Pickled Mustard Seed: Thanks, Sleevendog

annie1992

6 years ago

On the "What's For Dinner" thread, sleevendog shared a recipe from Momofuku for pickled mustard seed. I bought a pound of mustard seed at the Mediterranean Grocery (it's waaay too expensive in those little bottles) and read the very simple and straightforward instructions.

As sleevendog suggested, I toastd the seeds first and then simmered a while, removed from the heat to let the seeds absorb the brine and flavor, simmered it some more. When it was thick enough it held a line from my spatula I quit cooking it.

It made one full pint, and Elery loves it. The mustard flavor isn't too dominant, but it doesn't taste "pickled" either. The seeds pop when you bite, vaguely reminiscent of the texture of caviar. He had some tonight on a chicken salad sandwich, but I could see it being very good with meat or chicken.

Thanks, sleevendog, I still have seeds left, so I'll be making more of this!

Annie

Featured Answer

sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)

6 years ago

Oh joy! Good it worked. Nice plump ones Annie. So many ways to get there. Same with making mustards. You can take 2/3rd's and stick blend, add some mustard flour like Coleman's, horseradish, yogurt, fresh or dried herbs....

I added a big blob to my taco sauce last night.

This jar, where the black rubber band is located, is the dry seed fill line. Added a squirt of AC vinegar and filled with hot water. Sat back of counter for a few hours and it more than doubled. Somewhere around 12-18 depending on your room temp, they will start to sprout and on their way to plants. Not noticeable until about 24hours being such small seed.

Sprinkled on just an inch of clean soil, (I use coir), they will be salad in about 6-10 days depending on temp...same seed you use to make your mustard pickle.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (37)

ci_lantro
6 years ago
Looks very much like some French mustard that I bought (thinking it might be like the Edmond Fallot mustard that DH loves.) What I bought: Reine Dijon Whole Grain Mustard with Wine.

Was quite taken back when I opened the container (packaged in a cute little crock) and saw all those mustard seeds (they weren't kidding about 'whole' grain!) DH doesn't much like it but it's really growing on me. I've had it on hot dogs (very good) and brats (okay); that's all that I've tried in on so far. Has a very earthy, mellow flavor once you get past the acid bite; doesn't taste like any mustard that I've ever eaten before. If I had been blindfolded when I first tasted it, I would not have identified it as 'mustard'. Ingredients are: Water, mustard seed, spirit vinegar, salt, white wine, sugar, citric acid, spices, potassium metabisulfite (preservative.)

Thinking it will be good on a ham sandwich.

I agree that it doesn't taste 'pickled.' That's good AFAIC because I'm not much for pickles outside of sliced dills on hamburgers and sloppy joes and a bit of sweet relish on a hot dog. Pickled beets about once every five years.
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
Glad you picked up a bulk bag. Way cheaper. A tiny 3oz from Penzey's is 4$. A full pound from MRH is 7$. (and organic) I can make probably 8 or 10 batches with a pound. About a dollar a full jar including the cost of vinegar.

It isn't a traditional pickle. Or even reminiscent of any mustards I've tried. More like a jam. Vaguely sweet, not sugary. I made a garlic/red onion 'pickle' using the same recipe last night. Added some mustard seed and grains of paradise, some pink peppercorns....for burgers tonight.

I then read a recipe that brings to a boil the black/brown seed, then rinses, then more water to cover, 8 times total. Just water to extract the bitter tannins. Then proceed with the original 'pickling'. Might try that. The white/yellow seed is not pungent/bitter like the black/brown.

