Wow! This takes me back! We have a warm yellowy cream stone and the same siding as you. I made a giant mistake and had the whole board and batten and other siding painted Gray Owl. It looked horrible. I then asked the painter to use a color I cannot remember and he only did one coat and that was the end of it. Also only in the front, which was fine by me as that was really all it needed. Now all I see is GRAY! Someday I will need to remedy this. However, we still have so much to do on our new build that is still not finished. Either way I hope you find a color you love! Sometimes you just have to buy sample paints and a lot of them to figure out what you really want. Put them on every wall and look at the from every angle on any time of the day. That includes sunny and cloudy days. I know from experience how hard and frustrating this all can be! Here you can see how gray the siding looks. Which is fine. However the front is what really matters. Of course, I haven't a pic of it. I would trade you my gray for your yellow! ;)

Yes. They have two stock SW colors. Any other color is upcharge. I'll ask whether I can have a custom color and send them the SW formula. That is a good idea.

When you're mixing colors like this on the fly, I'd definitely take advantage of the BM affinity colors and then you know that they will work together well. I'm not sure how gray or creamy you want to go with the colors, but I'll suggest AF85 Frappe; AF140 Pensive; AF160 Carob as a nice cream, taupe, cocoa combo.

Thank you for these suggestions. Cmm, I was looking at Greek Villa but I'm in a northern climate and need a bit more color for it to look right in my lighting. Creamy is also too light for me, but if you want slightly warmer than Greek Villa, I recommend Creamy. Aktillery... that is so lovely. That's almost the look I'm going for, but would like just a bit more definition between walls and woodwork. I think that would have it in person, though. Thanks for the article, Outsideplaying. I'm using SW Pure White from that article as my trim paint. It's really just a nice, neutral white. Tina Marie, actually, Alabaster is popular as a trim around here, according to my painter. I got a sample of it, and it's very pretty color. But it won't work for the trim (just a tiny bit too dark), or the walls (too light). I'm going to use it for my closet, I believe, because it really is just a nice off-white. Right now, I'm looking at SW Natural Choice. In my light, it is light and warm but may have the slightest hint of green undertone. It works with my cabinets, though. My painter had to delay his start until tomorrow, so I've got another 24 hours to be indecisive.