plant large tree next to old roots of large removed tree?
we had to get a ~30 year old maple chopped down because it grew like a "Y" and was rotting in the Y and half of it was over the neighbors' pools, sheds, fences etc.
The ground here is only about a foot of good soil and then it's a lot of clay, so trees tend to root shallow and far instead of deep and close.
~15 years ago the now gone maple's root was already up to the neighbor's foundation about 50 feet away.
I want to plant a new oak or maple next to where the old maple was (but will prune/train it to not grow like a double/triple trunk Y, and also will plant it farther away from neighboring properties).
Will this work?
I might go ahead and dig up some of the old roots but if I don't have to go crazy about it then I won't .
If a chainsaw didn't dull in 5 seconds in dirt chopping old roots, then this wouldn't be such a problem but I end up having to use a sawsall and it takes a while, and I have to resharpen the sawsall with a grinder like every 10 minutes and I also make very aggressive teeth on it). The ground in this particular area also tends to stay wet so the wood/roots will be harder to cut.
I made a diagram to try and show the spacing. Baiscally the old maple (silver maple I beleive) was over the grey hexagon (the main roots are that large for scale but the canopy of the maple was larger than that hexagon FYI) and the new tree would be about 30 ft from the house, but right next to roots of the old tree. We had the stump grinded but that does nothing in terms of this. thanks
Comments (11)
Embothrium
5 years agobarplants123 barplants123
5 years agoRelated Discussions
Can plants be planted in the holes of large old trees?
Comments (4)You will be blown away by the wonderful wide world of bromeliads - they are mostly Epiphytic , meaning that they grow on other plants ( trees ) and hosts ( pieces of bark, dirftwood ) Some are terrestrial ( grown in the ground) and others are lithophytes ( grown on rocks ). Most are monocots. You can wire bromeliads to your pepper tree and it can become a beautiful blooming sight to behold. I have bromeliads wired to the trunks of my palm trees as well as a few orchids. My favorite website for bromeliad information is the Bromeliad Society of San Francisco http://www.sfbromeliad.org/ They have some great cultural information and some wonderful photographs of bromeliads in the garden . Bromeliads in a San Mateo palm tree From Bromeliad Society Tour 2008 Bromeliads in Ted Kippings garden From Bromeliad Society Tour 2008 A tillandsia set in a red banana From Pina Colada A sampling of bromeliads ( Aechema and Billbergia ) that could easily be wired to a tree David Feix design. From david's garden photos...See MoreCut large root on maple tree?
Comments (7)Cutting the root will in all likelihood not kill the tree; however, when you cut any tree root, it stimulates the cut end to grow even faster, so it's a pretty temporary solution at best. The surface roots around the tree indicate that the soil is so compacted that roots will not grow in it because it lacks sufficient air space. If the house foundation is a slab, I think you're right to be concerned about potential damage. The roots have entered an environment that is looser than the surrounding soil with lots of air and moisture. They will grow larger and larger and can in time crack the slab. A block foundation is also pretty vulnerable to root damage. A poured concrete foundation is the least vulnerable, but the first hair-like roots can still enter the tiniest crack and begin expanding. There are products which are sold as root barriers. Their installation involves a lot of digging and they are far from totally foolproof, but it might be worth checking with a tree or landscape company. It might be possible to cut the root and then install a barrier around the foundation side nearest the tree....See MoreCan I root a large branch of curly willow tree?
Comments (11)Thanks Brandon, Rhizo The truncheon search helped. I had never heard that term before, had to go to wiki! Now I see your response to the gardner wanting to do the same with a fig. Don't think that post was there in the days I combed this forum before posting. After reading pages of search material, even some from the 19th century, I think I've got my head around this. I plan to wait to late fall if I decide to do it in place(in AL) but I may try some in pots now if I can find any of my tree pots left or devise something else deep enough. Instructions say bury 1/2 to 3/4 of its length--seems a little excessive to me, but? Do you guys think I would be ok to start with 2-3 gal? I do not want to do a lot of potting up as these things grow so fast, or larger? I have many to choose from. I would hope to get these planted out by this fall, but that was also the plan with the willow gone wild mother plant, but you probably also know how gardening plans ...gang aft agley. I root a LOT of stuff and this should be a pc of cake. I do not know why I am obsessing over this so much, but I have tons of maintenance with all these pots and only ounces of energy left. I never throw away a pruning cut, stick it in a special place in the back yard (no treatment,) and everything roots. Then I really can not bear to throw it out. Thanks all for your time. Michel...See MoreAdvice: replacing a large tree: roots from previous tree are moldy?
Comments (7)I'm familiar with Phytolacca americana, American pokeberry, which is a herbaceous perennial plant that dies back to the ground every winter. Leaves and stems are mildly toxic... usually not browsed by grazing animals unless nothing else green is available. Early spring leaves and tender stems/shoots of P.americana are eaten as 'poke sallet'... usually cooked by boiling, discarding the first water, which will have leached out the majority of the phytolaccin toxin. Meh. Not a fan of poke sallet. Reminded me of spinach. Vastly inferior to collards, turnip or mustard greens. Suspect that any 'toxic' issues associated with P.dioica would be related to consumption of leaves or berries....See Morekrnuttle
5 years agoken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
5 years ago
gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
5 years agopartim
5 years ago
bengz6westmd
5 years agoEmbothrium
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoann2shop
5 years ago
Sherry8aNorthAL
5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago
gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)