Annie, try a 1/2 batch without toasting first and compare. I like both ways. So good with charcuterie...cheeses, smoked salmon, crackers, etc.
Related Discussions
I have no pickling pickles.
Q
Comments (15)
I understand that you don't want to do any canning but pickling is also food preservation and it has safety concerns attached to it. That's why the Harvest forum - the food preservation forum - exists for discussions such as this and is full of info on how to do it properly and safely. The problem with using slicing cukes for pickles, and this is discussed in great detail on the Harvest forum, is they contain 2-3x as much water as pickling cukes do and have a thinner rind. The result is mushy pickles. Experienced pickle makers will not use them to make any kind of pickles just for that reason. You can off-set some of that mushiness by using Pickle Crisp (calcium chloride). The Mrs. Wages and Ball pickling mixes have it added to them. They also contain citric acid to make the pickles even safer. If using other recipes you have to add your own Ca chloride and citric acid. But the pickles will still be softer if you use slicing cukes and many have sadly discovered that the hard way. You may be happy with the result but most pickle makers are not. Second, since the discovery of listeria, a bacteria which grows even under refrigeration, many of the old 'fridge pickle' recipes are no longer considered safe because they contain too little vinegar, they are not acidic enough for even fridge storage. Cukes are a low-acid vegetable so botulism, in addition to the listeria, is a potential problem when refrigerator pickles are made improperly. Thus the citric acid in the Mrs. Wages mixes. Dave
...See More
Flour is No-No What for Mustard Pickles?
Q
Comments (23)
kayskats - Yes, the "police" do show up at farmer's markets and farm stands, the state Dept of Ag can show up anytime (and have for several other vendors) to do a "surprise" inspection at your home kitchen, and yes, I do have to show my certification before I can sell at my quite small market (less than 30 vendors on any Saturday). The state also shows up to ensure that weighing scales have been calibrated within the last year, but that is another story. If you are caught selling BWB canned acidified foods when you do not have the cert. or are selling other stuff you shouldn't be (low acid, pressure canned, refrigerated, etc.), the Dept of Ag and the FDA could inflict very severe penalties on you and your market. We homegrown sellers have to follow pretty much what the rules are for commercial operations. One size fits all, US wide, but some states have lesser rules for farm stands and farmer's markets than my state does. Best to check with your Cooperative Extension office in your county and if they don't know, go on to your State Dept. of Ag. One comment one of my co-student's made was that if he didn't know what the rules were he would be safe from penalties. I don't think I'd buy anything from him, would you? Yes, please ask the sellers HOW their stuff was processed and if their kitchen was inspected, etc. We are consumers and should protect ourselves from bad stuff we might ingest. I even walk out of restaurants with a food grade less than "A". ksrogers - I think dry cured meats are regulated by another mega agency, the USDA. One of the vendors at my market raises cattle and hogs for cuts of meat he sells. He threw up his hands at the regs for slaughtering, curing, and/or freezing and now has a co-packer do it for him and THEY have to handle the USDA inspections and process filings which are really intense. >>I wouldn't go so far as to say that cured meat has no safety issues, because they do!Yes, I know, I make regular strawberry jam that is heated, but sadly it is not nearly as tasty as freezer jam. Horseradish, a low acid food, is not exactly stable and the pH acidification cannot be measured outside a food science lab according to my instructor, and that is why I can't sell it. It is not heated or pasteurized to eliminate bacterias, molds, and toxins, and "sealing" only means screwing on the cap. Refrigeration and acidification keep it stable and unable to grow the bad stuff because of refrigeration. That is also why it is sold refrigerated and you are admonished on the label to