Try to find Community, it's made in Louisiana. We strictly use the dark roast. Great coffee.

That is the brand I could not find. I have seen it is a store somewhere ( ?) in the mid-west but I can't recall where. I am keeping an eye open!

Interesting that you tried so many.

Many of these coffees are blends and are very different types and have differing flavor profiles from others. If comparing ice cream brands, it would be more telling to try chocolate from five different companies, rather than sampling five different flavors from one. You have various flavors from various companies.

In many parts of the US, the coffee flavor that has historically served as the "common standard" (and what was most frequently used in restaurants and canned and instant coffee brands and what most people prefer because of that) is the Western Hemisphere, Colombia-Brazil-Costa Rica types. These all taste rather comparable to one another. This flavor is most typical in the chain coffees like Tim Horton, Dunkin Donuts, etc, Your ratings show a bias in the Central-South American direction. The ones you like less well (that I know) have a less pronounced Western Hemisphere flavor.

If there is a local coffee roaster in your area, I wonder which beans you would prefer after sampling a small variety. Perhaps a Western Hemisphere type is what you like best.

I'll put in another good word for Community Coffee. I actually buy my beans online from CoffeeAM.com, usually either the Kenya or Sumatra Mandeheling. They roast and ship fresh. I grind my beans at home prior to brewing. But when I have to buy coffee in the grocery store I will either buy Seattle's Best or Community. Both are excellent IMO.

I have to say I have never had either of your two first place winners.

Gloria Jean's house blend was the Consumer Report's best coffee a few years ago. I buy it in Wisconsin. Tim Horton's is Canadian. I also buy whole beans and use a burr grinder.