If not than the darker one. At least on my screen, the medium gray doesn’t seem like the right shade.

ooh I liked that one too. Nothing is going to change in the bathroom other than the flooring. What about the tile to the left of the one you circled. Is it too dark?

I circled my favorites..

The original tile is a peachy pink color.

I really do like a medium gray, especially if the tub tile is staying the same. The dark is too dark and I feel it would make the bathroom feel dark as well.

Match it to the gray in your counters.

It would have to be the small tile that I circled. The tile is a medium Gray. Florida Tile Time 2.0 Grey Natural. Seems kinda dark now that I look at it.

First, replace a yellow light in your bathroom with something more neutral. Right now it is not clear if your bathtub and tile around it are also peachy. Or is it just the original floor tile?

Just the original tile floor is a peachy pink. The lights are Halogen and I"m not sure I can do much about the color. The bathtub and shower are white. Paint on walls (not accent wall) is similar in color to the cabinets.

Surface Art Natural Grey is the upper right side. The one you circled, Karen.

Or maybe this color? Emser Citizen Resident

I like that one better. Less movement to compete with your counters.

Natural Grey from Surface Art, the one that Karen circled. It looks pretty! You think it might clash with the countertop?

I would take the tile samples and place them on the counter rather than the floor. Then you can really see how closely they match. From photos the lighter gray looks better. The one larger tile looks to brown.

CAP, the lighter grey does look better. Just not sure whether to go with the Surface Art Natural Grey or the Emser Citizen Resident Grey. The Emser tile is more matte and muted. You think the Surface Art tile might clash with the countertops? I think it is rather pretty and might complement the countertops.

I like the Surface Art better. I think it picks up the colors in the countertop nicely and looks like it might have some slight white that pulls in the white tub tile to pull it all together. It is not really what I would consider a busy tile, but rather a slight color variation. So I don't think it will clash with the countertop.

Citizen Public is another one of Emser's tiles, very so slightly lighter than the Citizen Resident. I cant really tell much of a difference except in the light.

Actually, the tub is an insert. The tile is plastic and built into the insert. Faux tile.