Door are Benjamin Moore polo blue

You want to keep the trim and door colors? My first instinct was dark-painted brick- navy Or black. I’m also a huge fan of white/offwhite painted or lime-washed brick, which would look nice with your trim and door and black roof. What about leaving the brick and painting the shutters polo blue? Some photos.

Maybe consider replacing the columns and getting rid of the pediment over the door. See image below.

If you really want to paint the brick, consider a practical color with your landscaping (ex: will the soil get all over your lower bricks after it rains, do you have shrubs that are touching the brick, etc.)

I would avoid painting the brick unless it has highly visible discoloration in multiple visible areas.

Instead, work on the landscaping and the columns. I would paint the door but not white unless you want to be cleaning it non-stop or install a high quality stormdoor to prevent dust, pollen, etc. from settling on the door. If you can flex your budget, maybe get a different front door design all together.

I would not paint the brick. Also the shutter size is overwhelming the windows. (I know most opinions posted tell homeowners to get larger shutters). Shutters should 1/2 the width of the glass. Beef up the columns and work on the landscaping

Thank you for your input. There is a landscape plan and yes we are aware that the columns are undersized. The main question was coloring for the brick. The brick is the boring 1965 no life brick.

I would go with white brick, white trim and dark shutters.

More options

or gray brick and white shutters

I painted navy blue, and with blue door was too much,

so i painted the door with different color

I really like the navy. Turquoise or yellow door maybe?

Thank you! I was leaning for the lighter color. the house next door is a super light cream. The gray with the red door is nice too!

Here is gray/blue shutters with navy blue door.

I tried to paint the portico with the same color as shutters

I am leaning for navy on the shutters. I have been riding around my town, (with just me and my kids), and it seems most people have black shutters. I like the one above with the off setting blue gray shutters. You rock by the way!!!

I would remove the shutters and pediment before you paint..so you have that option..this alone will make a huge difference in your curb appeal....right now all you see is the big white shutters..not that much brick even shows

We have removed the pediment and replaced it with this.