T

here were a few things i declined in my preview... mostly because I didn't need them or already own similar. I will share them here because I know some people like to see what I reject as well as what i keep.

I like the first boot quite a bit

but I don't really need it and it is a Marc Fisher which tends to run a little narrow for me.

This is a waterproof Caslon boot. I have a couple of pairs of similar boots from Vionic (my favorite) and Blondo. I don't need it and I don't like this boot as much as the ones I already own.

This is a jersey jacket from Eileen Fisher. I don't need such a casual jacket and it's pretty shapeless. I don't think it would be all that flattering.

I didn't really have any issues with this scarf except that it is navy (i don't wear a lot of navy) and I already have a number of dark scarves. I swapped it for lighter pattern in the same listing (the second image). Both are wool.

And the remaining items are coming in my next trunk ...

Open Edit Casual Cardigan in Healther Gray This is a brand I haven't purchased but I do love a long line cardigan.

Vince Camuto Asymmetrical Fringe Cotton Blend Sweater - not sure it's my style but trunk club is a good way to try something new. We'll see.

NYDJ Marilyn Jean - this was added as a replacement to something I removed. I am not looking to purchase jeans until i lose more weight but we'll see.

Eileen Fisher Straight Ankle Silk Pants - I declined these at first but then decided to give them a try. They're machine washable and lined. They might be nice to have around and I am thinking they'd be pretty adaptable across different sizes. I had a similar style from many seasons ago that I wore a lot (until the elastic wore out from dry cleaning).

Eileen Fisher Cotton ribbed cardigan in Powder - I have a few tops in this color (which is a little more pink than the photo). It's a great color for my complexion and I have an EF ribbed sweater set that I love.

Eileen Fisher Funnel Neck Wool Sweater in Cypress - my stylist originally sent this in the Powder color but I swapped the color to cypress when I requested the above sweater. I don't think I'll like the funnel neck but will give it a try.

Caslon Gathered A Line Gathered tank - an odd choice for the season but I like the colors so let them go ahead and send.

Keen Targhee Hiking Shoe - I suggested this as an example of a shoe I could use in place of a winter boot. I shared it as an example but they happened to have the exact shoe in my size. I have wanted to try a Keen shoe for awhile so I am looking forward to this. I think it should work well for the light snow days in place of a heavy boot! I am also still hoping to take a trip out west this summer where I will do some hiking.

OK, that's it for this trunk. I will let you know how the pieces work out and what I choose to keep.

ooh nice!

I have a question about that really nice cardigan you are expecting to receive. I like it a lot but am wondering what kind of outerwear you will combine with it?

I am going to investigate the keen hiking shoes. They look good!

Please post back when you get your loot!

Looks very promising, Funky. I love the asymmetrical sweater, and of course all the Eileen Fisher is looking good. I hope the Keens work out for you. A good shoe and nice to have in your closet.

This is the best trunk show yet! Love the waterproof Caslon boot and the Open Edit Casual Cardigan. Both are multi- purpose as they could be dressed up or down.

I think you’ll like the Keens, they’re my favorite hiking and rock scrambling shoe. My old ones get retired to mowing/yard work/lighter walking. They’re very well-made — feel light and heavy, both. Heavy as in sturdy, not weight.

Love that Eileen Fisher powder cardigan, such a flattering color.

I like your choices and especially like the scarf switch you made - that off white one is lovely. The asymmetric sweater may surprise you - they can be very flattering if the high cut area hits at the right spot. I just bought 2 pairs of Keen shoes while we were in WA (not the ones you chose) - DS gets pro deals on Keen and other brands and I could try on there then order through his account. The 50% off made it quite appealing. I find Keens to be very comfortable though the ones I bought are not light weight which I would want for any kind of real hiking.

I like the long cardigans, but at 5'3 (barely) knee length is way too long for me. I like the asymmetric sweater although I do not do turtlenecks. The jeans look good, as does the pink cardigan. I love the style of the silk pants and wear them often, just not sure about silk.

I love that pinkish cardigan, and the new scarf. Everything looks so warm and cozy.

Thank you all for the feedback -- especially on Keens. I have been eyeing the since Spring when I thought I was going to be traveling in the late summer/early fall. I sure hope they fit well!

Salonva - when i wear a long line cardigan I usually use a heavier wool wrap or ruana. I go through a lot of the winter with a wrap and gloves/mittens. Unless I am hanging outside, I hate lugging a coat around.

Tina, i wasn't sure about the silk either but I watched a video review of the pants on the Nordstrom site that changed my mind. It isn't a silky silk.. it's a matte, washable silk. Still not sure about them but then that's what trunk club is about-- trying items your unsure about ... in your own home ... without the commitment to purchase. I too love the style.

JT - it's definitely the best one I've had in awhile! Much of my wardrobe is adaptable and can be dressed up or down within a range. 94.6% of my time is spent within that range.

I like the asymmetrical sweater, but agree with @Tina Marie that it will depend on how it fits on your body. Thank you for sharing your ongoing experience with the trunk process. It's quite interesting to me.

I am looking forward to what you think about the jeans. I know you are losing weight (congratulations) and not sure if you are in plus size. My Dd is a plus size gal and struggles with finding good fitting jeans….that brand seems to have a nice selection of plus size.

She is a teacher and her school allows jeans on Friday. She won’t buy expensive jeans, but I would splurge for Christmas😉.

I have noticed that you dress in styles similar to her (that is a compliment).

