You have an absolutely beautiful granite fireplace with stunning tiles on the hearth!

Your sample looks perfect to me.

Thank you, Houssaon. That’s Benjamin Moore‘s Pashmina. My husband and I were looking for something just a little bit lighter than that.

I like that one too!

Try SW Sea Salt, it has amazing qualities and can go greenish or gray depending on your light. It isn't too light or too dark. I think it would look awesome with your stone

Cool, thanks Flo. I’ll have to give that a shot.

How about London Fog?

Or Horizon Gray that picks up on the green in the stone and the tile?

By comparison:

Bleeker Beige

I would like to know what furnishings are going in the space and those colors along with rug colors.
The wall color is last thing to pick. I see your wood floors have some red tones. So help us see this in context so we can advise you more effectively.

Hi Flo, we are currently planning to have our floors redone - was thinking about having them strip it to their natural color and just keep that. Here is a picture of the furnishings we have for now, but again might be getting a new sofa soon. Don’t know if that’s helpful. Sorry about that.

Btw, I apologize for the bad lighting. The sofa is cream, the lamp bases are silver speckled and the tables are a dark cherry wood.

That a bit of help. Natural flooring would be beautiful. Do you plan on getting rug? It appears you have done cool art. Could you post that for inspiration. You really need to wait on wall color until you do floors. It will really impact wall color. Unless it will be years away. There is a sequence that saves money in the long run. Any remodeling like wall removal impacts flooring. So get that done, repair flooring then resurface floor. Then wall color. If you won’t be doing floors for a while, but a rug and let that help drive wall colors. The fireplace is pretty neutral so many wall colors will work. Plus, thousands of paint colors available. Hope this input helps. I know your post is about paint colors. But paint has to work with all elements to work well. Personally, greiges are passé. Lighter brighter color palette are strong now. So what do you think now?

My whole house is Pashmina-great “Griege” color but requires a lot of light and taller ceilings I would say. Undertone leans green. When I was choosing it, Revere Pewter as suggested above was recommended as a similar but lighter choice. Good luck!

OK, so I got four more samples and put them up. What do you ladies think?

I didn't think I would like the tan, but it really shows off the stone. I like the green the least. Darker gray is my second choice, closely followed by the light gray.

Flo was right - really need to select the floor finish, rug and furnishings first before settling on a paint. Do you HAVE TO paint NOW? why not wait until more items have settled into place and then commit to a paint. There are so many paints that will look good with your fireplace and equally many if not more that will look awful with your furnishings and decor.

In other words, you are boxing yourself into a corner- needlessly.