skip to main content

Home Decorating Design Dilemma living room

Trying to decide between two living room designs

3 years ago

last modified: 3 years ago

I just moved into a new place and am trying to come up with an overall design for my living room. I tried out a ton of ideas and shortlisted two options. One option is more modern with neutral tones and the other is a little more whimsical. I would be happy with both but I'm torn between them and mostly wondering which one looks more "designed" or put together well. Please help!!

I've pasted the two options here. You can check them out at the links as well :) If you have any suggestions for me, feel free to swap a bunch of things out on the Dabble site. Thanks, much folks!

Option 1:

Link: https://app.dabble.style/collection/dFfaLBED0VfBfdlf9gCT
Pic:

Option 2:

Link: https://app.dabble.style/collection/1rXPJTq1yVJdFfuakzc2

Pic:

Featured Answer

Design Girl

3 years ago

I prefer option #2

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (15)

eld6161
3 years ago
The second one.
Related Discussions
Who else is trying to decide between Culinarian and Blue Star?
Q
Comments (95)
I understand that the oven door on older versions of the BlueStar RNB could get quite warm (I've heard this described as "very warm" and "surprisingly warm" by two personally-known owners and in various ways by folks posting on the internet). My range is from this spring, 2011 -- I wouldn't say notably warm for either the door or the knobs. I can place my hand flat on the oven door, while the oven's in action, without any discomfort -- half a second, ten seconds, it just doesn't matter. It's not hot. Three kids and two small dogs and it's a non-issue. The culinarian is probably a very fine product -- certainly the specs look good and far be it from me to dispute anybody's happiness with his or her purchase. Folks should keep in mind that problems and praise for that range or any other on this board -- for all of this board's virtues -- represent a very small number of reports that may be more or less representative (or wildly unrepresentative) of the larger universe of consumer experience. With the culinarian, especially, we're talking about a very small number of reports on a fairly new product. Reported problems have not been many, but they have not been zero. Reports on Trevor's interventions have been very, very favorable, but not everybody has been instantly pleased by the company itself. I really don't mean to suggest that there are any major problems with the product or the company -- not at all. And for any particular person, for all I know, this may be an excellent choice -- maybe the best one possible. But surely folks know that the record is limited?
...See More
How to decide between light and airy vs. dark and cozy for living room
Q
Comments (31)
Thanks, Monica. : ). Your room looks so homey, and very much like normal life around here. ; ) I was picturing a wall color more like your orange- rust colored pillow when I heard burnished pumpkin. Aimee, it could be partly a function of climate, which might be why I find this to be a challenging decision! That's very interesting that you find cozy colors to be more intimate. I find that appealing, rather than off-putting, but we seldom have "strangers" in our home, and if they are here, I usually want to help them feel welcome and as much a part of the family as possible. Annie, can I come over and stay at your house and see what it's like to live in warm and cozy for a week? : ). I've seen a few pictures of your home, and it looks very warm and inviting. Thanks Lisa. Yes, the little blue library is off our kitchen. The kitchen can just be seen to the right of it. The doorway to the living room is between the library (errr, the bathroom, to be more specific) and the kitchen. Could we possibly get away with a color like this in the living room? This was my absolute favorite room at the home show this year. It's a dark bluish green.
...See More
trying to decide between 2 layouts kitchen
Q
Comments (10)
In the first picture, the fridge is convenient to the prep sink and prep area, but the dishwasher is far. If the dishes are kept near the dishwasher, they are far from how you might make a cold meal, like a sandwich or a cold breakfast. In the second picture, the island is a barrier between the fridge and range, though a prep sink might make it better. On the plus side, there is a decent prep space between the sink and range, making it easy to put your tools in the dishwasher as you finish. The cabinets at the end come down to the countertop which might look charming but becomes a bother because you have to have clear counters to open them. If they hold the toaster, coffee maker, and the like, and you don’t like those things out on the counter, then that could be okay. The rest of the lower storage should be more drawers, not cabinets. In general, I would say the first kitchen looks pretty but is too disjointed for my own personal situation. I might like the layout if the back wall and right wall were joined, because I like an L or a U. The second kitchen looks cold (photo quality?) and while I like an L or U, this one looks too big. There seems to be a lot of space to the right of the range, what is it for? Do you want to have family meals at an island? Or just snacks and breakfast? And if you do eat at an island, do you want it to be where the prep or cleanup is? (When DH cooks, he doesn’t clean up before he serves, so if we were eating at the island, especially where all the prep is, well, ugh.) Again, that’s a very personal thing. And, if you do want to have meals at the island, do you want to be in the middle of the cooking area, as with kitchen 2? It’s really impossible to say which kitchen I like better, or less. The widely varying quality of the two photos doesn’t help. And either of these could be facing front. or back, or the side. The kitchen isn’t in isolation. Talk with your architect about your pluses and minuses for front or back kitchen, dining area flow, and so on. He/she may have an idea you never thought of.
...See More
Help deciding between sectional vs 2 sofas in awkward living room
Q
Comments (2)
Personally, I'd get two sofas. This will allow for an end table and lamp to be placed in the corner. Also, people usually like arms to lean on when they sit. However, if you like the extra seating the sectional offers, I would decorate the curved void with a large floor vase or floor lamp.
...See More
Elaine Doremus Resumes Written
3 years ago
Option two has a lot of personality. I like it.
craljh
3 years ago
Two
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
3 years ago
I love minimalism but IMO #1 is not inviting at all I think #2 is okay but i hate the table lamp and please no fake trees. I think if at all possible rooms are best done with the main pieces to strat and then over the course of a few months find things you love to add to the mix. > Both these spaces are too “done” for me. Look fro art you love it will alwsy work in your space. A sofa and 2 chairs is a nice combo.
cawaps
3 years ago
Hmmm, I strangely fine myself in the minority of preferring the more neutral one, visually at least (usually I'm in the minority of preferring the more colorful one!). The rug is especially striking. It does have some issues: The side table is too small to set anything else with the lamp there. The chair does not look at all comfortable. And I prefer the plant and the lamp style in the second design (maybe a black version of the lamp for the 1st?) But I love the rug and the camel sofa, the black and white art. It should be easy enough to swap out the side table and chair for others with the same color and visual weight to address the above issues
thriftyboho
3 years ago
I think it's hard to tell you what would work without seeing actual pictures of YOUR living room, as well as whatever rooms connect to it. Seeing your ceiling height, windows, entry and exit points, etc., and perhaps even a floor plan with measurements (hand-drawn is fine) would help. Would you be willing to some pics and upload?
Kicksychick
3 years ago
#1 feels more masculine and #2 more feminine. I love both, but would choose #1 (but with larger side tables) because the #1 sofa can be styled many different ways and #2 sofa seems too trendy. Rug in #1 is awesome!
PRN
3 years ago
I like both sofas, but that's about it.
Val B
3 years ago
I prefer #1. #2 feels more trendy to me and I don’t care for the rug. In #1, I agree with another poster above that I would choose a larger end table (maybe something more solid instead of leggy, since that’s what you have for the coffee table) and a more comfortable arm chair.
decormyhomepls
3 years ago
#2
PRO
JudyG Designs
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
#1. However, I like this rug from West Elm better with the sofa. Occasional chair has great lines, but it is very low. When you ask me over for a ‘tini, you will have to help me up.

