Opinions on this house plan appreciated!!
Kathy-Ann Baptiste
4 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (20)
Related Discussions
House Plan Opinions and Help needed
Comments (36)I had some free time this evening (DH is out of town!) and I love playing around with sketching floor plans, so I decided to pull out my non-professional CAD program and see what I could come up with to fit your property. Idea was to see if I could give you all the rooms on the main floor that you wanted including space enough for 30 - 40 family members to gather, while maximizing the views of the lake, and allowing light to enter all major rooms from 2 directions and keep the heated/cooled square footage down to under 2800 sq ft. I also wanted to minimize west facing windows because those can bring in way too much heat. And of course, I wanted to make the main floor fully wheel chair accessible. I kind of like what I came up with so I thought I'd show it to you. The floor plan is below and below that is the house situated on your property as best as I can figure based on the photos you posted. **************************************************** FYI - all single doors are 36" wide, the staircase to basement if 4 ft wide, hallway leading to mud room is 5 ft wide with a 4 ft cased opening to the foyer. I didn't put a fireplace in the Great Room. It could go on either interior wall. His part of closet is 5 ft wide, hers is 7 ft. Shower is 50" x 102" so plenty big enough to roll a wheelchair in. I think the only thing missing is the "sun room." I left that out b/c, except in the far north, sun-rooms are one of those ideas that sound a lot better than they often work out to be. But, if you really really want one and otherwise like the plan, the banquette could be shifted over to where the patio doors are, the kitchen patio doors moved to where the banquette is and then a sun-room with south and west facing windows could be placed in the corner between garage and kitchen. Even with windows on just two sides (south and west), I think it is likely to get way too hot for regular use tho. Besides, another alternative would be to make the sitting room into a semi-sun-room by using floor to ceiling glass. South and southeast facing windows would get plenty of light without admitting quite so much heat. Anyway, if you like the layout, feel free to use it as is or with any changes you see fit to make. I just do this for fun so I'm happy to waive all copyright claims....See MoreRemodel Plans - Please critique - All opinions appreciated
Comments (6)You sound like a very careful planner and researcher. Good for you! You have also already identified that this is to be an income property of some sort, either as a flip or a rental. Has the economic downturn affected your target market? What is your bottom line return? And more importantly...your budget? Do you have a realistic contingency fund for those unpleasant little reno surprises? One of the most important things to remember will be that you are NOT designing for yourself. Moving walls, plumbing and electrical are very expensive. But how much of that is really necessary here? You have a pleasant, conventional colonial as it is with a floor plan that may be somewhat dated but is certainly workable. Having said that, I would suggest only minimal structural changes, directing your efforts (and money!) instead towards modernizing the kitchen and bathrooms, the fixtures and the finishes. In other words, the "funnest" stuff. The only structural changes that I would advise are: 1) Move the laundry centre from the kitchen to the room that you designated as the office. Let's rename it as the utility room, since it appears that you have no basement and only a small garage. The washer and work sink would tap into the already existing plumbing of the adjoining bathroom. Incorporate a new pantry and other storage area in this room as well, maybe by re-purposing the old kitchen cabinets. A folding/sewing/craft area could be made from the old kitchen counter top placed under the window. 2) Demo the little closets from the kitchen previously used for the w/d and the pantry. The passage between the kitchen and the DR would now be wider without sacrificing any kitchen wall space. In fact, do not knock down any walls. Gut the rest of the room from floor to ceiling and start again using attractive stock cabinets, lighting etc. I do think that the "L" shape as you drew it would work well. I also have some added suggestions. I would forgo any upper cabinets on the "L" in favour of a bank of cabinets and built-in microwave on the wall with the fridge. I would centre the stove on the short arm of the "L", topping it with a architectural type of exhaust fan. An island would have been nice but you have to have 3' clearance in all directions to avoid traffic congestion. Doesn't work here. A peninsula is not really necessary either since you have a long stretch of counter space and there is both a