I do like lands end for clothes for the kids, but their comforters are not really rated very good. Same with company store :( I used to love their things. I suppose I could try this charter club one charterclub down

I have an Ikea comforter (sorry, don't remember which one) that I bought about 5 years ago. I found this Reddit conversation about Ikea quality from about 7 months ago.

I also found this article reviewing down comforters from the Sweet Home.

I purchased my summer weight duvet from Dania Down. Having had a winter weight in the past I knew this weight would be perfect for me. I did have to (hand) sew loops of narrow gros grain ribbon in each corner to anchor it in the duvet cover. No problems after 5 years of use from October through April each year. Dania Down

IKEA has ones that are priced for use by kids. Then if they soil them, you won't be out too much. My college kids have ones from there and like them.

We bought queen down blankets from Company Store last fall and they came out beautifully from the wash. Their blanket fabric has fewer threads per inch than their comforters so a few feathers did escape last winter, but none since they were washed a month ago. We got really good prices on them by buying colors from their spring collection.

I use good flannel sheets, the down blanket, and my light weight summer comforter and never had to put PJs on all last winter. In summer I switch to cotton sheets and take off the down blanket.

Another Company Store regular.

I think our down comforter was also the one you're referring to because when we had to replace it, it was not longer carried as well. I bought and returned a couple looking for one similar in weight and feel and finally ended up getting ours from Sam's Club. It feels like an even match but I don't recall the brand.

I bought the ikea down comforter for my guest room in my FL house and my MIL commented that it was "noisy." I switched it out for one from Bonton (just a basic one, bought when I had a $50 off $100 coupon) and I had no further comments on noise.

I don't remember where I got the one on my bed.

Ours are from the company store, but a few years old so I couldn't say about their current quality. I would feel confident buying from llbean, as they really do mean their guarantee. (And in the years I have been buying kids' clothes LE quality has gone down, IMO, but LLBean quality has not gone down.)

I purchased my down comforters from Dewoolfson down. I purchased a synthetic down comforter two years ago for two bedrooms from Cuddledown. They are lightweight and stay really warm. They were roughly $400 for a king size but usually on sale for 20% off. Consider the synthetic down for ease of cleaning and it being non allergenic.

Batiste Cuddledown Comforter

Good luck!

My down comforter was bought online from Eddie Bauer 3-4 years ago.

They have several choices and I have a "light" version because we live in a moderate climate.

Eddie Bauer Comforters

I just bought the Hotel Collection medium weight down comforter from Macy's during their huge sale in early October. It's fantastic. Dh and I love it. Excellent quality, fluffy, and very warm. Our old comforter was a lightweight down, and was never that warm. I'm used to being cold at night most of the time, and always wore warm pjs and would add a blanket from fall to spring. With this comforter pjs are not necessary. I'm too hot with them, and I'd boil with a blanket. Such a nice change!

Eddie Bauer is available at Sam's too. I wonder if that's what we got, I'll have to check.

Can I add too that it's all about the fill. It comes in a variety of types and weights. I did some research on it when we needed ours and some of the ones I returned were returned because they didn't have enough fill for the cold winters we have, including Costco's brand. Some of the corners in their comforter didn't even have fill in them!

My point is, before you buy, find out what you actually need for the climate you live in, your price points will vary accordingly.

Information about buying down comforters

The Company Store sells their down comforters by weight/bedroom temperature. You can select the one that suits your needs. We have had ours for years and they are wonderful. We keep our night temperatures around 50-55 degrees in the winter. I actually use mine year round because my DH likes the ac at a low temp in the summer!

Just wanted to mention that for the Dewoolfson down, I selected the Southern Light. In the Cuddledown, I selected the summer weight. I live in Maryland and winters can be quite cold. These keep us very warm.

Good luck!

I started using duvets when I lived in Switzerland thirty years ago. I have two medium weight duvets I got from The Company Store, one in 1991, one about ten years ago. Both are still in daily use, still warm and cozy, no down escapes except a little fuzz when I run them through the dryer, and they're light, light, light. I got a cheaper one from Overstock.com once, but the down wasn't as nice.

Another voice for IKEA. We just bought six ikea beds, mattresses, comforters and duvet covers for our new snowbird house in Arizona. Down alternative in varying weights in small increments. No noise whatsoever. Love and so comfy. Great storage in brimnes headboard with underbed drawers.

Weight isn't always the decision to buy. The amount of true "down" is what will determine warmth and weight. Plus the cover material. I bought two down comforters 15 years ago and they are still in great condition. Couldn't find them to buy another until recently, but they are called FairyDown from the UK. You can get them online now and still at a very good price. I also bought a sheep wool mattress cover, they are wonderful to sleep on. With this company you will know also where the down came from.

Thank you all. tremendously helpful as usual! I was dead set on getting two full beds for this room. Luckily? My son is sick this week so I have been sleeping in there on a queen size blow up bed and him in a toddler bed. I really think two full beds will not work and it will be too tight. Even if we are just using it as a sleeping room. So now I have to figure that out. I guess it will save some money, but I am just not so sure how twin beds will be for the kids (and us if we have to be in there sometimes! :)

I bought mine from Lands End last year. I think it was $199 for queen size. It has box stitching (prevents shifting) and tabs (to tie in a duvet). Can't go wrong with their warranty.

Not true their on sale now 12/17/23 for 114 twin ,120,queen144 king 1 feather 2 feather 3 feather, 1 standard,2 med 3 heavy duty

I usually use BOLL and Branch only but this comforter for 144 was a steal.