I have exactly the same dilemma. Need white but not very popping out and doesn't go on the cream side as well. I have very light gray siding and we ended up liking Eider White and Extra White. Extra White Is the third one down on the same strip as yours.

Coastal? New England? Atlantic Ocean? Hardiplank shingles? What is Hardiplank? We use white cedar shingles for siding, and roof, pre dipped, before install, in a Cabot bleaching oil. Trim? Azek…you can paint it…white. Front door? Anything hubby wants. Keep your home simple in exterior. Let siding/roof weather naturally. For any metal…copper which will oxidize.

What a lovely view! I am so happy for you. Since outdoor light will cause more cool tones, choose something warmer. Try it on. a large swatch and compare, SW Fawn Brindle is in SW's Coastal Cool color collection, along with Eider White. Perhaps it will compliment your home's natural surroundings? https://images.sherwin-williams.com/content_images/pdf-hgtv-coastalcool.pdf

Need help with picking out paint colors for home. Please no gray(we have many gray days in Portland). Also I am thinking of adding some windows on my garage doors. Perhaps square row stacked on left side. Any help would be appreciated.