Can a silpat be trimmed to fit your pan?

8 years ago

I've googled this and am seeing answers of YES and NO. Have you ever trimmed one down to fit your pan and was it successful? I'm wondering if the No answers are stemming from the "do not cut on the silpat" instructions, which is to say "it's not a cutting board"!

Featured Answer

grainlady_ks

8 years ago

NO! Cutting it will destroy the woven texture and it will fall apart. Plus you risk getting bits of the mat in your baked goods.

When I "cut" dough on a Silpat I use a stiff plastic tool (like a bowl scraper, spatula, plastic lettuce knife, plastic bar-cookie cutting knife....) that won't damage or cut the mat. To "cut" cinnamon rolls I use dental floss, and I form the dough log on the Silpat.

The mats come in a variety of sizes, so I have a number of them, and I have a variety of pans to hold them for different tasks. I love my 10", eight-sided, Silpat for forming small amounts of dough and scones on.

A "World Cuisine" silicon mat is actually a little thicker than a Silpat, and my first choice when making peanut brittle. The hot molten sugar/nut mixture won't stick to a silicon mat and it's easy to remove when cool.

I line a rimmed cookie sheet with one when I bake meatballs. Clean-up is a breeze.

-Grainlady

Comments (7)

User
8 years ago
I would never cut it. Get a bigger pan.
arkansas girl thanked User
Related Discussions
WARNING: Silpat, induction and wok do not mix!
Q
Comments (25)
Silicone rubber is pretty inert to most chemicals, but it does dissolve slowly when subjected to silicon oil. Either silicone brake fluid (DOT 5), or various silicone sprays should aid removal of silicone rubber bonded to your wok. If the oil you use works for you it will probably also remove any silicone rubber from the cooktop without damaging the glass, but the operative word here is probably. Obviously, remove all the silicone oil before cooking on the hob. Remove oil, if any, from the cooktop with the provided cleaning solution (provided at least in the case of the Kenmore). Remove from the wok with detergent, or auto body paint prep cleaner, e.g., duPont 3900S. By the way, another datum for this topic. DW left the house one day with the tea kettle on high on our Kenmore induction cooktop. When the kettle ran out of water, it heated the silicone pad beyond its limit. Fortunately, the cooktop shut down on its own. Maybe a hob temperature sensor is included in the Kenmore. We removed the silicon pad from service due to elastomer breakdown, but it did not end up sticking to either kettle or hob. The pad being used was the Sili Gourmet silicone bake liner, by William Bounds, Ltd. These are all-red silicone (no transparent part). kas
...See More
What Size Pots/Pans fit Max Burton Portable Induction Unit?
Q
Comments (19)
Definitely need to stir porridges with MB units. Ran an experiment this morning with cooking oatmeal in a small, 1 qt saucepan (5" diameter magnetic base). The MB had trouble with low heat settings with the small saucepan. At a "2" setting, the small pan would intermittently boil furiously in a torodial pattern and then shut down, boil, shut down, etc. A "3" setting was manageable with frequent stirring. With the previous experiment with the 2 qt sauce pan, the small bubbles started out in a ring shaped band, but quickly spread across the whole bottom and gave an very even boiling. Did not think to look with smaller pan this am, but note the cooking description above. I agree that overnight in a crockpot is much the better way to cook steel cut oats. I was only experimenting because of amck's posting. I use my MB for pretty much the same reasons you do and for "cooking stations" at some large parties. Sounds like Tuesday Morning could be a good deal. We used to have one in the nearest big town (actually, our state's largest city), but they pulled out a year ago. Apparently, our market area was deemed too small for the turnover they wanted.
...See More
kas - use of silpat on induction cooktop?
Q
Comments (24)