keep it refrigerated after opening. Commercial processors ship in refrigerated trucks from refrigerated manufacturing and storage facilities, and they go directly to the refrigerated section of the grocery store. That is something that can't be duplicated in a home processing environment or at an open-air market. Also, adding more vinegar doesn't necessarily make it safer because we can't measure the pH of the horseradish's vegetable interior at home, and with pH meters and test strips all we are doing is measuring the vinegar's pH. BTW - shelf stable jams and jellies are exempt from these regs because they have low water activity and a low pH. Since they are also packed at high temperatures, they are not likely to harbor harmful food borne illness organisms. Molds are the most likely bad thing to form but that is usually from not having sterilized the jars or not heating the lids enough (or, dirty hands packing them, airborne dust in a room with a fan, using overly ripe or moldy fruit, etc. etc.). I can sell as many variations of jelly and jam as I want at market. Without a cert. but with a kitchen inspection. Nancy
...See More
Sleevendog and others
Q
Comments (3)
The ingredient list is simple. I make it minimal for the same reasons. -toasted sesame oil -white sesame seeds -vinegar -wasabi -fresh ginger -something sweet -soy sauce -Because so many brands have different intensity profiles i'll just suggest to start with 1 tbsp toasted sesame oil in a glass pyrex or i use the french jelly jars, the ones with the red/white lids. (i use them for everything so i can mix and store)...'toasted' sesame oil is important as it is full of flavor unlike regular sesame oil. -Sesame seeds i toast in a saute pan and watch it carefully and flip and wiggle the pan. On low to med heat. Turn your back and they will burn. 3-4 tbsp. -For the vinegar I use Braggs apple cider. (or my own). So many asian rice vinegars can be mis-labeled...added sugars. Water. Unless you have a studied faithful brand. (i have purchased because of the cool labels, lol.)... 1/4 cup vinegar of choice -Wasabi is another unknown in the heat dept. I like Sonic. But now have a bulk one i bought a lb....not at home for the brand. Love it and the reviews reflect that. (i use it in so many things now that i have one that is not 'gold' in price). I start with one half tbsp. -Fresh ginger, grated, 1 tbsp. Again can be 'pow' or mild depending on season or source. -The sweet is usually my maple or honey. I start with a tsp. I leave my ingredients out on the counter, make the small batch above, shake, then taste. Adjust. I do use a tbsp or two of san-j organic, gluten-free soy sauce....but it has organic alcohol in the ingredient list that freaked out my BIL, lol. (had a boozy year or two after his divorce, then rehab but no issues now) I make it more 'wasabi' for us, then a mild batch. For a crowd i print out the ingredients and label them 'hot wasabi', 'mild spice', etc. It seems common now to cater to sensitivities. I no longer have issues with that. I make my spicy wasabi for my brother, and us, and my dad ALWAYS has to taste it. Even after telling him 'you-will-not-like-it'. And always says, 'YUCK!!". Every year. Long winded recipe but i think, to make your own special recipe, is to start from scratch and adjust. So many recipes do not consider the potency of the basic available ingredients. And divide the first one, make two or three versions. So many people like different spice.
...See More
Can I sub prepared mustard for dry mustard in slaw?
Q
Comments (13)
Fred Harvey was out to make a buck. He knew that coach passengers on the trains were hungry when the train stopped, and rushed to fine a good sandwich shop. So he built good clean standardized restraunts as close to the train station as he could and manned them with "Harvey Girls"...clean cut looking girls who wore a uniform and were held to strict standards. His menus were uniform and you knew what to expect at a Harvey House And he succeeded and built more restaurants. he was the Howard Johnson of the rail roads; he created the first chain of restaurants. After he died his sons and grand sons carried out his legacy.
...See More
annie1992
Original Author
6 years ago
Sleevendog, that WOULD be good with cheese, just a dab. Hmmm...

