Quartzite Sealer Appropriate? Stainguard-50

2 years ago

Our fabricator used Stainguard-50 by Chemical Products Industries to seal our leathered Tahiti quartzite. It's 18 hours out and the quartzite looks and feels terrible. The color is completely different from before and the surface is sticky and hazy. My understanding is they should have buffed off any sealer that didn't absorb and that is at least part of the problem, but I'm concerned that the sealer is inappropriate for a quartzite countertop. Does anyone know the product or have experience with it? Google provides very few hits, and the product website seems to advertise more for exterior commercial masonry applications. A photo of the can of sealer lists isopropanol as a main ingredient. Trying to get information enough to decide whether we need to strip the sealer off with acetone and try to start fresh, wait and see, or figure out a different next step. Attached is a collage - before on top, after on bottom, and a view of the brown smudged appearance, and a look at the inconsistent surface.

Featured Answer

PRO

Joseph Corlett, LLC

2 years ago

"So the 3' limit for span of 3cm stone is not applicable here nor is the requirement for support of cantilevered stone since the stone isn't cantilevered"

It certainly is. You've got a huge span which appears to be more than 8' which is unsupported. The Natural Stone Institute allows 3cm natural stone to cantilever 10" without additional support, not 15". I've seen stone like yours sag and when it does, it torques the stone. If you develop a crack starting at a sink corner heading to the unsupported edge, you'll know why.

This isn't going to happen right away; it's going to take years. But hey, no worries, you've got a sign off from your fabricator, GC, and cabinetmaker.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
2 years ago
It'll probably have to be stripped with acetone; careful, it's flammable.

How deep and long is your cantilever on your island please? Any supports?
Jacque' Wicker
Original Author
2 years ago
Cantilever is 15" and is supported on both ends with cabinet structure.
Related Discussions
eeeek...etching on new quartzite counter
Q
Comments (149)
Howdy!!! Seems like this thread is relatively active. Not to beat a dead horse but if someone could help, we’d be so appreciative! We are finishing out a kitchen remodel and got our countertops installed Wednesday. We told the salespeople we wanted counters that were as white as possible but we could not do marble because we have five kids and can’t deal with stains or etching. I told them we likely needed granite and that I prefer granite typically. The salesperson sold me on Luce di Luna which I think is the one y’all have mentioned as not actually being quartzite? The person who sold it to us said it was a real stone (unlike quartz) and that it was more practical than marble because it won’t etch/stain and works like granite. We’ve used it for all of 36 hours and I noticed tonight MANY marks (forgive me I forget whether they would be “stains” or “etches”) on the island overhang where said children have sat to eat multiple meals. We are very clean people but didn’t anticipate any issues and thus didnt thoroughly clean the counters till this evening when I unpacked the cleaning supplies that had been boxed up from the remodel. Here’s some photos. So two questions: is there any chance this is indeed quartzite? We took a razor blade to it and saw only a minor scratch that wouldn’t be noticeable. And 2. Assuming this is our new reality, is there any way to repair marks like these so at least we can get a “do-over?” Can’t believe we trusted the “experts.” We are very disappointed and discouraged. Thanks for any pointers!!
...See More
Thoughts on this kitchen design please!
Q
Comments (63)
Again great questions and suggestions! Wish we would have consulted you all earlier in this process! Guests will use the hall bath just off the back porch. That will be an unoccupied space for at least the near future so will stay presentable. This is why we put a exterior door there and part of the reason the hall extists-to give guest access to that bath. We moved the bedrooms, baths, and closets a million times trying to accomplish the following: all beds with good sized closets, jack and Jill bath bt the kids rooms, guest/MIL suite with hall access to bath, close exit to back of house from bedrooms. We are not fans of hall space either but just could not come up with an option that didn't include one and met all the above criteria. Would LOVE to have that sq FT elsewhere as we are pushing our "limit" on size. Benefitting from this thread, we are essentially redesigning the entire plan lol! So keep the ideas coming! Here is the entire plan showing the back porch area as keywest requested:See above post for revised kitchen with open pantry and improved work triangle! So remaining problems/requests/ideas to address: -eliminating banquette possibly which would require reconfiguring mud entry from back porch -better home management area (computer nook/office space) possibly in mud area, not enclosed space just a tad but bigger then what is currently drawn -ensuring island size is appropriate I am sure there is more...
...See More
50 Shades of Quartzite (AKA, is quartzite porous?)
Q
Comments (24)
"The natural stone industry pays her to shill for them...Karin needs to tell her Brazilian overlords that she's out of scientific and technical lipstick to put on their impoted pigs...Karin, I challenge you to put your geologist brain to work coming up with a solution to the pervasive problems inherent in the quartzite aspect of the natural stone industry" The irony is that in this very thread, Karin has written at length about quartzite and its properties, and has written numerous other posts about testing quartzites and what to watch out for. Apparently @joseph_corlett wants Karin Kirk to solve all the problems of the stone industry. @joseph_corlett's comments above about Karin Kirk are despicable even for him who frequently tosses out supercilious comments on this forum. @joseph_corlett - provide backup that Karin, as you put it, has "Brazilian overlords". Provide backup for your statement that "The natural stone industry pays her to shill for them". You are one to frequently talk of lawsuits on this forum. Yet here you are, fervently making libelous statements about Karin. If Karin did not respond to the recent comments by @Lindsey Brady and @jmh0405, it could be because they have not actually tagged her, so how is she supposed to know she is being asked a question. Her tag is @karin_mt. Though with what Joseph Corlett wrote about her, I wouldn't blame her for not coming back to this forum. Karin Kirk has a website with her contact info if you want to look her up. BTW, Karin holds a bachelors in geology from Skidmore College and a masters in Earth Sciences from Montana State University. She has taught courses about climate change, ran energy conservation projects, worked on national-scale climate education efforts, and worked with NOAA on its Climate.gov website. She also has a TED Talk on climate change if you are interested. (There are about 100,000 people that apply to give a TED Talk every year. 100 get selected.)
...See More
Cleaning & sealing dolomite countertops
Q
Comments (57)
How to maintain Super White Dolomite While Dolomite is a super tough natural stone, it does require a little bit of maintenance to ensure it not only lasts a lifetime, but does so looking as sparkling and cleanly as you’d like. Luckily, it’s easy to maintain with just a little bit of proactive care. Clean up spills as soon as they occur. Avoid using knives or other cutting instruments directly on the stone. Seal your Super White Dolomite. Clean using warm water and a soft sponge. Avoid using abrasive cleaners or harsh chemical Ceciliano Marble & Granite Inc 142 Fisher St, Westborough, MA 01581
...See More
Jacque' Wicker
Original Author
2 years ago
I have assumed I need to strip it but trying not to get ahead of myself and get data/opinions.
millworkman
2 years ago
"Cantilever is 15" and is supported on both ends with cabinet structure."