Kas You have a lovely set up there. However, in my experience the induction cooktops are super easy to care for. I wipe mine down with the washcloth after doing the dishes, spritz it with "multi-surface cleaner" to remove the streaks and only use the cooktop cleaner when I start to see a sort of film over the cooking surfaces. Routine daily cleaning takes about 30 seconds. It's as good as new, if you ignore the stainless at the front and back. I followed the instructions when I first installed mine for a while, but decided I'd rather tolerate a little wear. However, there is still no evidence of wear after this amount of time. I don't want to discourage anyone from selecting induction because the think it is fragile or requires difficult care. It isn't and it doesn't. The thing is the absolute bomb in my experience. It's wonderful for cooking and easy-peasy for clean up. We're house hunting again and I don't want a kitchen with one of those big, fancy gas ranges ... now the racing red Viking induction range would be another matter!
...See More
Does your Springform pan leak?
Q
Comments (26)
Do your ears hang low? Do they wobble to and fro? Can you tie them in a knot? Can you tie them in a bow? Can you throw them over your shoulder? Like a continental soldier? Do your ears hang low? Do your ears flip flop? Can you use them for a mop? Are they stringy at the bottom? Are they curly at the top? Can you use them for a swatter? Can you use them for a blotter? Do your ears flip flop? Do your ears hang high? Do they reach up to the sky? Do they droop when they're wet Do they stiffen when they're dry? Can you semaphore your neighbor With a minimum of labor? Do your ears hang high? Do your ears hang wide? Do they flap from side to side? Do they wave in the breeze With the slightest little sneeze? Can you soar above the nation? With a feeling of elation? Do your ears hang wide? Do your ears fall off? Does it happen when you cough? Do they lie there on the ground? Or bounce around at every sound? Can you stick them in your pocket Like a little Davey Crockett? Do your ears fall off?
...See More
plllog
8 years ago
Absolutely to what Grainlady said. There are also silicone mats, however, that don't have the fiberglass mesh in them. They're just silicone. The surface feel is different--I don't know if there's a performance difference--but those can be trimmed. It's the fiberglass mesh that prevents you from doing it with the Silpat and similar. The no cutting on it is a different but related story. Yes, it's so you don't cut down to the mesh and get fiberglass in your food, but it's also because you'll cut the silicone (which doesn't heal, though it may look as if it does) and both trap particles with bacteria and decay, and also interfere with the non-stick-ness.
arkansas girl thanked plllog
arkansas girl
Original Author
8 years ago
Sounds pretty unanimous then. I personally just use parchment paper, I was asking for a friend, it had come up in conversation today. It's amazing what different answers you can get while reading chowhound and other forums. People went so far as to say that America's Test Kitchen said they could see no reason why not and thought the idea that you could not cut them to size was preposterous. Quoted from memory only...probably went a bit differently but was basically what they said. It makes sense if they have the fibers that would mess them up to cut the fibers.

Couldn't the mat hang over the side of a flat cookie sheet, assuming it's not way larger than the pan?
User
8 years ago
It can hang over. You just don't want to crease the mat.
PRO
Lars/J. Robert Scott
8 years ago
Silpat comes in a variety of sizes. Get the size that fits your pan, but do not cut the Silpat, for reasons already explained.
plllog
8 years ago
Maybe ATK were looking at the ones that don't have the mesh?

So long as it doesn't prevent airflow from being all the way to the walls of the oven, there's no reason the Silpat couldn't overhang the edges of a sheet at cookie temperatures. If you're pushing the useable temperature (well over 400° F), the racks could just possibly get too hot. Probably wouldn't but just possibly.

Most parchment is coated with silicone, so really much the same thing. :) (If it's not silicone, it's nearly always latex. That would the be the "plant based" ones.)

Can a silpat be trimmed to fit your pan?

grainlady_ks

Comments (7)

User

Related Discussions

plllog

arkansas girl
Original Author

User

Lars/J. Robert Scott

plllog

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Can a silpat be trimmed to fit your pan?

grainlady_ks

Comments (7)

User

Related Discussions

plllog

arkansas girlOriginal Author

User

Lars/J. Robert Scott

plllog

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

arkansas girl
Original Author