I did find mustard seed at the Mediterranean Market for just shy of $4 a pound, much cheaper than the grocery store or Penzey's. They also have it at Detroit Butcher Packer, $2.90 a pound! Since I have to order some sausage casings and kitchen twine, I'll order another pound. They do charge shipping, so I'll get it when I get other items, like those casings.

Cilantro, like you, I'm not crazy for pickles, although I like relish on a burger or dill pickle slices on a sandwich or sweet pickle chunks in my tuna sandwich. This doesn't taste at all like pickles, though, or even like mustard. It's something else entirely and very good, plus very easy to make.

Annie
ci_lantro
6 years ago
Agreed. It's a totally different condiment. If I end up addicted to the Reine Dijon that I bought at Big Lots for $6, I will have to make my own. Was shocked when I checked it on Amazon--almost $30 for the same size container that I paid $6 for! Felt like a total rube for liking it on hot dogs.
lindac92
6 years ago
So....all talk talk....but where's the recipe??
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
It was posted on 'what's for dinner'...I found it best to get it up to heat, then stir until the sugar dissolves, then let it rest a while to swell the seed, then back on when I was back in the kitchen. On and off a few times. Probably 4-5 hours on a back burner mostly with the heat off...no babysitting.
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
I need to make more crackers. The keep so well in the freezer. Perfect combination with cheese...
annie1992
Original Author
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
sleevendog, that looks so good, it would be supper for me but just a "snack" for Elery. I'm not a big cheese fan but I like just a little.

I didn't cook mine for that many hours, it cooked for maybe 2 1/2 hours, when it got thick I tasted it, liked it, and put it in a jar, LOL.

LindaC, it's way easy. 1 1/2 cups each of water and rice vinegar and 1/2 cup sugar, mix it and add 1 cup of mustard seeds. Toast the seeds or not, as you wish. Simmer it until you feel like stopping. Add more water as needed to keep it from sticking and stir it once in a while. Both sleevendog and I let it simmer, turned it off and let it sit for a while, turned it back on, repeat a couple of times (or more, your choice). Or just simmer it, I think the seeds won't get as soft, so whatever texture you like.

Oooh, I think this would be awesome with ham at Easter or on a turkey sandwich with some homemade cranberry sauce...

Annie
ci_lantro
6 years ago
Just noticed the 1/2 c. sugar, Annie. So this ends up being kinda' sweet? Or not? If on the sweet side, I think it would be great with ham or on a ham sandwich.

My container has sugar listed as an ingredient (way down the list); the 'mustard' is not at all sweet.
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
I just started another yellow seed 1/2 batch. The brown batch is just a bit bitter still. Even the one I soaked in cold water. (some other time i'l try the heat and rinse.)

I just did, with the 1/2 batch, 1 tbsp less than a 1/4 cup sugar. I used AC vinegar as that is all I have so mine is just a hint of sweet.
annie1992
Original Author
6 years ago
sleevendog, I was about 1/4 cup short of rice vinegar, so I used that much cider vinegar. I think the sugar could easily be reduced, but I like the sweet/sour flavor very much.

I only have the yellow seeds, but I'm thinking of trying the same thing with sesame seeds. What do you think?

Annie
bragu_DSM 5
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
sesame seeds and olive oil is basic tahini… i think it sounds good
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
Tonights batch was even better ...two hour but I was baking kaiser rolls and watching for perfection and had the low heat going on the mustard seed...stirring. Not that much different from the last 1/2 hour on a maple syrup batch. One false move and it is scorched.

this one did plump up a third more than the last batch using the same batch of seed. Same container 1/2 batch.

I think sesame seed toasted would be great. One of my brown seed batches had a bit of chia and flax. They do expand a bit. Especially chia. I would just not plan to keep them longer than a few days/a week. Mustard has such a long antibacterial shelf life on its own...but if I use it as much as I am now...no issue adding any herbs, etc.

I'm liking having the pure seed/pickle, then using it as a mix-in...dressings, etc

Or just toasting sesame seed and pepitas and keeping them in the fridge drawer in a container for the week for an add-in. Dressings....toppings. Add the mustard pickle to the toasted seed or a dressing.
2ManyDiversions
6 years ago
annie, that looks so good! I love your description of the caviar like texture and pop! I too was inspired by sleevendog's mustard seeds, and found a recipe for mustard (using yellow and some brown, no black), and used sleevendog's suggestion of letting the seeds soak longer and slower. We love it!
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
Todays batch was soaked overnight in the fridge. I just made a 1/3rd cup mustard seed. Couple tbsp cold water, one tsp RedBoat fish sauce, one tsp Tamari, 1/4 cup AC vinegar. This morning I put it on my lowest simmer flame with a cast iron heat diffuser ...added a scant tbsp dark brown sugar and more AC vinegar to cover by double...pinch of salt. (they swelled quite a bit overnight).

Fantastic. Will be great with smoked salmon or any seafood. Not 'fishy' at all. Just richer than the plain.
bragu_DSM 5
6 years ago
My wife thinks I'm crazy …

"I don't think of those as an individual item."