kitchen table and a dining room table only a few paces away. 3) I would be tempted to convert the jut-out back to the original screen porch - it does look rather like an unhappy after thought, both from inside the house and on the exterior. Don't you have bugs in NC? Especially if you decide to extend that awkwardly shaped back deck for the kids to play on. It would ultimately depend on the structure itself, whether it is worthwhile saving. Remember, it's NOT for you - you deserve the biggest bang for your buck. That's it - no more structural changes. And you have some wonderful wood flooring and trim already in place. Strip away all the wall paper, the panelled half-walls, kitchen linoleum, undesirable bathroom fittings and worn carpeting. Then, start to fluff. Aim for the average consumers' taste - clean, welcoming, predictable. Repaint all the rooms in the same neutral tone throughout the house. Don't remove the brick in the FR (a horrendous job) but paint it the same colour as the walls. Add a substantial mantle piece. The flooring should also flow together seamlessly from room to room. The new bathroom cabinetry ideally would reference that in the new kitchen. Of course,stainless steel appliances and granite counter tops are what everyone want. With that, I'm done. Take what suggestions you fancy and leave the rest. Just remember the mantra - it's NOT for me, it's NOT for me......See MoreWould appreciate help with house plans
Comments (13)Eh, I'm not finding a great deal of love for this design. The out-front garage that "starts" beyond the porch is going to overshadow the rest of the house. I know that pie-shaped lots can necessitate pushing the garage forward, but this is pretty extreme. Your porch and the rest of the house will be in the shadow of the garage. I wonder if you could win this game by going with a detached garage -- connected to the house with a breezeway. That could also allow you more windows in your public rooms. I'd move the washer/dryer to the side of the room so the dryer could vent directly outside. Of course, this means it'd vent onto the front porch. The concept of the workroom is nice, and I'm sure the garage's location is why you placed it here ... but I think it'd work better at the back of the house; it seems like more of a casual room. I've seen such a foyer, and it isn't my taste. To me, it feels like you don't have enough separation between the door and the great room -- like you're walking straight into the living room. However, if you've seen one and love it, you know what you're choosing. I am concerned about the size of the great room. You'll need walkways on all four sides, and minimal walkways will leave you about 12x12 for furniture placement -- the same amount of space as your smallest bedroom. Are these little lines windows or doors? I'd be most concerned about the ones in the dining room. If those are doors, you won't be able to access them easily once a table is in place. I do think the dining room is big enough for company. I like the suggestion to switch the master bedroom and the media room. I am completely ambivalent about closets opening from bathrooms ... but this one is arranged poorly. This concept works when the closet is near the door of the bathroom -- in this case, you have to walk the full length of the bathroom to reach the closet. And it means you'll have to thread your way through the kitchen, the bedroom, and the bathroom with clean clothes. The laundry-to-closet pathway is too complicated for convenience, especially for someone who's just had a hip replacement. The closets across the house aren't 'specially well thought-out. Though you clearly like walk-ins, several of these aren't wide enough to give storage on both sides ... which means you're spending the square footage for a walk-in but are only getting the storage space of a reach-in. You mentioned you have lots of stuff to store, and since you want to shove it into the garage, I'm thinking it's not stuff you want to access frequently? Do you have attic access anywhere in this house? It's a deep house, which will necessitate a large, expensive roof. If you're going to pay for that roof, you should have a way to access the storage it can provide. On the subject of depth, have you considered truss sizes? In the media room, if you lose the closet and move the built-ins to the inside wall, you can have windows on three sides -- which would be lovely. But then this best-lit room in the whole house would be the one in which you'd least want glare on the TV. Since your adult children live in the area and rarely spend the night, I wonder why you're dedicating two bedrooms to overnight guests. PLUS you have the workroom and the media room. I think I'd go with ONE guest room, and use the other bedroom as a media room (saving some square footage and lowering the budget). In the future, if it ever needs to be a bedroom, you could convert it. Similarly, with few overnight guests, why not skip the powder room and open the secondary bedrooms' bathroom to the hall? It's a big budget saver. On the positive side, I do like the kitchen layout. Simple, uncluttered, good pantry. Finally, about your current house -- you say that the modifications you chose didn't work out well. Why? I ask because you certainly don't want to repeat past mistakes. Did you jump into them without adequate research? Did you "go too trendy"? You're making some unconventional choices here, and you don't want to end up feeling the same way about this house that you do about your current house. Analyzing where you went wrong could be the path to getting it right this time....See MoreForever Home Floor Plan - Advice & Opinions Appreciated