Chair is from Article.

If you go faux for a tree, make sure the container is large enough…often 1/4 of the tree height is a good width. This photo is from Crate and Barrel.
PRO
Amy Peltier Interior Design & Home
3 years ago
We might propose trying the artwork in a different order or getting all of the same size artwork to go over the couch you are considering buying.
Modern Ranch · More Info
loobab
3 years ago
Neil-

It's not about us, or what the name of the style is, it's about you and what you prefer deep inside.

When you come home from work and open the door, which room will give you a little smile and and a relaxed "Aaah"

Room one is spare and sleek. Although well designed, it doesn't read especially comfortable, or as a place that stimulates conversation. I would wonder about the person that lives there. I would think, he's a loner, he's strict, authoritarian, or emotionally repressed. And I might feel repressed in that room as well.

Room two is reads comfy and colorful.

The sofa is stuffed and it as well as the art and rug have lively color with curved shapes.

It tells me, this person has warmth, maybe he is huggable.

Maybe this person has cultural interests (the art, the Persian carpet.)

I would want to room two. It is calm enough to relax me and my friends and interesting enough to not bore anyone, and it is interesting without being pretentious.

The only thing I would switch out in room two are the lamps.

The side table lamp has a bare bulb which I find gives out too much glare.

I would get one with a frosted globe over the bulb.

And the floor lamp, if someone looked up they would see the bare bulb, so I would get one like that with a frosted glass hemisphere or something like that to cover the bulb.
mnzinnia
3 years ago
The furniture in 2 sure looks more comfortable if you are really going to live in this room. If you want a more contemporary touch you could change to a more modern rug although the one you show is very nice. I would add a few bright accents (the red "buy me" dots illustrate how that would make the room come alive.

Which color way calls to you? You can always find similar pieces in either color way so you can choose styles and colors that you like best.

Related Stories

HOUZZ TV LIVE Tour a Designer’s Bold and Colorful Living Room and Guest Bath

By Mitchell Parker

In this video, an L.A. designer highlights the colors, materials and furnishings in her modern Spanish-style home

DECORATING GUIDES Room of the Day: A Living Room Designed for Conversation

By Jeannie Matteucci

A calm color scheme and an open seating area create a welcoming space made for daily living and entertaining

HOUZZ TV LIVE Peek Inside a Designer’s Eclectic Dining Room and Powder Room

By Mitchell Parker

In this video, Jules Duffy talks about converting a garage into a dining space and creating a powder room ‘experience’

LIVING ROOMS See How a Designer Tackles XXL Proportions in a Living Room

By Becky Harris

This two-story Maryland space is big enough for large crowds but intimate enough for family time

LIVING ROOMS New This Week: 5 Living Rooms Designed Around the Fireplace

By Mitchell Parker

Overcome one of design’s top obstacles with tips and tricks from these living rooms uploaded recently to Houzz

DINING ROOMS Design Dilemma: I Need Ideas for a Gray Living/Dining Room!

See How to Have Your Gray and Fun Color, Too

LIVING ROOMS A New Living Room Blends Midcentury and Traditional Design

By Jess McBride

See how a designer has mixed timeless elements and midcentury finds in a layout ideal for family and friends

LIVING ROOMS Trending Now: 10 Great Living Room Color Combos to Try

By Mitchell Parker

These recent popular photos show examples of color combos that exude comfort and style

MORE ROOMS Designer's Touch: Living Rooms

By The Inman Company

These design ideas from a professional will help make your living room the liveliest room in the home

SMALL SPACES 11 Design Ideas for Splendid Small Living Rooms

By Samantha Schoech

Boost a tiny living room's social skills with an appropriate furniture layout — and the right mind-set

Sponsored

EK Interior Design

5 Reviews

TIMELESS INTERIOR DESIGN FOR ENDLESS MEMORIES

More Discussions

ideas to turn this open plan corner into an office/den

5

Is there such a thing as a “dark academia” garden?

27

Finished Master Bath Pix (well 98.9% finished)

36

furniture / photo alignment ? What’s my guide?

7

kitchen mixing metals

8