skip to main content

Hiring architects and GCs

7 years ago

I have plans for kitchen/bath remodel drawn by my KD, which involves removing non-load bearing walls in my 1915 bungalow. More detailed drawings are needed for city permits. I've been talking to 3 GCs who have done work for neighbors:

GC #1: Gave me an estimate within my budget, seems good to work with. He referred me to an architect to do drawings as a next step.

GC #2: Walked through the KD plans and my house but wouldn't do an estimate without the structural drawings and referred me to his architect. He thought my budget sounded tight. He seems like the highest quality, though I'm worried he will be too expensive, and I won't know that until I get the drawings and he does the estimate.

GC #3: I'm waiting to get his estimate.

It seems like the next steps are deciding on a GC and getting drawings--does it matter what order I do it in? Are there any issues if I hire GC #1's preferred architect, but end up wanting to hire GC #2 or #3? I'm happy with the KD's design, so not anticipating needing the architect to do much more than drawings.

Featured Answer

Katrina Tate

7 years ago

last modified: 7 years ago

How are the GC's giving you estimates based on these plans? Did they all visit the site? I ask because the KD plans have only a couple of measurements. I picked my GC first after interviewing like 15 GCs. My GC and architect did not know each other. I picked my architect based on a referral from an engineer friend.

Here are my architectural drawings. We are knocking down several non-load bearing walls. My renovation had to be filed with the department of buildings.

Demo

Renovated space

Electric plan

0

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
7 years ago
Focus on vetting and hiring the best GC for you then follow their recommendations for architects.
0
Fori
7 years ago
It shouldn't matter which architect you use, and you'll get better estimates once you have drawings. Sometimes a GC will have a good relationship and work well with a particular architect which can be nice, but if everyone is professional any architect should be able to work with any GC. (But you have to LIVE with the GC so if yours has a preference, it might be good to go along with it.)

Are you sure you need an actual architect to do these drawings? It sounds like you might be able to get by with a less expensive source of drawings. If your city's permit office is helpful, ask them if an actual architect is required. This just doesn't seem like a job for one, and they are not inexpensive!
0
Related Discussions
Hiring a construction manager vs. GC
Q
Comments (18)
ctycdm, thanks for sharing your experience. We've spoken to several people that have done large scale renovations or built homes in our area and many of them have had that same arrangement with their construction or project manager. I personally like the idea as it allows for the homeowner to have a greater level of involvement and control. I don't follow the assumption that those who choose to be project managers are failed general contractors because that's the exact opposite conclusion we've reached -- it's a beneficial arrangement for both homeowner and the licensed contractor. jellytoast, thanks, we did it too on our last remodel. I like the idea of being here when the inspector comes over to make sure my subs are doing things properly. It makes sense for it to be in the homeowner's names. gladys1924, thanks for sharing your experience. sounds like it worked out well for you -- we are looking at a similar arrangement, and as Gaucho points out, having someone you trust on site is key. Trebruchet, we're not in FL so that's not an issue - the permit will be in our name.
...See More
How prepared do you need to be before hiring your GC?
Q
Comments (7)
I agree with kptwin...the more specific you can be, the better and more accurate your bid will be. And it will send a message to your GC that you know what you want, and tell him not to pull the wool over your eyes. Be very careful out there...there is more shoddy work by contractors than ever before. Take your time finding someone, get at least 5 bids, including design/build (but they are usually more expensive). Hold firm to your wants and needs, and don't budge if the GC cannot or will not give you the exact fixture or appliance brand you want. Just have him pull it from the bid or give you an allowance for it...then go and buy it yourself. In fact, you may be able to get most things cheaper than your GC can. Many GC's are heading in that direction nowadays...with the internet and GC supply houses that are open to the public, you can usually get his discount without his markup...all for being willing to do the research, pay the invoice, and bring the materials back to the job site. Saves him a lot of work and paperwork. Even if he doesn't charge you markup on materials, he'll make it up with higher labor charges. They will try to get their money somehow. The bigger stuff...like windows, doors, etc...you can work with him and see what he recommends. Be careful of certain large companies like Milgard which pay the biggest commissions and kickbacks to GC's. They are not necessarily the best windows, nor the cheapest. As for flooring, if it's wood, know exactly what species you'd like, as well as what grade and stain/finish. For other solid floorings, know what brand and color. Same for countertop materials. Check out Costco if there is one near you...you might be able to get cabinets/countertops, windows, blinds, closet systems, etc...much cheaper. And know exactly what paint brand and color you'd like him to use. The more you know, the less likely you'll end up with builder-grade materials.
...See More
Architect vs GC
Q
Comments (6)
Yes, my gc came recommended and for the most part, I trust him. It does worry me a that he would completely change the front entry of a two story house without so much as making a phone call to us or to the architect.... He just took it upon himself to make a major changes, which in the end I still don't quite understand... He thought it would "look" better, that is why he was going to change it. I was available and could have been there in 15 minutes, if he had called me. Luckily, I happened by that day and it could be fixed before he went any farther. I appreciate that he wanted my house to look good, but I would like him to run it past me before making changes to our plans that we have worked hard on. We've been in this house for 32 years, I've always disliked the entry and have put a lot of thought into this part of our remodel. The 5 windows alone being used around the front door are costing over $17,000. He was basically rearranging the windows for us. I also want to still be friends with the gc when the job is finished.
...See More
Permits / Notice of Corrrection/ Hiring GC to help
Q
Comments (22)
We had a home inspection before purchase by a great home inspector (and also separate sewer and chimney inspections as well). It is not the job of a private home inspector to research or verify permitting issues - there are even disclaimers on their contracts that state this. Our RE agent did look into permit history but we had no disclosure from the seller that they did work for which permits are required without the permits. Licensed RE agents are not required to know the ins and outs of the LADBS building codes. I understand that we may have a legal route to take but the reality is right now we need to do the work and get the permits. This is our house and we are now stuck with the correction notice. Beyond that, we can't wait until legal action is taken (it could take years) to fix this problem for the reasons indicated in my original post. I think we will be able to get the final permits from the trades who did work for us (small job plumbing + elec permits) once we straighten this whole thing out. I think we just have to keep looking until we find a qualified licensed GC willing to take the job. Someone out there needs the work and the paycheck. We can then work on pursuing the seller for reimbursement. This post was edited by tinyone22 on Fri, Aug 22, 14 at 12:36
...See More
caligirl5
Original Author
7 years ago
I did go to the permit office yesterday to ask about what is needed. They said my KD drawings are missing some necessary detail, but that anyone can do the drawings--it doesn't need to be an architect. Looking again at the referrals from the GCs, 1 is an architect and the other is some kind of designer.
0
User
7 years ago
You will get better, more accurate, quotes if you are pricing out the architectural drawings to the contractors instead of doing it in the reverse. All you are getting at this point are non binding guesstimates. Which are probably 20-30% low, as is fairly standard without detailed plans from which to bid.
0
caligirl5
Original Author
7 years ago
Could you guys give me some examples of what the architectural drawings include that affect the pricing? I know they would have the framing details, which the city needs--does the GC need those if they're not load bearing walls?

