Painting or replacing mid-tone oak (?) trim
Bing Croutwell
5 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (20)
User
5 years agopaintguy22
5 years agoRelated Discussions
New Floors, Painting Trim, Painting or Staining Cabinets
Comments (3)Hi there, Here's your post with pictures: Because of water damage to our kitchen floor our kitchen/dinning room/living room floor is getting replaced. Right now everything in our house is the same wood tone.. the kitchen cabinets, the doors, the trim, the table and the floors. It's time for a change. We also plan to replace the counter tops, skin, faucet, range hood, and put in a back splash. We are most like also going to replace the white range, dishwasher and fridge with a stainless set. This is our kitchen/dinning room now. We plan to replace the light colored laminate floor with Engineered Hardwood Maple in a darker shade.... Flooring link But that would look awful with our oak trim. So I have started with painting all our trim white. I'm still not sure if I should paint all our bedroom doors white too (they are a solid oak, as is our trim.. I would like your thoughts on that. I like what these folks did.. white trim and closet doors but dark doors. Posts like these make me want to paint my kitchen cabinets white because they are so beautiful. Or should we stain them dark, like these? Or should we keep the cabinets as they are and just change the trim and floors like this? If we go white cabinets this is what I�m thinking of doing: off white cabinets, dark brown counter top, and dark brown subway tile back splash. I would love the idea of having a butcher block counter on the island though. I would also love your thoughts on the floor in the kitchen/dinning area. Right now the laminate floor is in the kitchen, dinning room and living room (since we have a very open floor plan). The dilemma is what to do in the kitchen. Should we continue the hardwood into the kitchen up to the cabinets or should we put tile there? If we paint the cabinets white I was thinking we would go with the hardwood. But if we stained dark it would get too dark. Right? And please tell me: Paint? Stain? Or keep the cabinets as they are? Thanks....See MorePainting oak trim white?
Comments (11)First off---painting oak is silly---unless all the grain is filled. Reason---it simply looks like painted oak---which you have found unacceptable. Second, to stain, the wood has to be bare--NO finish. Removing finish from trim is more time consuming and expensive than finishing/replacing it. IMHO, painting oak trim does devalue the property. Which Zinsser primer did you use? Bull'seye or BIN? BIN is the better choice for trim. White trim is traditional and can also be modern. Buying paint grade(the least expensive type trim anyway) pine trim, priming with BIN, and adding two coats of the paint(usually gloss) is the minimum process. Poplar trim can be painted more easily than pine. Stain grade trim is more expensive(pine wood is difficult to stain evenly). Minimum process for stain grade pine is a wash coat(preconditioner), stain application(preferrable wipe on/off since that allows much better color control), light hand sanding, and several coats of varnish. Installing trim can be a good DIY project. The list of necessary tools can be as simple as a hand saw/miter box combo(as low as $20), a smooth face hammer($10) , a box of #8 finish nails($4), and a book of installing trim($20). Or as complex as a power miter saw($200up), a compressor($100up), a finish nailer($80up) learning to cope cut joints(coping saw/hand rasps at $20up) and more. I have tools worth over $1,000 just to install molding and doors. And some other tools to make molding, if necessary. Base molding and door molding can be a one person job. Chair rail/crown molding requires two people(or several special tools)...See MorePainting trim around oak casement windows
Comments (11)@K paulson, I can't say for sure without seeing it a bit closer, but I'm about 95% sure that only your casing is oak. Those look like common pine windows. As far as painting, its not uncommon at all to paint them and is not subject to any major problem as such. Basically everything that you can see and touch when the window is closed can be painted without any issue, and actually a little farther into the jamb than that. The grids will be a pain (removable?), but other than that, pretty simple stuff. Just a lot of taping and prep work....See MoreWood trim consistency—stain or replace? NOT painting.
Comments (12)It's yellowed because of the oil based finish and stains they used. Takes decades to yellow. yes you can strip it. I like SoyGel by blue Bear. cleans up w/water and it's a mostly natural product. works great. You can also try sanding if most of the top coat is gone. that door and trim isn't oak. looks like cherry. (3rd pic) Whats w/the door in the 2nd pic? did someone find that and put it on? or did they cut the bottom or what's happening there? I might go to a salvage place and look for a door that fits the space. give me a close up of the window by the stairs so I can see the wood. And that baseboard in the 3rd pic, what on earth? that isn't original. and it's not oak. wondering why they used a quarter round piece. if those are original oak floors, they should go all the way to wall. gaps would have been covered by the baseboard so no need for the quarter round molding. were those floors put in later? original woodwork and as mentioned, that mitered trim work in pic 2 is not original. if you want to stay period to the home, the door casing should be done like these. Since that's not original, take out the casing/trim and baseboards and replace w/oak, if you want it to stand out like it was 1919 again....See MoreBing Croutwell
5 years agoUser
5 years agoBing Croutwell
5 years agoci_lantro
5 years agoLisa SW
5 years agoUser
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoLisa SW
5 years agoLive Architects
5 years agoBing Croutwell
5 years agoUser
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoFori
5 years agoBing Croutwell
5 years agoci_lantro
5 years agoaprilneverends
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoBing Croutwell
5 years agoBing Croutwell
5 years agoLisa SW
5 years ago
Related Stories
TRIMTrim Color Tips: Get Your White Trim Right
Set off wood tones, highlight architectural features, go minimalist ... white trim is anything but standard when you know how to use it
Full StoryTRIMWhat Color Should You Paint Your Trim?
Learn the benefits of painting your trim white, black, neutral, a bold color and more
Full StoryWINDOWSShould My Window Trim Match — or Contrast With — the Sash?
The short answer: It depends
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDES7 Ways to Paint Your Trim Fantastic, From Classic to Fearless
Give your rooms an edge with a trim treatment that shows attention to detail
Full StoryEXTERIOR COLORDynamic Duo: How to Pull Off a Two-Tone Exterior Color Scheme
Why stick to one main house color if you can easily and beautifully combine two?
Full StoryCOLOR8 Reasons to Paint Your Interior Trim Black
Hide imperfections, energize a space, highlight a view and more with a little bit of darkness that goes a long way
Full StoryKITCHEN CABINETSThese Jewel-Tone Kitchen Cabinets Really Shine
For a colorful but sophisticated look, paint your cabinets one of these dazzling hues
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDES8 Reasons to Blur the Trim Lines
See what happens when you let your wall color cover doors and moldings too
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNA Two-Tone Cabinet Scheme Gives Your Kitchen the Best of Both Worlds
Waffling between paint and stain or dark and light? Here’s how to mix and match colors and materials
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDESHow to Make Wood Tones Work for You
Avoid the ski lodge look by using the rule of three, creating texture, adding pattern and more to expertly mix wood types
Full Story
Blueostrich