On a quick look at the website, I think I saw that the recycled has 25% more substance. I did not even notice the prices. Are they 20% more in cost?

Anyway, I want to tell you that we have two large Waterhog mats (the recycled) and they are so sturdy. Small rugs elsewhere in the house have undergone multiple replacements over the years, but the Waterhogs just keep on going, still looking crisp and clean. Twice a year we wash, them hung over sawhorses, sprayed with the garden hose and a Dawn detergent solution.

One compliant is that it can be hard to get them to let loose of some bits of debris when vacuuming. It is not just my vacuum; I'm on my second vac and still have the same problem. I also saw mention of that at the LLBean website reviews before I purchased.

The other concern/complaint is that I've decided they do look a little "commercial", like something you might find at a store entry.

I can live with both complaints quite well because they just function so well. No sliding even without carpet tape. Wears like iron. Doesn't seem to stain. Doesn't crease or roll up at corners. Truly does catch the water, ice, snow, salt, dirt, sand, grass, pebbles, etc that otherwise might track through the house. A lifetime purchase.

thanks matthias, which design did u buy? i was looking at the diamond style...$120 is pricey....

If you Google there are some really pretty designs and colors not available on ll bean.

I have 2 ll bean water hog matts. They show no wear & one is at least 10 years old. I have a tan & charcoal. It is true the dark one doesn't vac as easy. I think the diamond design is deeper. I think they are worth the price.

What they said. We've had 2 in our mudroom for years. One for feet-wiping and one under the dog bowls. Unfortunately they do hold onto dog fur and the only vac that works well on it is my house cleaner's heavy duty one.