Below are some pages from the KD plans, to give you an idea of what I'm giving the GCs now. For materials, we talk about the bigger expenses in the meeting (cabinets, countertops, flooring). I realize there's other small stuff that can add up--my budget is $100K, so I feel like if the estimate is accurate for labor, framing, and the major materials, that would be close enough even if they underestimated the rest. I'm working on a spreadsheet for fixtures, lighting, etc.

Thanks in advance--not sure what I would do without all the advice on this forum!

There's an elevation like the one below for each wall. Also 3D visuals.
0
caligirl5
Original Author
7 years ago
Thanks for sharing! Yes, they all came to the house. The elevations have all the measurements, though I see they're not on the aerial view like in your architectural drawings. The aerial view is to scale, I just accidentally cropped the scale when I cropped out my name and the KD's to post here, oops :)

Related Stories

WORKING WITH PROS How to Hire the Right Architect: Comparing Fees

By Dylan Chappell Architects

Learn common fee structures architects use and why you might choose one over another

WORKING WITH PROS How to Hire the Right Architect

By Dylan Chappell Architects

Your perfect match is out there. Here’s how to find good candidates — and what to ask at that first interview

LANDSCAPE DESIGN How to Hire a Landscape Architect

By Falon Mihalic

Find the best fit for your landscaping project with this guide to evaluating and selecting a pro

WORKING WITH PROS 5 Steps to Help You Hire the Right Contractor

By Dylan Chappell Architects

Don't take chances on this all-important team member. Find the best general contractor for your remodel or new build by heeding this advice

WORKING WITH PROS 6 Reasons to Hire a Home Design Professional

By Incite Design

Doing a construction project without an architect, a designer or a design-build pro can be a missed opportunity

LANDSCAPE DESIGN How to Find and Hire a Great Landscape Contractor

By Falon Mihalic

Get your landscape project built on time and on budget by hiring a quality professional

ARCHITECTURE Design Practice: How to Get Hired

By Eric Reinholdt, Architect

Pro to pro: Strategies for winning a client’s trust and getting work that supports your brand

WORKING WITH PROS How to Hire an Architectural Photographer

Pro to pro: Great project photos can boost business. Get the details on finding the right photographer for your project

WORKING WITH PROS What Do Landscape Architects Do?

By Falon Mihalic

There are many misconceptions about what landscape architects do. Learn what they bring to a project

DECORATING GUIDES Decorating 101: Do It Yourself or Hire a Pro?

Learn the advantages and disadvantages of decorating alone and bringing in skilled help

Sponsored

Nova Design Build

Custom Premiere Design-Build Contractor | Hilliard, OH

More Discussions

Help with kitchen design

13

Kitchen Cabinet Advice

6

Kitchen floor tile advice

10

beverage faucet

1

Kitchen cabinets to the ceiling and cover a window?

19