skip to main content

Pella 450 vs Andersen 200 series windows or other?

7 years ago

We just purchased a house and the windows need to be replaced. I currently have quotes from Lowes/HD for Pella 450 ($270 with in pane grille and screen) and Anderson 200 Series ($354 with in pane grille and screen). we can get about 15% off those prices through bulk purchasing, but thats what I am going off of for now.

How are the Pella 450 and Anderson 200 series thought of? I realize they are maybe a step above builders grade, but they seem like decent windows when I played around with them in the store (Andersen 200 felt a little better). Do you guys recommend I look into another brand? The Pella is cheaper, but will it be as good as the Andersen?

Featured Answer

Tech First
Original Author

7 years ago

last modified: 7 years ago

See I really don't get comments like yours winkster. First of we are not claiming Pella or Andersen 200s are top of the line. My folks have Andersen 200s in their custom $650k home and never had issues with air leakage (living in MD so fairly cold winters and pretty hot/humid summers) from the windows. A couple of the windows did fog/glaze up, but Andersen sent out replacements in a matter of days.

I got a quote on the 400 series and they are about $950 each. I'm sorry but I don't have $12k to blow on some top of the line window. There is a rational to buying quality windows, but there is a point of diminishing returns when you just end up paying for options you don't need. The average customer just wants a good solid window that won't blow the budget.

I ended up buying the 200 series windows and putting them in myself, was careful to properly seal and insulate around windows while installing. Paid about $3000 for 10 windows (Model # DH3049), with grille and bug screens (had a 10% off coupon HD honored and used my 5% discount with card). temps have been in the mid/upper 90s for two weeks and we just had a MASSIVE rain storm a week ago with winds up to 50 mph. No discernible water or air leakage. AC is running noticeably less too, and I don't notice a temp difference when I pass by a window like I could before! Its early still but I'm very happy with my Andersen 200s.

I have to replace a double exterior french door and am thinking about trying the 200 series for that too.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
7 years ago
The Andersen 200 isn't a bad little window in my opinion. I have always found it to be in pretty good shape and pretty sturdy.
Tech First
Original Author
7 years ago
Any opinions on the Pella 450? The brand seems to be having some issues, but I was curious what people thought of that particular line of windows.
Related Discussions
Andersen 200 Series as insert?
Q
Comments (8)
When I replaced my windows I think Woodwright was the only Andersen insert option. It now looks like you can get Tilt-Wash inserts and also a 100 Series window that can be installed as an insert - is that what you mean by "composite by Andersen"? I was looking for wood interiors. Marvin Ultimate was my first choice but they were a little too expensive for my budget. Andersen Woodwright was a close second and I have been very happy with them. I also looked at Harvey but the quality was a big step down from Marvin and Andersen. I didn't talk to Pella or Renewal by Andersen just because I didn't like their sales approaches. Can't comment on the Andersen 100 Series or other options - but I'm sure others will!
...See More
Pella Pro-Line (450 series) vs Marvin Integrity Cost difference
Q
Comments (9)
Leaps and bounds better quality IMO. The wood interior on the Integrity is largely isolated from moisture due to the fact that it's basically a fiberglass window with a veneer interior. The pella on the other hand is wood clad in its true definition. I've seen 10 year old Integritys that look good as new, while most pro lines are due for replacement around that time frame. Try to get a look at a corner cut of each to see what I'm talking about. Price wise the integrity is probably a little more, but should be in the same ballpark. I've sold and installed both
...See More
New Construction - Pella Proline vs Integrity vs Andersen
Q
Comments (10)
We don't care for the Integrity windows. They are the lowest line of Marvin and don't have the same features and look of the regular Marvin line. They have no exterior profile and look like trailer windows once installed. The regular Marvin line is nice quality. We use Pella and have had no problems. We are slowly replacing the windows in our own home with Pella. Some of them have been in for 4-5 years now and no problems with them. What I don't like about Pella is that the glass has more green tint to it than some other companies. We don't generally use Anderson so we have no experience with them. We have had to use them a time or two to match up with existing windows. Our real issue is with the companies here that sell them and the fact that they are hard to work with.
...See More
Krestmark 200 vs MI 3500 series windows
Q
Comments (3)
Both krestline and Mi windows are low quality garbage. You cannot beat the system and get quality at a cheap price, it doesnt work that way. I would not call andersen or pella top quality either. high end vinyl will yield the best energy efficiency at the best price. Look at soft lite , okna, sunrise, or kensington. those are all solid brands. If you want wood, look into marvin or kolbe.
...See More
millworkman
7 years ago
Anything Pella in general will get poor reviews from most any pro I am aware of.
freeoscar
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
who will be installing the windows, and what do they think? We faced the same choice and went with Andersen because our contractor used them more frequently. He was fine if we chose the Pella, but unless I really care about something, we default to what he is most comfortable with.

