Houzz Logo Print
andreap_gw

Pay it forward?

8 years ago

Today I went grocery shopping and I know I had a cold and did not look my best but I was dressed properly, but the lady in front of me at the cash register turned and gave me a 50 dollar bill and said, "here, use this for your groceries." I was flabbergasted. I don't need her money and now feel I should pass it on. Has this ever happened to you? I know someone who needs 4,000. to pay off a DWI debt but I already sent her money and she still owes. I can't stand feeling indebted. Maybe I'll go down to where the homeless people at the mall hang out and give it one of them? Is this a trend?

Comments (30)

  • 8 years ago

    Sometimes people just feel good surprising others with a good deed. Use it however you wish. My preference would be to let the person paying off the DWI use her own resources to do so. And if i wanted to help homeless, I'd buy food and distribute instead of cash, or give the money to a charity that helps feed/house people. Too many homeless in our community are drug addicted and would just use cash to feed their addiction. I want no part of enabling that, but there are differing views about giving cash to homeless.

    andreap thanked Olychick
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    andreap, what made you grasp the money and take it? That was a choice you made, no? Give it to charity.

    I agree with olychick. I believe strongly that our society should offer everyone every opportunity and open doors for all to work hard for a better life. Those who choose to not do so are entitled to the life that results in as far as I'm concerned, I feel no guilt or obligation to help otherwise able-bodied people who'd rather do nothing.

    Yes, some are homeless because of mental illness, bad luck, broken homes. There are plenty of hard working agencies who can provide help and care for such persons with money contributions they receive.

    andreap thanked Elmer J Fudd
  • Related Discussions

    'Pay it Forward' Offer

    Q

    Comments (13)
    What a wonderful idea! I am already planning to do this, this season, with tomatoes, zucchini and beans. I would love any supplements to further our 'cause'! We have a wonderful food pantry here that has, in the past year alone, nearly doubled its' applicants that need more food in hard times. Times are tough for many families right now. It's a great idea to remind others that we're put here to help each other! ~Wendy / sassyb
    ...See More

    Giving back and paying forward

    Q

    Comments (1)
    Moving down
    ...See More

    Paying it forward

    Q

    Comments (3)
    Yes,Yes,Yes!!! I was especially wanting the pea vine & mine didn't form seeds last year! I will email you...thank you for the offer!!!
    ...See More

    North Dakota Bank employees to Pay it Forward

    Q

    Comments (13)
    Each employee also received a digital video camera with which to record their project. In addition to the "Pay It Forward" gift, employees also receive year-end cash bonuses totaling 5 percent of the bank's earnings for themselves. From article; "The bank's act of kindness has had unexpected consequences. Reif said that at his branch alone, about 50 people have called wanting to open an account because they were so taken by the gesture." Yeah, 'unexpected'. Riiiiiight. That's why they hired an Oprah look-a-like with a duplicate set, to host the announcement. The whole thing is a marketing ploy and I would love to revisit this thread July 1, 2008 to see what great deeds have been performed. Is the list going to be made public? The employees get free money to give to whomever they want, and the whole thing is a huge tax write-off for the bank garnering tons of publicity to attract investors to the bank. I'd be more impressed if each one of them donated a kidney or something. Or banded together to forgo their hefty end of the year bonus and donated that. Call me a cynic and a realist. Here is a link that might be useful: Oprah Look-a-Like and Bank Officer
    ...See More
  • 8 years ago

    Oh My. I wonder if lip gloss might have helped LOL. I've had people offer assistance when I was on crutches, but assistance shopping, opening the door, putting my groceries in my car. I must have managed to look broken, not broke.

    Kidding aside, I would give a windfall to a food bank, a shelter, a school lunch or foster childrens program. It's a complicated debate but I think most would agree the reasons for being homeless could be varied - I wouldn't know if I was putting the money into the right hands, enabling a runaway or as Olychick said, fueling an addiction one more day.

    While you sound like a loyal friend, I wouldn't likely contribute to a driving under influence fine or expenses either. The penalties for getting behind the wheel after drinks shouldn't be a surprise to anyone these days. Their choice, their consequence.

    andreap thanked morz8 - Washington Coast
  • 8 years ago

    I did not grasp the money. She pretty much shoved it at me and rushed away. I give to charities all year long via checks and have given material goods to people in need as well. I'm just not familiar with receiving cash from or giving cash to random strangers. This 50 dollars is burning a hole in my purse and me because I feel I don't deserve it from someone I don't know. So maybe next time I go there I'll pass it on. I was a bit too tired or untethered to think of that today. But I'd hate to put someone else through this. I just want to pass it on!

  • 8 years ago

    I would give it to a non profit I felt good about. For me it would probably be Guide Dogs for the Blind or an animal care center I trusted.

    Helping someone pay off a DWI does them no service in my opinion. I don't understand why you would want to. I call that enabling not helping.

