Would you please define 'flat edge', given there are a number of edges on pulls? Did you mean flat front/face? Perhaps a couple of visuals/examples might help.

They're very nice in a modern setting--I almost think the drawers pictured above are a little too traditional for the look, but a straight Shaker door in a contemporary/modern kitchen can handle it just fine. Take the time to find ones with a more rounded profile so I don't keep snagging my clothes on them though, kay? :)

I think they look ok. I was interested in a similar style pull, but I had a hard time finding phots with shaker cabinets. Would you use those on both cabinets and drawers?

Would they be a functional faux pas? Have you handled them in person? Are they easy to grip? Easy to clean? Easy to use to open a large heavily loaded drawer/ Do they hurt when you accidentally bump them? The wrong answers to these would make them a "no" for me.

I've never seen these in person, so there might not be any issues, but I would want to find out before I committed to a full kitchen of them. I changed the pulls I was going to use in my kitchen because of a functional issue I found after getting a sample pull.

I'm on my second set of knobs, too. At least with these, you don't (depending on model) have visible holes should you decide to go with a more traditionally styled knob/pull later.

I opened this thread thinking a definite no, but I actually don't mind the example luckyblueeye posted! I would never have thought they'd work together.

Do you know if you can use this style pull with a paneled dishwasher?

Here is our linen closet. I love the edge pulls with Shaker cabinets and am considering the same for the mudroom (again, Shaker cabinets). The advice I was given from pal (which I did not follow but have remembered and am considering on this project) is to center the pull (1 vs. 2).

Linking to thread [here [(https://www.houzz.com/discussions/finger-pulls-dsvw-vd~2670633)which shows install, not inconsequential.

Prior to uppers being selected, but showing lines from farther back:

I think the look is great!!! I have redone my kitchen with the white shaker cabinets, embarrassed to say over two years ago and still do not have the hardware or pendant lighting, because I cant decide. I do know I want brass or a gold finish, ..and I saw the flat edge pulls and thought of using them, so until today I google what it would look like... I now see how nice it can look!! I love how my/ the cabinets look without anything so this is very minimal. So where would I put these pulls on the upper cabinets?