Does your roofer have access to a visualizer so that you can "see" different shingle colors against your existing home? Is he suggesting darker colors because of the prevalence of algae growth on roofs? If so, it's usually prevented by installing copper or zinc strips at the peak. Alternatively, treating the roof shingles with Wet n' Forget once or twice a year will also deal with algae streaks (This Old House member Tom Silva attributes this to the newer shingle composition-little to no asbestos now and more algae streaks).

If you're in a warmer area, the lighter color should be more effective in reflecting sun's rays. I prefer the pewter for contrast, but it would be wise to see it on a visualizer.

Hey ceilsan32! I believe he is steering my towards those shingles because that is what he pre-purchased in bulk during COVID this year and he is wanting to eat up inventory. I have requested they drop off some samples of Charcoal and Weathered Wood. I have used GAF's visualizer but still haven't had a great feeling. We are in the Southeast (Alabama). Thanks for the feedback!

Weathered Wood

Pewter

Charcoal

Oyster Gray

Of the three, I like the look of Charcoal, but you're in the south. Dark shingles heat up and often increase summer utility bills.

Hi, Jared, if you're staying in this home for a while, I'd select a top level underlayment and at least a 40 year shingle. Take your time and try out various options. Did you check the Timberline series? If I recall, GAF offers 4 levels of warranty, based upon your selection. Make sure you read ALL the fine print before making your selection, particularly since you have had to worry about storm damage. Once the roof is selected, advise your insurance person of the details before work begins, as it adds to your home's value (even more so with a better shingle life/expert installation). Given your location, I'd definitely lean toward a lighter shingle color. Your brick appears to be a solid color. Did you consider a multicolor/dimensional roof that would coordinate with your home?

I am looking to have them install the GAF Timbeline HDZ (architectural) shingle line with synthetic underlayment and Ice and water barrier in the valleys along with dripedge/gutter apron where required. It will come with GAF's Gloden Pledge warranty which I believe is their highest. Ive done a lot or research but really struggle with design and colors. I thought I had all that behind me when we finally found our interior paint and trim haha.

"Master Elite Roofing Contractor" authorized by GAF is required for your Golden Pledge Limited warranty to be valid. Read this very carefully to be sure you'll receive a warranty without major loopholes. I feel your pain re: design and colors. It never ends when you own a home over many years. I had the Timberline 40 year installed 20 years ago, but am looking to re-roof in another 5 years. Inclement weather can really take a toll on a roof, and revisions are continual on older homes!

Charcoal.

Agree with deco on the charcoal but do check the heat issue. If it's a problem I'd go a bit lighter but definitely stick with grays since it works well with your brick and black shutters. We had an oak tree hit our roof this summer, so I can sympathize with you.

I love the look of what appears to be a gray roof on this house. The brick looks similar to yours and is classic with white and black.

One more thing...think about painting your downspouts to blend with the brick.

Great tip on the downspouts! I haven’t thought about that but it would help a lot!

Jared, note the more solid color of the roof in the photo I posted. IMO that works better with brick vs variegated shingles.

Thank y’all for the replies! The more I look into the charcoal, as suggested, the better I feel about it.

yep, charcoal. looks great with anything, brick, painted brick, wood, whatever. and it will look a bit lighter once its up on the roof.

Romabio Classico lime wash if you want this look on the brick

Thank you, Beth!