It is hard to tell from photos but I don't think either one of those grout colors is what you want. Is that a paper towel under the tile? Would be better to remove it. Also, do you have a picture of the kitchen? What is the name and color of the tile?

Removed the paper towel

The pictures I have found online for your tile show white grout. So actually the frost you picked out might be good because it ties in with your countertop and is light enough to show off the tiles. I don't think the Rain color would do your pretty tile justice.

Thanks Sukiyaki Mom
Our tile is 2.5 by 5.5
My husband is worried there will be too much of the lines. The grout will be 1/16. Thoughts?

The rain color is closer to the color of the tile, but it's still different. I think that's what I would use. The white will give you more of a grid effect. It depends on what you think you will like more. Either would be OK IMO.

I’d use frost. On my screen the tone of it corresponds the best.

I think I like the Rain the best, but the Frost would be nice if you want more contrast. The Cobblestone is a distant, distant third to the other two.

I would pick Rain. Maybe try taking a picture of the rain sample between and underneath two tiles with just a tiny bit of the grout showing. It might give you a better perspective of what it would actually look like? I think it will blend in nicely with the slightly lighter edges of the tile.

As mentioned, if you would like a little more contrasting grout, but still go well with the tile, then I think the frost is great. No to the cobblestone. Love love love the tile btw!

frost or cobblestone. frost if you want it to show......cobblestone i like as it blends , and is a little warmer which brings out the warmth in the blue you've chosen. Rain is a really cold gray ...not my pick with your blue in this tile.

Love the tile! I think id do frost, although rain works too. I had to really think and look for pictures about this! My concern with doing such a close colored grout in an area that’s typically under some shadow from cabinets is that it could throw off your color perception, so that beautiful blue without contrast might look like a dull white in shadow. Here’s are two pics to give an example. Still pretty, but it doesn’t show off the blue nearly as well as the pic of the herringbone tile.

These are all great comments and I really appreciate the thought and time you are putting into your comments!

Installed with frost grout!

It looks FABULOUS!!!

Thanks for all your help!!!

I dont know what things will sit on the counter but the wall is a beautiful backdrop. simple but not boring . nice install.

Gorgeous!

@sistertamala you made the right decision. It looks amazing!

This looks so good! thw frost really made the backsplash perfect in your space!