How to tile over tile - should I use a membrane between tiles?

5 years ago

We're updating our basement bathroom. The existing tile is 8x8, good shape, laid over concrete subfloor. We are not taking up this tile - we've done that enough in this house :-) My question is: should I use a Schluter tile underlay membrane between the tile layers? I tried contacting Schluter but no answer yet - they don't have this question on their website that I can find, either. I just want to ensure the new tiles will never crack. There are a couple hairline cracks on the existing tile from the concrete shifting - we've lived in this house five years and they were there when we moved in. No new cracks since, but I to ensure new tiles don't crack. I've read lots about applying tile over tile using modified thinset, but nothing to be found about putting a membrane down, then the new tile. Anyone done this?

Featured Answer

MongoCT

5 years ago

TCNA has guidance...I think TR712.

Laticrete offers a spec sheet for direct tile-over-tile using their 254 Platinum thinset, as well as a few other thinset combinations.

I'd first clean the tile surface (TSP is what I favor), then when dry do a bond test to see how well the thinset adheres to the tile. If not well, then the tile can be abraded with a carborundum disc or equivalent, or a primer can be used to improve adhesion. A couple of primers I've used in the past are Laticrete's Prime-N-Bond and Mapei's ECO Prim Grip.

Tip of the Day: A primer is much easier than abrasion. lol

While you can tile over tile, I personally prefer a membrane. I like Nobel CIS for situations like this.

Clean the tile

Prime the tile

Adhere the CIS to the tile

Then tile over the CIS

Grout

Cocktails for all involved

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

Corinne
Original Author
5 years ago
I heard back from Schluter. Here's my question and their answer:

Question:
- Can the uncoupling membrane be installed directly over existing ceramic tile? This is a basement - the tile is installed over the concrete subfloor. Tile is in good shape - just ugly. We don't want to remove it. So if the membrane can be installed over top, what type of thinset should we use to bond the membrane to the existing tile?
Answer:

If the following requirements are met, we expect this type of installation to be successful. However, given the wide range of potential existing conditions, this application is not covered by a specific detail in the Schluter-DITRA Installation Handbook and is therefore not covered under warranty.

In principle, DITRA can be installed over existing tile. In general, the following minimum requirements must be met for a successful installation.
1. The substructure must be adequate, per the DITRA Installation Handbook (e.g., joist spacing, plywood thickness, etc).
2. The existing tile must be well bonded; any loose tile must be removed.
3. The tile must be cleaned before the DITRA installation to remove any bond breakers.
The DITRA can be installed in a similar fashion to what is called out in detail D-V-T in the DITRA Installation Handbook. (I looked this up, and it's referring to installing over vinyl.)

Option 1. Use a rapid-setting modified thin-set mortar suitable for bonding to existing tile to install the DITRA
Option 2. Skim coat the tile with a modified thin-set mortar or suitable cement-based embossing leveler, allow it to dry, and install the DITRA with unmodified thin-set mortar

