I am struggling with this decision. I have to decide today and just can’t decide. I have been agonizing over this for two weeks. Snowy Ibiza is gorgeous but I fear it is too taupe? For those who have it is there a lot of grey? That is what I want.

Karis I also love but is it too busy?

Cabinets are white shaker (white dove) and white subway tile backsplash. This isn’t a full rehab, just replacing counters.

These two colors could not be more different but I love them both. I really went into this wanting something white/off white with some subtle grey veining.

I did see both colors in person, full slabs. when viewing the Karis in person they also had another big sample of Karis and it looked so very dark (dark, precise veins) when compared to the slab. I fear I would end up with something like that if I went with Karis. It seems to me it was mislabeled but who knows. Was also told I could not pick the actual slab.

I am attaching a pic of the Karis slab and also the sample I saw. Along with the SI sample.

which would you choose?