    I am with Elmer and Olychick. I do understand how you might have been stunned and froze when she thrust the money at you however. Now do something good with it.

    andreap thanked wildchild2x2
  • 8 years ago

    My grocery store does a program where you can buy a prepackaged bag of food to be given to a local program that sends food home for the weekend with children who qualify for reduced lunch at school. If you recieved the money there and want to pay it forward there, maybe something like that exists in your store. Or, to keep it food related, the next time you eat out pay for another table’s meal or the cars behind you in the drive through lane.

    But yes, it is a new trend- not shoving money at strangers, that’s kinda awkward. There is a movement called Random Acts of Kindness encouraging people to cultivate a habit of being kind, i.e. paying for the person behind you or letting a struggling mom go first in line. However awkward the encounter may have been, it was probably meant in kindness. Pay it forward; there are lots of ideas at https://www.randomactsofkindness.org/

    andreap thanked aviastar 7A Virginia
  • 8 years ago

    I agree with Avia. Lately, I'm not as quick to just hand over cash. (Although Christmas time a man approached me in the parking lot of my gym. I gave him $20.)

    You can buy groceries and bring the food to the food bank. Buy supplies that an animal shelter can use etc.

    andreap thanked eld6161
  • 8 years ago

    "Grasp the money", Elmer. Really? That's quite insulting.

    I personally would give it to a dog shelter. I donate to several, Hope for Paws is a great one. Also Rescue Road trips. Both groups are on facebook and have videos that tug at heart strings.

    As to the "friend" with a DWI, no no no! My local communities have facebook groups that post arrests and convictions and such. You would not believe the lax penalties for DWI, especially people with multiple. These people get a slap on the wrist for multiple DWIs, probation many times. Free to drink and drive over and over. It enrages me, but the correctional institutes are too full to incarcerate.

    andreap thanked sleeperblues
  • 8 years ago

    I would have thanked her but told her there were surely people in more need of the money than you. I would have suggested she donate it to a local food bank or homeless shelter.

  • 8 years ago

    A big thing people are doing in Canada is going to Tim Hortons and giving the cashier money to pay for the coffees of how ever many people that will pay for. You may want to go to a Dunkn Donuts (forgive my spelling,) or Krispie Kreme had the cashier the $50 and tell her/him it's to pay for $50 worth of coffee for the next however many people order coffee.

  • 8 years ago

    Sounds like it was a nice if awkwardly made gesture. I also don't give much cash to charities. So, I'd keep the $50 as 'cash on hand' for myself, and increase my next check or credit card donation.

    I'd rather get a "free" cup of coffee from a stranger. That would make me smile, without second-guessing my appearance!

    andreap thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Regardless of the why’s, it was a nice gester on her part. If it were me, I’d hold on to it until I saw an elderly person who’s struggling and use it to help pay for their groceries instead. I’m not in a traditional grocery store often, but at least two to three times a year, I witness an elderly person having to put groceries back at the register because they are short on funds. It always pings at my heart, so if I’m close enough, I’ll ask the checker to ring it through and either give the additional cash to the cashier or I’ll just pay the bill for their groceries.

    andreap thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Did you 'bury the money' for New Years?? LOL.

  • 8 years ago

    Animal shelters are worthy. Please make a check payable to your nearest shelter.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I've never understood the "pay it forward" sentiment, it always has seemed like some form of public exhibitionism to me. Keep your hands to yourself, don't stare, and keep your money in your pocket/purse - good advice always. If you want to encourage thoughtfulness to others and charity, give out prepaid envelopes to the local humane society.

    Sleeperblues, you bust me for perhaps inelegant language (though maybe not, it doesn't seem a problem to me this morning) that I used at 11 pm, just before my bedtime? Okay, so be it.

  • 8 years ago

    Why pay it forward? See Satine's post - that's why.

  • 8 years ago

    skibby, one event had nothing directly to do with the other.

  • 8 years ago

    Elmer, thanks for clarifying that. You know we are usually of the same mind.

  • 8 years ago

    Elmer, I see what you are saying. Although I do like hearing these stories, I can't help but believe that some are self-serving. "Look what I did!"

    If you do good, you certainly don't have to agree to have your picture taken to go along with the story.

    The little girls who donate their hair to Locks of Love come to mind. My DD did it three times, quietly, without a public announcement! Okay, so part of this can be a good advertisement for the cause. But, an anonymous picture of the back of a child's head getting the ponytail cut would serve the same purpose.

    I particularly like the random acts that Avia posted and Lukki gave an example of how she does it.


  • 8 years ago

    Of course it's very often a self-serving insincere chest pounding. It's showing off, look what I can do, I have so much money! Especially the extreme cases, the $50 or $500+ tip for a $50 restaurant bill.


    Quietly helping an obviously needy person to pay a grocery bill, that's admirable. A lot of major charitable giving is done anonymously - that's the classiest way of all

  • 8 years ago

    I wouldn't force it. You'll know when you need to pass it on.

  • 8 years ago

    Dang it, I need to stop going through the "self" check out. LOL I would keep in your wallet and pass it on sometime. Like adellabedella said, you'll know when the time is right :-)

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, all. I agree. I'll wait and pass it on when the situation seems right.