Comments (32)How long is forever? I can describe a couple forevers -- here's my grandparents' forever: - When my grandparents married, they built a small house on family land in the country (with an eye towards adding on as they could afford it), and they intended to live in that house forever. - When their oldest child graduated from high school, they opted to move to the big city 1) so she could attend university and live at home. 2) so they could start a business. They bought a very nice house and intended to live in it forever. - My grandfather died, my grandmother remarried, and the neighborhood showed signs of going downhill. So my grandmother and her new husband moved into a small condo that they thought would be ideal for a retired couple forever. - After a couple years, my grandmother felt restricted in the small space, so they bought a large ranch house and intended to live in it forever. My grandfather did, but after his death my grandmother didn't like upkeep on the large house, so she moved to a smaller ranch with the intention of staying in that compact house forever. - When she was 99 years old, she moved in with her son, who added a lovely little apartment to his house. And she did stay in that forever. And my mom's forever: - After she married, my mom moved into the house in the country where she'd been raised (my grandparents had rented it when they moved to the city). She intended to stay there forever. - She divorced, remarried, and her new husband wanted to live in the mountains. So they did, and they say they intend to stay in that house forever. I suspect my stepfather will live there the rest of his life (he's not in the best of health). - I think my mom'll leave the mountains after he dies. She's going to want to be nearer family. See how unexpected life events change your "forever"? My husband and I are building what we expect to be "forever". We've just turned 50 and our kids are almost out the door, so we're in a better position than a younger couple to say "forever" ... still, do we know? Not really. Likely most of our big life changes have already happened -- small kids, teens, now it's just us. We're building with an eye towards aging-in-place, but we also know that we could potentially end up selling....See MoreKathy-Ann Baptiste
4 years agoMark Bischak, Architect
4 years agoMark Bischak, Architect
4 years agonhb22
4 years agoKathy-Ann Baptiste
4 years agoshead
4 years ago
Related Stories
REMODELING GUIDESHouse Planning: When You Want to Open Up a Space
With a pro's help, you may be able remove a load-bearing wall to turn two small rooms into one bigger one
Full StoryLIFE9 Ways to Appreciate Your House Just as It Is
Look on the bright side — or that soothingly dark corner — to feel genuine gratitude for all the comforts of your home
Full StoryADDITIONSWhat an Open-Plan Addition Can Do for Your Old House
Don’t resort to demolition just yet. With a little imagination, older homes can easily be adapted for modern living
Full StoryUNIVERSAL DESIGNWhat to Look for in a House if You Plan to Age in Place
Look for details like these when designing or shopping for your forever home
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESHouse Planning: How to Choose Tile
Glass, Ceramic, Porcelain...? Three Basic Questions Will Help You Make the Right Pick
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNHouse Planning: How to Set Up Your Kitchen
Where to Put All Those Pots, Plates, Silverware, Utensils, Casseroles...
Full StoryLIFEThe Polite House: On Dogs at House Parties and Working With Relatives
Emily Post’s great-great-granddaughter gives advice on having dogs at parties and handling a family member’s offer to help with projects
Full StoryARCHITECTUREOpen Plan Not Your Thing? Try ‘Broken Plan’
This modern spin on open-plan living offers greater privacy while retaining a sense of flow
Full StoryARCHITECTUREStilt Houses: 10 Reasons to Get Your House Off the Ground
Here are 10 homes that raise the stakes, plus advice on when you might want to do the same
Full StoryARCHITECTURE10 Advantages of the Humble Ranch House
Boomer-friendly and not so big, the common ranch adapts to modern tastes for open plans, outdoor living and midcentury mojo
Full Story
Angela Zuill