Hi Tuesday-- yes, I am plus size. I actually have these jeans in a larger size. This style does run large-- i would definitely recommend going down a size. I am pear shaped and I think these may be better suited to an apple shape.. but they are generous in the thighs and behind so maybe that will change in the smaller size? I will let you know. I have tried Good American jeans which get great reviews but I wasn't thrilled with the fit on me.

How old is your daughter? Is Talbots a turn off to her? (My nieces wouldn't be caught dead in Talbots LOL!) I have had very good luck with Talbots jeans -- and pants in general. I especially liked their jeans for casual work days. Many of their styles are just that little bit more refined than your average jean. I think they look great belted with boots and blazer or cardigan. They do run a little long (I am 5'6") and generous in the legs-- so a jegging isn't skin tight, for instance. The curvy style is generous in the hips and behind-- sometimes too generous but i prefer that to pulling too tight.

And thanks for the compliment! It can be hard to find nice quality plus size clothing-- especially if you want a little shape and style. There are plenty of cropped tops and body con styles that I am not comfortable wearing ... and then plenty of shapeless pieces with no actual style to them. I appreciate that there are more options these days but it's still a challenge!

the Wit and Wisdom line from Nordstrom also has plus sizes that several influencers seem to like. They appear to go on sale often too.

Funky, I was excited when I saw the title of this thread. 😀

That’s an exciting collection! especially love the scarf and the EF powder cardigan. I like the jeans too and am interested to know how you like it.

Funky, thanks for the feedback. DD is more apple shaped, so these jeans might just be the ticket for her. She is 39 and would not hesitate to shop Talbots. We really need a Mom and Daughter shopping day in the future👏.

RN, I will tell her about the Wit and Wisdom.

Ha! Well, i guess it is exciting after the last few stinkers. I am excited to try the keen hiking shoe as I have been wanting to give them a try all summer. But really, I am in a "we'll see" place with all of the pieces ... but I think that's a good place to be. I don't NEED anything but it will be nice to add a few new items!

Mtn.. I bet the EF powder color will look good on you too-- though I don't really imagine you wearing many EF styles. It's a wonderful brownish pink. Like the color of cooked salmon with a little soy and chile glaze lol.

And yes.. all my wardrobe selections lately have been all about comfort. I am cocooning and doing all i can to make my life soft and comfortable. :)

OK.. i have received my trunk and tried everything on. Unfortunately, the black pants that i declined then requested did not make it into the trunk :(. Also, the scarf sent was a completely different pattern that I did not like... so no further reporting on either of those.

On the Fence.. need to decide over the weekend:

1. Vince Camuto Asymmetrical Sweater - I really didn't think I'd like this.. it definitely has a bit of that acrylic feel but it isn't too bad. It is BIG more oversized than i expected (and Vince Camuto often runs small on me). I am just having a hard time swallowing $124 for an acrylic sweater-- even if it is only a small percentage of acrylic. Still.. it's really kinda cute on.

2. Open Edit Relaxed Cardigan - This is also running big on me .. in fact, all but one of the sweaters was bigger than i expected. Still, i like it and it is perfect for this time of year. I am only on the fence about the whether to exchange for a smaller size.

3. Eileen Fisher Ribbed Cardigan - I do like this cardigan-- but not as much as the brown one i bought last year. The ribs are a little wider which I don't like as much. I love the color but still deciding if i want to pay the price or wait to see if it goes on sale as the holidays approach $248. Will I be crushed if it sells out before holiday sales? I don't think so.. but that's what I need to confirm before I return it. It's also a bit big. Why are all the sweaters big?? I don't think I've lost more weight.

4. NYDJ Marilyn Straight Leg Jeans - a size smaller than I've worn in the past which is good-- but i feel like if i lose more I will quickly size out of them. Also, i don't like the worn thigh look -- and I especially don't like the look on thick thighs. I could use a pair of jeans to wear until i lose some additional weight and they are on sale.. but I am betting I return them.

For those who were waiting to see what I thought of the brand and style, I do think they are pretty proportional (not always the case with NYDJ) and there is a LOT of stretch so I think they could adapt to different body shapes. I pointed out the faded thigh/knee area but what I didn't see before receiving them is that there is some slight destruction in the upper left hip area. It's pretty minimal but for those who were considering them for "wear jeans to work" days, I wanted to point it out. I wouldn't wear even slightly destructed jeans to work. I would recommend the jeans.. just not this wash (Heron). They are slightly long-- I'd have to wear them with boots (i am 5'6" but with short legs)

Definite items to return:

• Keen boot looked huge on my foot-- huge and wide like a man's work boot. Disappointed but now i know! Plus, I recently bought LLBean Moc booties so they will serve my needs for now. Returning.
• Eileen Fisher Funnel Neck sweater in Cypress - lovely textured wool fabric, i like the color quite a bit but the sweater was too boxy and shapeless. Not flattering at all. Returning.
• Gathered A-line tank - really disliked the pattern and who wears sleeveless in Nov? Returning.
• Birkenstock Suede Boot - i never shared this because i had no intention of trying it on.. and i did not. Returning.

Really like those first two and yes to trying them in a smaller size!

Update: I have decided to return the jeans and the Pink (powder) EF cardigan. I'll keep the other two sweaters. The gray long line sweater is a Funky staple.. and the fringe sweater is different from everything else in my closet.

I love reading these posts.

Outside, Merrells have worked for me in the past-- I will have to look into them. For now, the LL Bean moc booties will work in light snows.

And thank you-- i really didn't expect to like the fringed sweater but I really do!