For further details please see attached Ditra installation Handbook
Related Discussions
Help Bill Vincent et al. Should I Remove Tile and Start Over?
Q
Comments (9)
Hello Karen, Sorry it took me so long to find this thread. Bill left a trail of breadcrumbs though and that's helped me along. :) So, from what I see in the photos it's a textbook Bay Area "single-coat mortar installation". He's got a moisture barrier of Aqua-Bar asphalt-impregnated Kraft paper and he's used 1" galvanized chicken-wire for lathe. His float looks to be a nominal 5/8" thick at the exposed edges and he's been pretty dang clean judging from the surrounding walls, so I don't think he's a hack. Now for the not-so-nice news. I can also tell from the photos that he's got quite a bit of lippage on those walls. It may be that those large porcelain tiles are not "rectified" (re-milled at the factory for flatness and squareness)and so he's made the best out of warped materials? Ann Sacks, and many other boutique showrooms, sell beautiful tile but it isn't always a guarantee that it's also flat or square. The best test will be to lay a straightedge across the tile (front and back each)from corner to corner and from side to side. Can you see daylight between the straightedge and the tile? Does the straightedge teeter and rock? If either of these is the case, then your installer did his job. If the tiles are flat however, he's ruined some very fine material. Without a better picture of the return-walls, I can't tell you why he chose the cuts he did. It may be that he allowed the niche's dimensions to dictate his layout, rather than the other way-round? All-in-all, it's not a terrible job and grouting may shine it right up or it may make things worse? A good grout job is like **magic** though so I think in this case I'd share your concerns with the installer and emphasize how much you HOPE he can make things better with a spectacular grout job. He should take the hint and screw his wizards cap on tight for the task. Best of luck, Shaughnn
...See More
Tile over crack - isolation membrane?
Q
Comments (5)
I agree. It's one of the best for keeping the height of the floor pretty much the same. Let me ask you, though-- rub your finger across that crack. is the concrete on both sides the same height, or is one side higher than the other? Here is a link that might be useful: Noble CIS (6th product down the page)
...See More
For tiling a bathroom, do you need cement board and tile membrane?
Q
Comments (5)
twigs, If using cement board, you want a waterproof membrane of some sort in the wall system. Easiest, and often the better performing, is to use cement board and a surface applied membrane on the face of the cement board. The SAM can be a sheet barrier (Hydroban sheet, Kerdi, Nobel, etc) that gets thinsetted to the cement board. You then tile directly on the membrane. An alternative is to use a liquid membrane over the cement board. Hydroban liquid and RedGard are common, though there are others. Another alternative is to use a foam board that already has the membrane applied to the face of the foam. USG has a nice system. Regardless of the path you choose, read the instructions for each product you select. They are available online. Watch Youtube videos. Often times the manufacturers have a series. Pro tile installers have them too. I recommend you avoid the jack of all trade video bloggers that do everything only because they are filming themselves, and they usually only do it once. I recommend you treat the ceiling as you treat the walls.
...See More
Tile over a lumpy schluter kerdi membrane
Q
Comments (9)
If the mortar was mixed to thick or allowed to skin over the bond to Kerdi membrane will be compromised. I'm willing to bet you could peel the membrane off fairly easily. The membrane / cement board assembly has a good shear strength but not a very high pull strength. At the very least pull away a section to check mortar transfer as noted in the installation instructions. If it's not 100% and you see orange membrane rip it all down. No saving it. Use a rubbing stone to smooth bumps and apply new membrane according to manufacturers instructions. Mortar should be mixed so it's just thick enough to hold the ridges from the gauging trowel. Keep in mind 95% coverage is required for setting tile in a wet area. Be sure to check as you go. "He put too much thinset behind the membrane" How is that possible when using the correct size gauging trowel. There are a lot of unlicensed trowel operators out there nowadays:) Good luck.
...See More
Corinne
Original Author
5 years ago
The only thing I'm not sure about now is what modified thinset mortar to use. I asked Schulter if Versabond Modified Thinset Mortar would work (which I already have) and they only replied that they recommend their own fast-set mortar. Of course :-)

Actual answer: Even though we do not warranty this type of application, we recommend using a premium rapid set for the installation of the Ditra membrane over tile. Schluter has a premium rapid set mortar called the FAST SET.
PRO
Creative Ceramic & Marble/ Bill Vincent
5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago
I would not bother with using Ditra. If you need Ditra, you shouldn't be setting over this tile. All you should need is to scarify the existing tile (scratch up the face for a better bond) and then use a premium thinset (versabond is NOT a premium thinset). My personal choice would be one of two-- either Laticrete's 254, or Mapei's kerabond mixed with Keralastic liquid latex.
Corinne thanked Creative Ceramic & Marble/ Bill Vincent
Corinne
Original Author
5 years ago
Bill - we have considered tiling right over the tile without the Ditra, as it would certainly be easier. The existing tile is in good shape, solid, nothing loose. However, there are a few hairline cracks in three of the tiles (which were set right on the concrete subfloor), so I'm worried the new tiles would eventually crack too. That's why we were thinking Ditra, so if the floor shifts again, the new tiles won't crack.
PRO
Creative Ceramic & Marble/ Bill Vincent
5 years ago
If there are any cracks present then you shouldn't be going over the tile even WITH a membrane. No way to determine exactly what's causing those cracks without taking the tiles up.

How to tile over tile - should I use a membrane between tiles?

MongoCT

Comments (6)

Corinne
Original Author

Related Discussions

Corinne
Original Author

Creative Ceramic & Marble/ Bill Vincent

Corinne
Original Author

Creative Ceramic & Marble/ Bill Vincent

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

How to tile over tile - should I use a membrane between tiles?

MongoCT

Comments (6)

CorinneOriginal Author

Related Discussions

CorinneOriginal Author

Creative Ceramic & Marble/ Bill Vincent

CorinneOriginal Author

Creative Ceramic & Marble/ Bill Vincent

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Corinne
Original Author

Corinne
Original Author

Corinne
Original Author