Sorry, just to clarify: Is the architect recommending the dark Schluter trim to finish the white tile? (Is that what I'm seeing here, or is that the grout color on the left?) If so, no dice. Either get a Schluter trim that matches the white of the tile surround or use the pencil liner.

I am one of those who prefers Schluter myself for a more modern and “sleek” look. But it really is a personal preference thing. Seems a lot of people really dislike Schluter here for some reason going by past questions.

@Sabrina - that looks like a grout sample to me.

If you're going with a dark grey grout, then you'll have a grout line along the edges of your bullnose trim. This may look busy. But if you use a white Schluter to match your tile, it will be much cleaner looking.

The Schluter trim will make it very minimal/modern looking. If you want a more transitional feel, go with the pencil liner.

How close in color is the Schluter to the white in your tile? I'd probably go with the matching bullnose for a sure match. Probably the difference in $$ is very small when you look at the total cost for your bathroom.

Schluter in Bright White, or polish the edges if it is a through body porcelain. No pencil ever in a modern design.

Since the tiles come with the trim pieces use them. It will help to keep you in the transitional style better. The Schluter white may look off in the finish next to the tiles, or consider using a metal finish from them that matches the plumbing fixtures if you want to go that route.

Agree with Skippack. Tile trim before a profile edge.

Hi J. Kendzejski. I know it’s been a few years - I’m curious what you selected and how it’s held up?