  • 8 years ago

    A couple of years ago a guy in the line ahead of me and I had been talking a little and when I got to checkout the cashier said that he'd given $5.00 toward my grocery bill.

    I think it may have been when I was to attend a gathering of former missionaries and had been instructed to bring serviettes/napkins to help with lunch. I don't recall whether that may have been part of the conversation.

    A couple of times when someone was going to put some groceries back because they were short of funds, I've offered some help with the payment.

    Many of our grocery stores have a box by the exit where people can deposit some groceries to go to the food bank.

    If I buy a Dollars worth of groceries to put in there, I paid retail and I chose what to buy, possibly low on the food bank's priority list.

    A couple of times a year we can contribute cash at checkout to go to the food bank, so if I give 80 cents, the food bank can choose the items they need most, at wholesale price.

    If I go to the food bank and give them 80 cents, they choose the food they need most and get it wholesale. And they give me a receipt for 80 cents, and if I'm in 25% income tax bracket, it'll save me 20 cents at income tax time.

    I like to get $1.00 worth of charitable value ... for 60 cents out of my pocket.

    ole joyfuelled ... who doesn't mind using legitimate income tax deductions


  • 8 years ago

    It may very likely have had nothing to do with her perception of you, personally, but just that she was moved by her own inner voice to give you the money. And, if you believe in things happening for a purpose, perhaps its true need is the person to whom you pass it when you are moved to do so...without you having received this money, you may not (in that upcoming right moment) think to give money. Hope that makes sense outside of my head ;o)

  • 8 years ago

    A couple at our church has a grandson-in-law that is Iill with cancer. The lady was telling our ladies group about his struggles. They have 3 small children. She spoke of a special spoon for him. It has a cover that opens once it is at the mouth. The spoon cost is $50.00. I could not get this off my mind.. the next time I saw her I gave her the $50.00 to buy it. She cried and thanked me over and over. I love doing things like this. I am fortunate to be able to do things like this. I look at it that if for some reason I needed help someone would help me..

    We have a young couple that live next door to us. They have 4 small children. They are wonderful neighbors. We have a 10 acre field behind our home and we let them have the hay each summer for their animals and to sell some. Last year at Christmas they gave us a $100.00 bill in a card.. I told my husband we could not take that with them having 4 kids. We knew they would not take it back so when our town fair came to town I bought them $100.00 in tickets. It takes a lot to take 4 little ones. I took the tickets over to them and explained to them we could not take that much money from them. Kyle, the dad, is so good to help me when I need it. He knows we have needs sometimes. My husband was going to get up on the roof one day and I knew he had no business doing that. I came in the house and quickly called him. He had just bought a new tractor so he pretended to come show my husband. He asked Larry what he was doing. Kyle did it for us!! Husband didn’t know I called.

    There are so many ways to help others that cost so little.. we have been blessed in so many ways I just want to pass some things along..


  • 8 years ago

    I find giving is a good feeing too and have often responded to my neighborhood's e-list voicing requests for people in need. It is relief to know the stuff I don't need is appreciated and used. But I have never shoved money at a person who did not ask for it.

    It occurred to me that I was blowing my nose and had watery eyes as I was shopping and maybe the donor noticed that. How embarrassing. It is a cold and not the misery I used to have shopping the year or two after my husband died.

    It makes perfect sense, crazybrunette and susie. Thanks.

  • 8 years ago

    >>Of course it's very often a self-serving insincere chest pounding. It's showing off, look what I can do, I have so much money! Especially the extreme cases, the $50 or $500+ tip for a $50 restaurant bill.>>

    ???

    'self-serving'? Interesting to always be so quick to attribute bad motives to people.

  • 8 years ago

    I tend to cringe when I hear the "pay it forward" phrase. It's another term that's become so cliché. I hear often of people who go through a drive-thru and pay for the person behind them. I also hear of a number of times the person behind didn't get what was purchased.

    There's SO many good opportunities to make a contribution, help someone out, surprise them or whatever that I don't like the "pif" obligation. I guess the term offends me more than the act. There's been times I've asked if I could buy the coffee for some cops/fire fighters, National Guard members or others or if it's a trusted place, just do it. I know of people who can surely use a few bucks of assistance but some of them I like to give them something they dearly want but can't afford or won't spend the money themselves because of financial fears. I know one older lady who is on a very limited income. She's too proud to take money, and I understand that. But a gift of some Tide PODS to make her laundry chores easier is unbelievably appreciated As is stamps and an assortment of greeting cards. She enjoys writing cards to people. I just make one stipulation to her. Don't spend her stamps and card as a thank-you to me. I just say I'd much prefer to see her smile. A good friend buys his grandmother a small ham at holidays. Again, she loves ham but won't (or can't) buy it. He purposely gets a small one so it's not overpowering.

    And pets need help too and are often forgotten. For some reason this year I've contributed more to the various pet charities than ever before. Made me feel good.