveway. I would also create raised beds along the foundation to hide it, balance the patio, and tie the brick to the ground. Fill it with low maintenance plants and shrubs; talk to your local nurseryman for ideas. Avoid yew or other shrubs that tend to quickly become overgrown. You don't want it to become cluttered, but you want to soften and add some interest with groups of varying textures and heights. I think the tree is fine, it just needs some other tree(s) on the other side of the lot to balance it. Might consider window boxes, or some other decorative structure, to give the high short windows an illusion of more depth but with a raised bed foundation planting the plants might serve to balance the windows in the overall structure.
...See More
considering buying an old house--heating/cooling questions
Q
Comments (14)
"Ice damns" are basically just a term for when the roof gets warm enough to melt some snow in some areas. The water then can refreeze when it hits a cooler spot like at the overhang. That basically forms a dam that can hold water on the roof. Roofs are designed to let water run off them, not to hold water for any length of time. If the problem persists, the water can work its way up under shingles etc and leak into the house. Obviously, that can be a huge problem. The way to avoid this is to avoid transferring too much heat to the roof during winter. A big open and vented attic accomplishes that in most instances. If you are going to enclose the attic, you will need an effective way of keeping the heat from rising up through the new room and to the roof. The "low tech" way to do that is to make a mini-attic above your new attic room. It doesn't have to be tall, just enough room to keep air flowing. For that to work, you need vents to get air between the roof and the ceiling of your new attic room. The heat needs a way to escape instead of through the roof. The "high tech" way to do it is completely shut off all air flow going up to the roof and insulate the heck out of it with expanding spray foam. That is a less reliable way to do it though because you are just counting on the insulation to keep heat from getting out of your room. If the insulation is compromised for any reason, you'll end up with hot spots on the roof.
...See More
Huge heating challenge in old house - hydronic?
Q
Comments (24)
@Emily L A few points about your "Ideal" system: 1. For future resale value, you need a "conventional" primary heating system that is able to heat the house. That could be forced air, hydronic, ground loop, etc... but not wood. 2. Wood can be a good backup / supplemental heat source (think power outages, propane delivery issues, -30 weather, or the cost of propane goes crazy like it has in previous times.) It comes with the cost of installing and maintaining a flue. It also has insurance implications. That's probably one pellet heater on the main floor or basement or an outside furnace. Outside furnace has some advantages. 3. You need to be able to leave the house and have it not freeze up. You need to be able to heat the house when you sick, overwhelmed, tired, etc. The most comfortable form of heat for that home would probably be baseboard hydronic convectors on the exterior walls. It would counteract the cold air that will be cascading off the walls and windows and would provide the most even heat. The boiler would be in the basement and the water lines would go up a chase (or more more than one) and be distributed to the rooms. That would probably be the most expensive to install. The least costly to install would probably be the conventional forced air in the basement and the attic - with the attic unit heating the second floor. Heating the second floor from ceiling mounted vents is not ideal for comfort, however. If you can find ways to get the heat to floor level through interior partition walls, that's a good plan. A multi stage or modulating furnace would probably provide you with greater comfort by giving you longer run times instead of cycling on and off.
...See More
Related Professionals
Emeryville Solar Energy Systems · Brentwood Home Automation & Home Media · Coronado Home Automation & Home Media · Hialeah Gardens Home Automation & Home Media · Lincolnwood Home Automation & Home Media · Milton Home Automation & Home Media · Orange County Home Automation & Home Media · Pine Hills Home Automation & Home Media · Saint Augustine Home Automation & Home Media · Tucker Home Automation & Home Media · Waterford Home Automation & Home Media · Aurora Fireplaces · Chelsea Fireplaces · Evans Fireplaces · Oak Hill Fireplaces
rwiegand
2 years ago
Start with an energy audit and do the air sealing and insulation that will almost certainly be recommended. This may dramatically change your heating needs and the solutions available to you. (at a very small fraction of the cost of geothermal heat pump system-- which are wonderful, but can be extraordinarily pricey for the benefits gained)
Guillaume Gaillard thanked rwiegand
Guillaume Gaillard
Original Author
2 years ago
Thanks for the reminder! I applied several months ago for that program, but never heard back from anybody.
0
Elmer J Fudd
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
The energy review is a good suggestion to start with.

Before you get too far shopping for equipment suggested by well-meaning people but at a distance, you need to first assess the situation in a holistic way and then bring in an HVAC contractor or two to assess the situation in person and propose alternatives.

Good luck/Bonne chance, Guillaume.
fsq4cw
2 years ago
Re: Elmer J Fudd

“The energy review is a good suggestion to start with.”

Not saying that shouldn’t be done but beyond a blower door test that might involve a lot of guess work in a century old house.

IMPO

SR
0
Elmer J Fudd
2 years ago
Energy audits should, among other things, involve an inspection for problems and fixable issues far afield from HVAC needs. Insulation present or absent, sealable holes in the envelope (walls, pipe and other kinds of openings in walls, floors, and ceilings), leakage around windows, condition of weather stripping, yada yada. Typically money spent on these often easy fixes have a much greater effect and faster payback than HVAC solutions.

HVAC people shouldn't be called in until after this kind of work is done or at least identified, it's usually well beyond what they understand and work with themselves. A conscientious load calculation on a status-quo situation before remediation is done will oversize the spec for needed equipment. Good for the HVAC contractor, bad for the homeowner.
fsq4cw
2 years ago
Your confusing a home inspection with an energy audit.

An HVAC specialist can always be called in at any preliminary stage for a consultation. Size can be adjusted later.

IMPO

SR
0
Elmer J Fudd
2 years ago
No, I'm not.
rwiegand
2 years ago
What Mr. Fudd describes is what I'd expect in an energy audit. Big emphasis on discovering sources of air leakage, combined with evaluation of insulation.
0

How to improve the heating of an old house (Ottawa)

fsq4cw

Comments (10)

Charles Ross Homes

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

rwiegand

Guillaume Gaillard
Original Author

Elmer J Fudd

fsq4cw

Elmer J Fudd

fsq4cw

Elmer J Fudd

rwiegand

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

How to improve the heating of an old house (Ottawa)

Comments (10)

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

Guillaume GaillardOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Guillaume Gaillard
Original Author