Scale may be more of an issue than the chair itself. Do you love your sofa? If you could have another chair instead it would be more open feeling. Its hard to see the colors clearly so get out your color wheel and find a complimentary color to the chair's colors. Use that for the window treatment or better yet, wide blinds and no curtains. Also, I have found that accent pillows go a long way. Good luck.

Is replacing the run an option??

A brighter picture of the whole room would be helpful. Hard to tell right which direction would be more pleasing (neutral or not) from that small section of the room

The colors go well and it sure looks comfy. I like the fabric, and I don't think the curtains & rug seem too out of place w/the furniture, but I realize we're relying on photos that may not accurately reflect the colors in person; the too dark ones certainly don't. Maybe some pillows that pick up the curtain color on couch & chair?And perhaps solid &/or more simply patterned rug & drapes would work better. I also think that end table could be more substantial. Right now, the chair seems so far away from the rug and couch. Can it be pulled closer?

I think I'd pick one of those neutrals from the patterned fabric - taupe, warm grey or umber - for new curtains &/or rug.

This seems a bit busy, but I do like the color scheme..

I really feel as if you lighten up the rug, the whole space will have a brand new look. Maybe something like this?

Surya Frontier FT165 Blue/Neutral Flatweave Area Rug, 8'x11' Rectangle · More Info

https://www.wayfair.com/rugs/pdp/union-rustic-litz-hand-tufted-ivory-area-rug-unrs6500.html?piid=26956586

https://www.wayfair.com/rugs/pdp/bungalow-rose-allens-hand-knotted-natural-area-rug-bngl6586.html

I'd change the curtains first. I would like something lighter and more neutral. Everything is big dark spots against light walls and medium floors. The chair can actually help break that up, but it can't do it alone. Lighter rug might help, but the curtains along with accessories are the easiest and possibly least expensive changes - then see if you need to change the rug. Unless you are wanting a new rug.

I would change the curtains to a solid cream color and find a large painting to replace the mirror over the couch. That will pick up the cream in the chair and create a lighter and more unified look. If that is a blue color in your chair I'd find blue and cream patterned pillows for your couch to bring the couch and chair in synch. I do think a lighter colored rug in a more modern pattern or stripes will help. I like your chair.

I’d get drapes the same color as the cream in your chair and a rug that also has the same cream color in it.

Really funny but one of my friends ordered this exact fabric it arrived and the upholstery was just like yours I made her return it to have it redone , those 2 arms should match IMO , her store actually had it redone .As for othere items I think you had some good advice here.

Flat weave Couristan I had open yesterday - might work and add a lighter warm color, as a lift.... art could have a mix of all your 'warms' --

https://www.hayneedle.com/product/couristan-monaco-784710-alassio-indooroutdoor-area-rug.cfm

Linen/ poly -

Open Weave Natural Linen Sheer, 50"x96" · More Info

I'd almost think a very pale linen / off white - to lighten... if it's a paint blend:

Solid Off White Voile Poly Curtains, Set of 2, 50"x96" · More Info

Would adding window texture soften the effect of a pattern ?

Pearson's Room · More Info

These have good reviews - maybe I mean that it makes decor more casual ...

https://www.jcpenney.com/p/jcpenney-home-bamboo-woven-wood-roman-shade/1d6e1c9?pTmplType=regular&searchTerm=bamboo shades&catId=SearchResults&searchType=Predictive%20Search%7CProducts%7C1&predictiveDetail=product:bamboo:1:1d6e1c9

I noticed the chair wasn't upholstered correctly either. Arms should match and pattern should go in same direction on the seat as back. Maybe you can have them redo it - and use a different material if you are still not happy with it. Bur for sure complain about the matching of the arms.

I agree about the matching of the pattern on the chair. Is the seat cushion reversible, or could you at least try placing it the opposite way it is now? I think that will show you how the pattern should run on the back and the seat. They should definitely redo it for you.

It's hard to find examples of similar patterned chairs, but this is close. See how the arms match, the pattern is symmetrical - including where the cushion front and the area below it are matched up.

I love your pieces! They are really stylin!

I would paint the room a warm white, possibly Benjamin Moore Cotton Balls or Cloud. Then I would have a charcoal accent wall, and go from there......add a pair of charcoal lounge chairs, some steel and wood end tables, a washed grey oak round cocktail table and some killer lamps. A woven wall hanging would be nice, or a small area rug with texture to hang on the wall in wool, or an indian vibe wall hanging.

HOuzz has such interesting pictures.....white/light walls, strong red leather and patterned chairs, wood and steel cocktail table, hardwood floors with sisal/natural bound rug woven window treatments, the cabinets on either side of fireplace can represent the dark accent wall you might want to consider to get more contrast in the room......of course this is very modern room, but the concept could translate to your room.

Lake House · More Info

And of course pillows and love this abstract rug but possibly with less contrasting colors....cream/white on pale charcoal for lower contrast.

Surya Archive Rug (ACH-1710) · More Info

Natural tans are a good coordinate for that deep bossy red. I would lighten up on the wood and the iron, and send that torchiere lamp to live with a starving student somewhere.

Sorry but its too big and the fabric isn't helping. Grover's ideas make it better but still too big.

I'm sorry but it is not just the arms. Each piece of the chair has pattern running in different directions. Your sofa is beautiful, very elegant but the size and directions of the fabric pattern on the chair do not complement it. Since it seems like the chair will need to be reupholstered, I would suggest you choose a new fabric, still with the bright colours of this fabric, but in a smaller less dramatic pattern.

Chair & sofa work very well together. I'm thinking the scale of the pattern in the rug and the scale of the pattern in the chair are too similar/alike to each other, & are competing with each other. A larger rug which both the chair & sofa can be placed on together will also tie the two together & make the room look more cohesive.

*I like the room groveraxle did for your, burlap rug, fun art, interesting floor lamp, nice drapes. --very good.

Poster above is right that chair needs to be sent back and redone with pattern matching!! It goes and all the advice about lighter drapes and larger lighter rug are spot on!

Can you send more pics of the room. Sometimes zooming in on just a little section gives the wrong impression of the room.

In the first photos For some reason, I hadn't immediately noticed that the pattern was going in different directions on the arms than the seat & backrest, but now I can notice it in the new photos taken head on. I also notice the pattern on the seat cushion looks like it was not centered and is off center. Looks like someone didn't know what they were doing, or were careless when they upholstered this. I also agree with others that a smaller pattern may be better on this particular chair. Overall when I look at the chair though, I still see a nice chair in nice colors which goes with the sofa well, but I do hope they will fix the issues for you.

Grover's suggestion is spot on. The rug is too busy for the busy chair. Let us know what happens. I'm sure you paid a lot of $$ to get it done and they didn't do the right thing with the fabric.

Glad that the upholsterer did the right thing for you. Keep us updated.

Sommers Sommers, Glad it worked out for you in the end! Sometimes it works out to be true that 'the squeaky wheel gets the oil!' Please post more photos when everything new is added to the room!