X-Back Dining Chairs - quality differences between brands?
CaroleOH
5 years ago
I'm looking to purchase several x-back bistro type chairs for my small dinette area. I've done a lot of searching online and have found several to choose from. Has anyone purchased this style chair and have a recommendation on where to purchase. Unfortunately, I haven't found a chair locally, so I'm faced with having to order online. Restoration Hardware carries several options and of course is the most expensive. Ballard's and Birch Lane/Wayfair also carry versions. I'm starting to go blind staring at online pictures and people's reviews etc.
Restoration Hardware Option
Ballard Designs
Wayfair
There are probably 4 choices on Wayfair/Birch Lane/Joss & Main ranging from $95-$240 a chair.
Would greatly appreciate any first hand experiences with any of these chairs.
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (10)
beckysharp Reinstate SW Unconditionally
5 years agobeckysharp Reinstate SW Unconditionally
5 years agoCaroleOH thanked beckysharp Reinstate SW UnconditionallyRelated Discussions
Amish furniture quality (vs. major brands)?
Comments (14)Found this old thread, but feel that I need to comment based on a recent experience we had with "amish" built furniture. We purchased a dining room table, 6 chairs and a hutch from Amish Oak Furniture in Pataskala, Ohio. They also have a store in Loudonville, Ohio. We searched in many stores for exactly what we were looking for. We were impressed at Amish Oak that we could custom order the furniture, choosing the stain and the chair seat upholstery design. We spent over $3,000 for the furniture in 2008. This set was used once or twice a year in the dining room in our home and had no problems. Fast forward to 2015 when we moved and our new home did not have a separate dining room. We decided to use this set for our everyday use. Less than a year later the chairs are falling apart. Two are so bad, we don't take a chance sitting on them. We took two of the chairs back to the store to be repaired. They want to charge us $95 a piece to repair them, even though their website claims a "Lifetime Warranty". These chairs were rarely used from 2008-2015 and have minimal use in the last 18 months. We are a soccer family so we don't sit down and eat dinner every day. We don't abuse them, we're not obese. I WILL NEVER buy from them again. I expected Amish built to last a lifetime and wanted this set to be a family heirloom for our children and grandchildren. Our dinette set from Wal Mart gets much more use and has held up so much better - all for $150!...See MorePoor quality with BM Eco Spec paint line (x-post Home Dec)
Comments (21)I am a builder: In June of 2009 we received shipment of interior MDF doors from Holzkraft. The doors arrived pre-primed from the manufacturer. Being a LEED project, zero VOC latex paints were used. The painter lightly sanded the pre-primed doors, used a tack cloth to remove any loose paint and applied a Benjamin Moore paint, Eco Spec. product directly to the door. The paint did not stick to the door and could easily be removed with a light scratch. We called the paint store who lined up an on-site meeting with the Eco Spec. representative who confirmed the techniques being used by the painter were part of the correct process for his product. He suggested we use a primer to go over the manufacturers primer. The painter then primed all the doors before applying the final coat. The finish paint adhered to the new primer. Two years later the homeowner has noticed several areas were the paint has been removed with the least amount of effort. The confusing part of the equation is the painter used the same process on the MDF baseboards and casing through out the house and the home owner is seeing no signs of problems. I am in the process of hiring a surface engineer who has assured me that his firm will find the problem. I will post the results....See MoreX-post - How to tell good quality furniture?
Comments (16)Thanks everyone for the comments and advice. I have been out shopping this morning at 3 different furniture stores. One was a chain type store, Levin...junk, junk and more junk (and thanks to all the info I am gleaning from here I could tell the junk), another mid-grade local place (think Broyhill, Flexsteel and Lane)...a lot of junk and a few decent pieces and then a more high end, family owned and ran local store. That place had a couple options that were within budget and were better quality than the other places. One piece in particular had all hardwood frame, 8-way hand tied coils, top grain leather, nail head trim and nice simple but classic rolled arms...I can't stand these awful poofy pillowed arms that so much furniture has now. The salesman said it was from the "South Pacific" but wasn't sure which country that meant...maybe Malaysia, maybe Indonesia. I will never get my DH to agree to used furniture...it's a losing battle that I'm not willing to take on. He has issues with other people's "garbage" so I know that's not gonna happen. Thanks again for all your advice and suggestions. Hopefully your collective knowledge will help me select something that will last longer than our current piece of crap!!! Just for reference, this is sort of the style I'm going for And this is what I hate... So if anyone knows of something in particular that you think is a good quality choice within my budge, please let me know!!! Thanks again!...See MoreAnother example:the difference between men & women in remodeling.
Comments (35)Hmmm, so I fuss over "girl" AND "guy" stuff. When it came time to have our electrical box upgraded from the old 100 amp service to the 200 amp service...I was the one asking the questions to the electrician. When our electrician was here this weekend to replace an old light switch that sizzled and fried (littlerally...black smoke coming out and everything!), I was right there, asking him about it. And I LOVE that he explained it to me as a human and not as "okay, little lady, here's what's up with it." When we were getting ready to build a house a few years ago...it was me that fussed over the dual zone heating. And me that fussed over the geothermal heat pump. And me that was asking about the relative advantages and disadvantages of Superior Walls vs. standard foundations. My husband came along for the ride on most of that. In our house, in many cases, I do the research (be it "male" or "female" based. Narrow down the choices to what I find acceptable. Present findings to DH and then we work on finding a decision. But, me, heck yeah, I'm going to be SO excited (seriously!) when it comes time for us to have the HVAC people in to replace our old furnace. But, I'm a little odd like that....See More
tackykat
5 years agoCaroleOH
5 years agotackykat
5 years ago
Lil S
5 years agoslicklydia
5 years ago
Related Stories
FURNITUREEclectic Matchups: 10 Round Dining Tables With Chairs
Check out these ideas for pairing round tables with complementary chairs of different styles
Full Story
FURNITUREIconic Designs: 10 Modern Dining Chairs to Know
Elevate your dining space with classic chairs by some of the 20th century’s revered designers
Full Story
DINING ROOMSSmart Shopper: How to Choose a Dining Chair
Before you go for that gorgeous velvet nap or slender sculptural seat, check out our guide to successful chair buying
Full Story
DIY PROJECTSDining Set Makeover: Paint and Tea-Tinted Fabric Make Old Chairs New
Reclaim dated dining chairs for far less than buying new, using spray paint, modern fabric and a handful of tea bags
Full Story
FURNITUREDesign Dilemma: Choosing Chairs for a District Dining Table
12 not-too-industrial dining chairs for a Houzz user's kitchen
Full Story
MOST POPULARSee the Difference a New Back Deck Can Make
A dramatic 2-story porch becomes the centerpiece of this Ohio family’s renovated landscape
Full Story
KIDS’ SPACESWho Says a Dining Room Has to Be a Dining Room?
Chucking the builder’s floor plan, a family reassigns rooms to work better for their needs
Full Story
DINING ROOMSHow to Choose a Rug for Your Dining Room
Measure Well to Be Sure You (and Your Dining Chairs) Have Room to Move
Full Story
DECORATING GUIDESDIY Project: Sit Pretty with Mismatched Chairs
Create a one-of-a-kind dining set from a collection of cast-offs
Full StoryVINTAGE STYLEBet Your Bottom Dollar on Cane Chairs for Stylish Seating
Cane and Chippendale-style chairs are so easy to customize, you can make one work in a dining space or home office of any style
Full Story
tackykat