Thanks! We already found that, unfortunately, the number goes to a disconnected line and our order has been setting on pending for a day now, so we don't know if they are still in business or not...

Too bad. Hope it comes through for you. Good Luck!

Thank you and thanks for your help!

Once you start ripping out tile in a shower you have compromised the water proofing so now you need to remove all the tile and redo the waterproofing so just get some new tile that will actually go better with the floor.

I was wondering the same thing Patricia stated above. How do you ensure waterproofness when you just take out one bit of tile?

Agree with above. I would choose another tile and redo shower. Even if you find it, the tile will not match especially being a stone as it seems to be this one.

Would waterproofing repair be much of a problem since the compromised space is above the showerhead?

In terms of waterproofing, posters are correct that taking out tiles compromises waterproofing.

However, I recently remodeled my master bath which had a tub/shower combo with the all in one sides. They did NOT go all the way to the ceiling but the "plastic" sides ended at some point above the shower head. When the wall was demoed down to the studs, there was no mold behind the walls so obviously the upper level of the walls did not seem to need to be waterproofed.

As others have posted, you will not be able to match the tiles so you could find accent tiles and use them as if it were an intentional design statement. That might hold you until you decide to do a complete remodel - building a shower, at least in my experience, is pretty costly if done correctly - I think mine was between $8,000 and $10,000 for for the waterproofing and tile work - it could have been more but I did a complete remodel so lots of the costs were bundled together - i.e. showers in guest and master bath.