vinyl plank or stained concrete home bar

5 years ago

Hello,

Torn between vinyl plank or stained concrete. I’ve read a lot of articles on the two. One question I have for this group is do you feel it cheapens the look? Cost isn’t a huge factor but it will cost me a lot less to do the vinyl plank, 200 vs 1500. I appreciate the insight.

Featured Answer

PRO

HALLETT & Co.

5 years ago

Vinyl plank is cheap but predictable- you can buy a box, toss it down on the floor and know what it will look like. Polished concrete is the opposite- expensive and unpredictable. The age and history of the concrete will affect how it takes the finish, and microtopping is an unpredictable art.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

PRO
User
5 years ago
Neither. I’d suggest something interesting in a porcelain. A wood look. A stone look. A concrete tile imitation. Inkjet printed porcelain can look like anything.

Porcelain will stand up to wear and tear better than vinyl or any $1500 stained concrete job. That’s just too low a price for a quality job. Even $200 is quite low for vinyl, as there are floor prep requirements that must be done for all floors to make them flat enough.
Related Discussions
Laminate, carpet or vinyl plank over concrete on lower level
Q
Comments (2)
Vinyl plank is becoming very popular and the quality can range wildly. Main thing that will need to be asked is how is the concrete? Level? Any pits? LVT is a bit more sensitive to that. Laminate is also light years ahead of where it was 10 years ago. They're textured and look more like real wood now. Beveled edges also look nicer in my opinion. Most of it is loose lay now and with modern underlay the echo and moisture issues are gone for the most part. I would not use carpet with cats. You could always use a rug if you wanted the comfort in certain areas. My laminate runs about $3-4 sq/ft and the vinyl plank about the same for the better stuff. There is cheaper out there but if you look at the top layer it's paper thin. Those are my suggestions as the owner of a flooring store.
...See More
Home Depot luxury vinyl planks -- I tested the tiles
Q
Comments (19)
Salonva, we have Coretec for a year now in our Florida home. You clean it with water and vinegar. For the most part I spray with just water. We have a dog. No scratches from him, pulling chairs on, dropping something hard etc. It never looks dirty because of the grading, knots etc. I think I look at things a bit differently. Does mine look the same as hard wood that I have up north? No. But it looks nice! Yes there are some fake looking products, but I don’t believe Coretec falls into that category. We chose a beachy/ driftwood look. We were lucky to see this is someone’s home. We were going in a whole other direction! In the kitchen.
...See More
Engineered Hardwood, Luxury Vinyl Plank, or Luxury Vinyl Tile/Stone?
Q
Comments (9)
Installing hardwood in Florida takes extra effort. The first part of that effort is having EXCELLENT humidity control in the home. In hot, humid climates that means the A/C might not be enough. It might require an additional whole-home dehumidifier. It can also rule out an 'open window' type of home. Again, it depends on the location and the humidity levels. Hardwoods must be kept in a 'happy humidity' range between 45% - 60%. At all times. Every minute of every day. For ever and ever. And ever and ever. That means you will spend more on your HVAC system to have that type of 'push button' control (whole home humidifier/dehumidifier). And then the type of build also dictates the best practice for installation of hardwoods. A concrete slab takes extra effort to glue down wood. A high-end adhesives must be used and those add $2-$3/sf...just for the glue. The hardwood and labour are on top of that. In Florida, the most appropriate floors are stone, tile, terrazzo or concrete. All of which are hard and cold. Of course a cool floor in a hot climate is a BENEFIT...not a drawback. Part of the cold flooring is it helps keep the house feeling cool. Vinyl is then the next option. The difference between the 'wood look' or the stone/tile look is simply aesthetics. If you LIKE the look of wood, then go for it. If you LIKE the look of stone/tile, then go for it. With vinyl you will require very good UV block on your windows. Ask your builder what level you have on your windows right now. You will want to find something with UV block ABOVE 50%. I prefer to see 70% - 75%. That keeps the vinyl and the house cool. But it also makes growing indoor plants a difficulty. Plants struggle with UV blocking windows at 70% or higher.
...See More
Luxury Vinyl Plank or Luxury Vinyl Tile
Q
Comments (11)
I opted for LVT in my home because it was the right choice for my lifestyle. I originally wanted a very light LVT, but learned about "Environmental Staining". The flooring stores assured me that there are not issues with yellowing of LVT like there used to be and discoloration, if it occurred would be covered by warrantee. Being the distrustful type, I called the manufacturer and asked specifically about yellow staining in traffic areas caused by residue on our shoes after walking across the blacktop driveway. It is not covered by the warrantee and is specifically excluded in the "Environmental Staining" clause.
...See More
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
5 years ago
Is this a complete basement or just a small bar area. We need more info to advise
Terry Davis
Original Author
5 years ago
Area is about 110 ft2. Putting cabinets and bar on top of it. Finishing carpet around area. Just want bar and bar stools on hard surface.
fnmroberts
5 years ago
http://s1277.photobucket.com/user/treeshouse/library/Basement?sort=6&page=1

Above link included pix of our kitchen/bar in the basement. Used ceramic floor tile. About 100 sq ft. Like the wood look tile but such wasn’t available for us.
SJ McCarthy
5 years ago
So "floating vinyl" is out if you are planning on putting the cabinet/bar on top of the flooring. That means you have to move to a glue down installation. And that means you have to have adhesive that LIKES moisture in a basement slab (which is super expensive and tough to get right).

Once you start looking into moisture mitigation issues with vinyl in a basement setting, you quickly realize your options get really small really quick.
Kitty Lanier
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
I suggest looking at some of the SPC Rigid Core plank floors. Those have a limestone polymer core and can handle heavier furniture than the WPC plank flooring which is a wood polymer composite. The SPC will be able to handle moisture better, but you will have to use a moisture barrier on the concrete. Republic, republicfloor.com, SuperCore WeShipFloors.com and several others make the SPC flooring. I would call and ask questions if you find one you like.
seosmp
5 years ago
I have a follow-up question as I have a similar situation. I was told that they would put the LVT floors down after the cabinets where the flooring would go up to the cabinets. Any issue with this? In theory they could put the cabinets on LVT as long as it wasn't connected to the main tiles (meaning it could be raised to the same height)?? No?
Kitty Lanier
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
If you have a built in cabinet, bar, etc., the LVT will have to be installed after the cabinet, and a quarter round painted or stained to match will cover the expansion gap between this cabinet and the flooring. Fixed in place cabinets should NEVER be installed on top of LVP, LVT, SPC or WPC flooring.

I do not understand your “theory” as written above.
seosmp
5 years ago
Thanks!

I just meant - could they use completely disjoint (unattached from the main flooring) pieces under the cabinets.... or would that still be a problem. I'm not saying they would or would even want to...

vinyl plank or stained concrete home bar

HALLETT & Co.

Comments (10)

User

Related Discussions

Patricia Colwell Consulting

Terry Davis
Original Author

fnmroberts

SJ McCarthy

Kitty Lanier

seosmp

Kitty Lanier

seosmp

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

vinyl plank or stained concrete home bar

Comments (10)

Related Discussions

Terry DavisOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Terry Davis
Original Author