They will be great for on top of cheese and crackers.

"Maybe so."

Been experimenting … made a batch with white vinegar and sugar, and another AC vinegar and sugar.

This batch it's brown sugar, ac vinegar, cayenne pepper, orange peel (LOTS of it) and a nice shot of lemon juice. This batch may not make the jars ...
annie1992
Original Author
6 years ago
bragu, that sounds really good, I'm going to do that!

Annie
Islay Corbel
6 years ago
Ooooo I love the sound of these. Will have a go. Is not really necessary to cook longer than the 45 mins in the recipe?
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
"About " 45 minutes. All stovetops are a bit different, and all seed is different. I've been making mustards for eons and have usually 6 or more different lb bags of seed at any given time I pick up here and there. Different shades of white and yellow and mostly now a few different browns. And different sizes.

If you google 'mustard pickle' recipes they all come out a bit different and many comments are 'bitter' or not as silky as most restaurants. Chang's book is more about the restaurants and their evolution than recipes. I'm guessing they make 1 lb batches, bring it to a slow simmer and let it rest off heat to soak. Just like beans that soak up water overnight and expand, I find a resting and/or long soaking gets a better swelling of the seed. Restaurants prepping for the day often get something going and have things on and off heat white multi-tasking.

I'm also using half the amount of sugar now. Still slightly sweet. I'm using it in so many things by adding to dressings and sauces later on so adding spices to the original works well.

When I first made the recipe a bit over a year ago it was fine. Then revisited the recipe recently and needed to run errands so I got it up to temp and set it off heat on a back burner. The extra soaking made a much better product.

Their recipes are more 'ideas' and how they use them over exact measures and methods.

Giving the seed time to soak means 10min total time over a few hours, rather than 45minutes babysitting and watching/stirring. Just sharing my experience what works better.
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
Another variable would be the size of your pot/pan. I'm using a small AllClad about 6 inches across 2 inches high. Big surface area for a 1/2 cup seed. Low and slow is less risk of a burn.

Started a heat and rinse of the black/brown seed this morning. And a batch of chili oil...fresh ginger slices, garlic, star anise and Szechuan peppercorns in avocado oil, low and slow until the moisture evaporates from the wet ingredients....then added hot to toasted sesame seeds and chili flake.

Tapped a couple birch trees for syrup yesterday. Should have about six gallons by tonight. yum.
beesneeds
6 years ago
I think I need to try this. I have no idea what kind of yellow mustard seed I have, it’s just the stuff I get in bulk for making pickles with.

I have steel and nonstick pans... is one or the other better for making this?
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
I would use a stainless small sauce pan. Not too big since you are simmering with some sugar. Think like making a jam. As it thickens, low and slow, it can scorch.

Bring to a simmer and let rest for a 1/2 hour or more to swell the seed.

Similar to simmering fresh cranberries. Hard for 20 minutes, then they make a natural pectin with some sugar and get thick.

My brown seed, after 8 simmering and draining, are not at all bitter and plump. Now on a low and slow burner with the 'pickle'. Good stuff.

The chili oil is nutty and spicy,...just jared it.

Notice the brown seed, gorgeous color, after a few rinses.
neely
6 years ago
Finally made this... thanks sleevendog. I may have over cooked it but in any case it tastes good. Planning on trying it with some slow cooked lamb later on.
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
Looks good! Can always add a bit of water or vinegar if you want to make it a bit looser and glossy.

My simmering and rinsing of the dark seed took all the bitterness out. For some reason has a faint note of blueberries. Fruity. Not nearly as plump as the light yellow ones but still a nice pop.

Planning to use some in an Asian fresh slaw.

The birch syrup is just odd. Tastes like minerals and wet green wood. And the lingering taste a bit like a bay leaf. Weird. Not recommended, lol.
beesneeds
6 years ago
The birch syrup might be good in a cocktail of some sort?

