My vote is for #2

There is this one too

Is there a way to put the rug in picture?? So I can visualize better?

I am sure someone on here could photoshop that in.

No i don't think it clashes with the stars at all. It will actually pop the blue tone out of your wall paint by having accents of it elsewhere.

The only rug I would avoid is #2 as it will me an upkeep nightmare and the space is too light for a dark gray essentially solid rug.

Ok thanks!!

Always worry too many patterns clash. I’m not a pro which is why I need help lol

Why do you need a rug? You already have carpeting. I fear it might be a tripping hazard.

Love your stars and other decor, but he will be growing fast in this phase. It won't be long you'll be switching out the crib for a little boys bed.

#1 my choice. But a rug on top of a rug doesn’t stay flat. Gets lumpy and is a tripping hazard

Can someone use app to put rugs in photo so I can decide? Thanks

Here blue versus gray. Would the blue look better over the gray carpet??

It is still solid and bland in style. I would never recommend that for a child room.

You are a professonal decorator? All my friends said the one you alll picked on here they didn’t like as much . Isn’t less is more?

Nope, decorators and designers are different. I am a designer with a college education in space planing and codes, aesthetics are personal decisions.

Less is more only when it makes sense. That particular rug will look worn within months.

Here's one of them

Thanks!!

Here's the other one.

Here's another one.

That last one that Mackey's mocked up is best of all.

And the blue one :)

Which one??

I like the first one and the third one

Polka-Dots or Diamond.

Diamond may be more fit to the star theme.

Where is diamond rug at? Trying to find

https://www.google.com/shopping/product/6967409644287401703?rlz=1C1GCEU_enUS821US821&biw=1920&bih=969&q=5%27+round+rug+blue+stars&oq=5%27+round+rug+blue+stars&prds=epd:16281642098095573500,paur:ClkAsKraX-ORvBFdk3l15bEIFV0DmOScANvbcrfqf4HdmPqzJjvjssXYcegTOVJI6-_YZYcI4PTg5AeFh3V_hZEyddAmk7drNVdKhWalTtCKrpYKPVNySZP7RRIZAFPVH718JQopiTo8SCINsXrR3lteu59FVg,prmr:1&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiN1s_zmu_jAhVewMQHHex6BJAQ8gIIygc

I cannot make a decision on this!? Need someone to convince me of one

So do you all like the blue one ??? Or dot one better it’s between those!!

You and your friends have been raised in an era where color has been taboo, but thousands of posts on houzz are asking how to bring life into their dreary gray or beige or taupe room.

Less isn't always more and sometimes more isn't better. Everything is about balance.

If you have a little black dress accessories make the look.

A sting of pearls will make it sophisticated, leopard print shoes and a gold snake arm band makes it a sexy / dangerous look and dding white shoes a big flowered purse and a brightly colored chunky necklace make it playful, less serious.

You don't want to wear pearls, leopard print shoes and carry a big flowered purse. (Less is more)

In this room, less is not more, it is drowning in a sea of plain and neutral. It is the girl standing alone in the corner wearing the little black dress, black shoes and a gray chunky necklace.

The diamond patterned rug complements the stars and adds the color and playfulness that the room needs to pull the look together.

Not sure if you saw the link to the one with diamonds - posted above your request for a link

https://www.google.com/shopping/product/6967409644287401703?rlz=1C1GCEU_enUS821US821&biw=1920&bih=969&q=5%27+round+rug+blue+stars&oq=5%27+round+rug+blue+stars&prds=epd:16281642098095573500,paur:ClkAsKraX-ORvBFdk3l15bEIFV0DmOScANvbcrfqf4HdmPqzJjvjssXYcegTOVJI6-_YZYcI4PTg5AeFh3V_hZEyddAmk7drNVdKhWalTtCKrpYKPVNySZP7RRIZAFPVH718JQopiTo8SCINsXrR3lteu59FVg,prmr:1&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiN1s_zmu_jAhVewMQHHex6BJAQ8gIIygc

You can't go wrong with any of them, but the two with more pattern make the room look more fun and have some interest. They also will tie in your colors better because you have varying colors of blue right now going on in the room and the more colorful ones pick that up.

Can you do the striped one like one above? I keep going btw striped and dot one. Thanks . I need to just pick

Why don't you order the two you've narrowed it down to and try them in the room?

It's just a little rug that won't make or break this sweet room one way or another. I encourage you to trust your own vision and instinct and decide for yourself. This decision will boost your confidence when it's time to make the next decision. You aren't going to choose "wrong", and you deserve to make this space your own rather than trying to be "convinced" by a bunch of internet randos. ;)

Mackey can you put striped one in pictures?? Thanks

If this was my child room I would go with the diamond one. The shapes connect to your theme more that the dots. The colors connect everything in the room together. It isn't as feminine as dots.

Here you go :)

Like this bc so much going on on walls. This is my pick

Congrats on making a decision. It is the only one I would never suggest but to each their own.

I think it's lovely. Enjoy that precious room!

Seems classy to me :)

... and you'll add whatever else is pleasing!!! child is always growing.

That's the one I would have chosen, as well.

Yah or nah??? Feel like blues clash. Hate on line bc you can’t tell color

No, they don't go that's why I was suggesting the white color background ones that have a variety of colors in them.

Like mackey said, there is a reason we suggested the white rugs with pattern and color.

So would stripe one match?? I’m returning

Looking for something softer and little cheaper . Any Ideas? Kind of a ru/crawling play mat . Ideas please

Any of these?? They are not circular but cheaper