In general it seems that Pella have questionable reviews and lots of bad experiences.

I would add that the Pella 450 being less expensive than the Andersen is unusual in my experience. The Andersen 200s were about 20% less.
Tech First
Original Author
7 years ago
our GC likes simonton windows, but I don't like the feel of vinyl windows. Even the more expensive ones just feel kinda flimsy and cheap.

Any other thoughts on good vinyl clad wood windows? is the 200 series the best value out there right now or is there any other recommendations?
User
7 years ago
I'm in the same boat. I need some new windows and I have Anderson coming out soon. My husband had a Pella slider door installed about 10 years ago and it has preformed great. It wasn't cheap (2000k installed) but I'm happy with the quality so I'd give Pella a shot at the windows if they are cheaper than Anderson.

Here's how I look at it - I'm in a 90s builder grade home with the original windows. They have been just find for the last 16-17 years... And the original windows are just above "builder grade" so I'm sure Pella or Anderson will be a nice step up and perform just fine. I don't need nor want top of the line. I want decent quality at an affordable price. I don't care much about energy savings. In other words, I'm not spending lots of extra money for energy saving windows if it's going to take 10 years to break even.
User
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
First off, both the pella 450 and andersen 200 are builders grade in my opinion. Unlesss of course you prefer air leakage.

if you get an andersen, at least get the 400 series. Avoid tilt wash.

Your notion about taking 10 years to recoup your savings is complete hog wash. Perhaps a paper savings but what about the intangable savings you get by being more comfortable in your home. Would you rather feel the savings in comfort or just see it on some utility bill? What good is that ?

Especially on very hot and very cold days. Those 2 producrs wont do much for that.

this is a typical consumers rationale. Of course after a few years everyone complains about their new, cheap windows but never seem to blame themselves for their poor choice.
User
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
No offense tech first, but i find your claims very hard to believe. I grew up in this industry and stand by my comments.

Related Stories

REMODELING GUIDES Which Window for Your World?

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

The view and fresh air from your windows make a huge impact on the experience of being in your house

REMODELING GUIDES Top 10 Solutions for Architectural Peeves

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

Cavelike hallways, immovable shutters, poorly proportioned doors ... avoid these and other common gaffes with these renovation solutions

DECORATING GUIDES Budget Decorator: How to Save When You Don’t DIY

By Laura Gaskill

You don’t have to be crafty to decorate your home inexpensively. Here are other ways to stretch your design dollars

MIDCENTURY STYLE Houzz Tour: Addicted to Iconic Furniture in Houston

By Annie Thornton

Most people buy furniture to fit their homes. This collector of midcentury modern pieces takes a different approach

HOUZZ TOURS Houzz Tour: Let's Be Transparent Here

Expansive glass and a new floor plan celebrate a midcentury modern home's openness and connection to nature

GREAT HOME PROJECTS 25 Great Home Projects and What They Cost

By Mitchell Parker

Get the closet of your dreams, add a secret doorway and more. Learn the ins and outs of projects that will make your home better

KITCHEN DESIGN How to Choose the Right Hood Fan for Your Kitchen

By The Sky is the Limit Design

Keep your kitchen clean and your home's air fresh by understanding all the options for ventilating via a hood fan

GREEN BUILDING Houzz Tour: Pickle Factory Now an Energy-Wise Live-Work Space

By Carol Crotta

A charming but poorly insulated 1880s Philadelphia commercial building becomes a spacious energy-efficient home and studio

HOUZZ TOURS My Houzz: Updated Federal Style in Massachusetts

By Mary Prince Photography

This spacious 18th-century home artfully combines traditional and modern design

MOST POPULAR Find the Right Glass Door for Your Patio

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

It’s more than just a patio door — it’s an architectural design element. Here’s help for finding the right one for your home and lifestyle

Sponsored

More Discussions

Are Marvin windows hard to open?

23

mudroom door through Marvin windows

2

Muntins or no muntins?

21

Design Help for Old House Window Bank

1

Milgard Ultra C650 vs Marvin Infinity

0