Decided to try a batch today. Did it half of the book photo- and fell a wee bit short on rice vinegar and added in a splash of cider vinegar to make the amount needed.

Since they were yellow seeds, I didn't do any rinses, and didn't toast them this time. I have enough seed left to try another batch with those adjustments to make comparison against this batch.

Used my 1 quart stainless steel saucepan. Over medium heat I got the sugar and salt melted in, stirred in the seed and let it come up just a wee bit.. then turned it down to very low and been stirring it around while I've been working up dinner to pop in the oven. Now that dinner is in the oven I killed the heat under the pan and just left it on that burner- it's the venting burner for the oven and stays that nice bit warm while the oven is on. Giving it a good stir every time I walk past to do other stuff.

Haven't given it a taste yet. It has reduced down a bit and is nice and smooth and thickening.

Question- what do I do if when I taste it it's really bitter? Anything I can do to save the batch, or just scrap it and start over with it?
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
White/yellow seed will never be bitter. (I've never had it go bitter)...the nature of the seed variety. Darker seed is almost always bitter.

Some of the medium yellow seed can get slightly bitter.
Compumom
6 years ago
HELP Needed! I finally found bulk mustard seed at my local Sprouts Market. Yesterday I made a batch of UNTOASTED seed, organic rice vinegar, water, kosher salt and sugar in a Le Creuset saucepan. I gently simmered for about 20 min, then I moved the pot off of the flame for about 30 min, then returned it to a low flame simmering for maybe another 40 min. The seeds expanded, but I never needed to add more liquid. When I tasted it, as I was going along, it was yummy. HOWEVER at the end of my cooking, it hadn't really gelled and it had become quite bitter. DH said it was still good, but he hadn't tasted it in the beginning.

What went wrong? I will make another batch today and will toast the seeds first. How long should I toast them for? What else should I do? I'm serving pork tonight and think this would make a wonderful accompaniment.

Thanks in advance for your help!
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
All seed is different from different suppliers and the crop last year...if it is multi-colored...yellow/brown mix, I like to soak it like dried beans. Soak in hot/not boiling water for 6hours to-overnight, then simmer. White/yellow seed will never be bitter.

Darker seed needs a few heat and rinses. A light toasting just wakes up the seed coat and makes the soaking a bit easier. Soaking is key really. My seed doubled+ over-night.
annie1992
Original Author
6 years ago
Ellen, mine never did get bitter, and it did gel nicely, it got thicker than many of sleevendog's pictures but I liked the consistency that way. I did not soak mine before hand, but I did toast it. As you can see, the seeds expanded nicely. (That's a tiny ladle from my jam jar, for perspective)

Definitely try again, mine was yummy and I had some last night with venison steak.

Annie
Compumom
6 years ago
Thank you!!
Compumom
6 years ago
Success! Toasted and served tonight!
Compumom
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
Off shortly to Sprouts to pick up more mustard seed. Last night I wasn't in a cooking mood after a late lunch. I made DH some type of Trader Joe's garlic sausages with sauteed onions and white wine. I had an idea to stir in some of the congealed mustard seed. He loved it and then finished off the jar!

THis time around I'm going to soak the seeds first. Do I soak them in the vinegar/water/sugar/salt mixture? I imagine that I do. Should I toast them before I do that?
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
You have choices. That is the beauty of making the seed 'jam' any way you want...

Like the pic above, I soaked for 6-8 hours in warm water with just a blurb of ac vinegar...nice and plump and when I had time I put it on the back burner on low heat...it just sits there fine until you have time to get it on the stove...no need for anything else until you put it on heat....
Compumom
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago
Thanks! Do they still retain that pop/crunch like roe? He loved it!
sleevendog (5a NY 6aNYC NL CA)
6 years ago
si, : )
Compumom
6 years ago
I had a soaking fail. They became bitter and never really swelled further to absorb more of the liquid. I added only 1 cup + water and 1 cup Rice vinegar, yet the full 1/4 cup of sugar. DH and I both find them quite bitter. I'll make more, toasting them first and recreating the last successful batch.