Nothing in the center? That's not gonna cut it for support only at the ends.
Jacque' Wicker
Original Author
2 years ago
Well, it's not only supported at the ends, it's got 3 sides of supports. So the 3' limit for span of 3cm stone is not applicable here, nor is the requirement for support of cantilevered stone since the stone isn't cantilevered and does not require supports to prevent tipping. The fabricator has signed off on the cabinet design and the GC, cabinet maker, and fabricator have stated that the design is sufficient. Revisiting the issue, I'm now trying to research installation recommendations for 3 side supported stone to evaluate adding supports.
M Miller
2 years ago
I had thought true quartzite isn't to be sealed at all due to its density. Some quartzites are sealed because they are more like marble, and not true quartzite. I would strip the sealant with acetone as suggested above - note that a little goes a long way, and keep the windows open - and then do an easy absorption test. Drip water on it, wait 15 minutes, if the water has absorbed you need to seal, if it has not absorbed you do not need to seal.
millworkman
2 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago
You have a 15" overhang, unsupported at the leading edge the entire length, from cabinet to cabinet (6-7' minimum?). That needed some steel for sure.
Mama Cita
2 years ago
Don’t take on remedying the finish yourself — right now your fabricator owns that responsibility. Make it worse DYI, and they’re off the hook.
Jacque' Wicker
Original Author
2 years ago
M Miller, it definitely absorbs water. Very thirstily. It's why I questioned the fabricators on whether it was sealed. They said they seal at their shop but some stones need to be sealed more than once. So they came out to seal it again and did this.

Mama Cita - I have the same concern. I've just had issues getting information from them and I disagree with the product they use and the method. I need to talk to my GC about the right path forward. I tend to want to take stuff over a La "if you want something done right" but this is a different type of situation.

Quartzite Sealer Appropriate? Stainguard-50

Joseph Corlett, LLC

Comments (10)

Joseph Corlett, LLC

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author

Related Discussions

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author

millworkman

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author

M Miller

millworkman

Mama Cita

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Quartzite Sealer Appropriate? Stainguard-50

Joseph Corlett, LLC

Comments (10)

Joseph Corlett, LLC

Jacque' WickerOriginal Author

Related Discussions

Jacque' WickerOriginal Author

millworkman

Jacque' WickerOriginal Author

M Miller

millworkman

Mama Cita

Jacque' WickerOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author

Jacque' Wicker
Original Author