Thanks everyone!  Our painter uses SW so I was thinking decisive yellow or fun yellow.  Thoughts on everything being yellow? Our door and the side windows are iron, so it might be hard to do the sidelights the trim color and just the door yellow.  Not impossible.  Just more expensive and it might not totally match the trim.  Thanks!

Your house looks more craftsman than country. Especially the design on the windows in the door and sidelights. That said, if the doors and sidelights are wood, I’d rather see the paint stripped and just stain the door a nice medium to dark stain. If they are not wood and need to be painted, I’d go with an olive green, but I actually like the yellow they are now and you could even go more into a mustard. The trim should not be painted to match the door unless you also paint the trim around all the windows. The window trim currently matches the trim around the door, which looks fine IMO. I’d even say strip and stain the window trim if that’s what you do with the door. Just my two cents. Hope you find a solution that you LOVE! Good luck!

I’d look at Farrow & Ball, Dulux, and Edward Bulmer colors. Do searches for them with ’front doors’ and lots of images come up. Dulux Indigo Shade: Farrow & Ball Green Smoke is versatile: Farrow & Ball Lichen: Farrow & Ball Mouse’s Back. I know, it’s taupe, but what a good-looking one: F&B Card Room Green:

Pool, I thought I’d love the navy, not sure why I don’t! I like it in Deco’s example. Maybe it’s just the mock-up — the lighting, door style, etc. Mock-ups can help somewhat, but of course aren’t exact. You made a lot of good points. Different colors really influence the personality of the house in different ways. My fav is the California Chamois, or something like it. It looks fantastic with the stoop and brings life to the house without being garish. I don’t love every color I posted, but just wanted to show a variety. I think shutters (especially white) would look awful on this house because the windows are different sizes and too close together for them to look right. Kathleen, if you decide on white for the door, you could bring in color with pots. Such a charming house. :) I hope you don’t paint the bricks. They bring personality and character. White brick would stain easily, peel, etc.