skip to main content

Hire a Painter or a "Cabinet Guy" for Kitchen Cabinet Color Change?

8 years ago

last modified: 8 years ago

http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/3425364/hire-a-painter-or-a-cabin

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (2)

Ellie B
Original Author
8 years ago
We bought a house recently and our kitchen cabinets are not old (~10 yrs) and great quality and we like the configuration so we decided the only thing we wanted to change is the color. They are currently stained with a glaze. We want a clean white or off\-white look (no glaze). We have a lot of cabinets and are not skilled in DIY so we agreed to hire a pro. The problem I am having is determining what kind of pro/process we really need. I have received at least five (5!) quotes which is a lot for me. We got two from painters and three from cabinet specialists. The cabinet guys' quotes were 10-12k. The painters quoted 3-5k. We got samples from one painter and two cabinet guys and I do think the cabinet guys' samples were superior - they basically look like factory cabinets but I am reluctant to spend that much money for changing the color and the painter sample seems good enough to me. I would go with the cabinet specialist, however if painting is going to be significantly less durable. The painter said he would use oil-based paint, no poly with a high volume, low pressure sprayer. One cabinet guy said he would use poly (I was less confident in him); one described a multi-step curing process (a franchise called n-hance https://www.nhance.com/blog/service/cabinet-color-change/)) that uses all water based products. Now I'm getting a bit daunted by the differing approaches and posts I've read and not really knowing the right path. Any advice? I've seen lots of posts about Cabinet Coat which I hadn't heard of. I'm including a couple of pics of our kitchen. http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/3425364/hire-a-painter-or-a-cabin These are pictures from before we bought the house so we have changed wall colors and furniture and such but hopefully you can see why we want to change the cabinet colors \- they are beautiful but they blend right in with the floors, giving a sort over-all "blah" effect. Any advice is very much appreciated!
paintguy22
8 years ago
I don't think it matters if it's a cabinet specialist or a painter as long as the person is proficient at doing this type of work. I don't paint cabinets all the time, but I'm sure my work would stand up to the cabinet guys job. In fact, I know a few companies that specialize in painting cabinets and they are usually double my price. The reason for this is because they charge twice as much as me (over $100 per hour). The reason they charge so much is because they can. They target rich people that live in wealthy areas and once you do that for a few years, those rich people refer you to their other rich friends and it snowballs. I work for regular people too so it's why I get to be the poor guy. I find that cabinet makers are carpenters first. That is their craft. They do paint and stain the cabinets they build, but painting is not their primary trade. I think finding a company that specializes in cabinet painting is going to be harder than finding a cabinet shop that will paint cabinets. Usually cabinet guys want to use lacquer or conversion varnish and will swear it's the best finish you can possible have. Everyone will have a different opinion about what is best. For me, I'm a fan of acrylics because they don't yellow. I always say the best way to find a contractor is from a friend. It would be great if you could actually see an entire kitchen that somebody painted and has been in use for a few years instead of just seeing sample doors.
Related Discussions
Found a local custom cabinet guy.... how do you judge?
Q
Comments (20)
Sorry for the delay Frameless cabs are European in origin which means they are metric ( US & England are the only Imperial holdouts left on the planet ). All your modern hardware ( hinges & slides )are designed in metric around the 32mm system. True frameless cabs are all in increments of 32mm, so a base cab would be 768mm ( 24 increments of 32mm ) This makes drawer and door sizes easy, as you could have a 6,6,6,6 or a 5,6,6,7 or an 8,8,8 or a 5 drawer ( 5 x32 ) & a 19 door ( 19 x 32 ). This is all very exact. The reveals on euro cabs are usually 3mm between doors and drawer fronts. When you place two cabs together, they need to have a shared 3mm reveal, so in actuality they only have 1.5mm each of a reveal. Where is this going? Veneer core plywood has never been nor will ever be flat or have uniform thickness (3/4" ply can go from 11/16 to 23/32 throughout the sheet ). So, you need these crazy exact reveals you dont have a square face frame to hide an out of square box so all your door and drawer front reveals dont line up. It can look horrible. Mdf and pb have a bad name but they are flat and consistent in thickness. They are the superior substrate anyone who tells you different ask to see a true frameless cab made from ply and check the reveals.
...See More
No meeting with cabinet guy
Q
Comments (19)
My Little Pony, lol 4 door samples were lacquered in colors of my choice..and when I still wasn't sure of the shade, I took my samples-and every sample reminding even remotely my preference, that our cabinetmaker had in his shop, and brought them to our place where I can see them in our light, with our floor, else. another guy whom we got a quote on our kitchen before also showed us the shop, the types of doors, explained everything we might need to know, and was also going to give us at least three samples to choose. this is a normal common practice with normal professionals. On the other hand not everybody is that accommodating..not everybody understands that a customer needs to get such and such info in order to be able to make educated (almost wrote "guess" lol) decision. Sometimes you have no idea what to ask, and some people think it means you already know. Ask for a normal explanation of what your builder going to put in your kitchen. And ask for the samples too. What does that even mean" modern door"? flat panel? colored laminate? wasn't torn off the walls of a medieval castle? I'm getting mad just reading this, really. Resonates so much. Like these shower glass doors guys. They come, show us 3 types of handles on the picture in a catalog, bring 2 samples of glass( but you see-they at least did bring something!), and answer every our question "talk with our boss, and we really need to run, and we also can't leave you this catalog."
...See More
Kitchen Cabinet Color Change to Gray
Q
Comments (12)
The cabinet color goes very well with the floor and counter; there's a good chance that the light gray you want will not (you'll have to evaluate in your own space, since photos and monitors can misrepresent reality). Changing out one element of a design that works well often produces something that works less well, sometimes a lot less well. I agree with others that the most jarring thing in the photos is the wall color, and that it appears to be in large part due to the effect of the lighting. I'd start with the lighting, move on to the wall color if lighting doesn't solve the problem, and only then would I even think about doing anything else. And even then I would take to heart the advice about how difficult and costly it is to get a good finish when repainting cabinets.
...See More
Painter ruined my kitchen cabinets
Q
Comments (30)
I am sorry you are having these problems. While sanding is important, I used a "no sanding necessary" primer (Zinsser) about 20 years ago on old kitchen cabinets that I put in my laundry room and one bathroom vanity. Over all, it has held up very well - though I admit neither room gets the wear and tear of a kitchen. Also, the original cabinet surface, while finished, was not glossy. The primer did take several days to cure and was initially easy to chip, but eventually hardened up. This does not help your issues with brush marks etc, but lack of sanding does not necessarily mean the paint will chip off totally. Even well done painted over finished wood cabinets experience the need for touch ups which is why I consider painting over previously finished wood cabinets to be a stop gap measure while saving for new cabinets to replace worn cabinets. With touch ups the cabinets can be presentable for many years as it can take some time for many to save up for new cabinets. I do have two friends with new white custom kitchen cabinets - both have chips on the pull out trash - so even expensive painted kitchens can need occasional touch ups. Even when the paint job comes out wonderfully, I usually caution against expensive counters / backsplash on painted over previously finished wood cabinets. Often, the paint job does not hold up over the long haul (> 5 years) and new cabinets become necessary - then the new counters and backsplash are wasted. If you plan on continuing improvements - keep them sensible and low cost - laminate counters rather than stone. You can have a sweet and functional kitchen without spending a fortune. If your layout is good, and your cabinet boxes in excellent condition, you could consider refacing in several years. it is great your cabinets are so tall. I hope you are able to get a discount and or repairs to your present paint job - but the kitchen is looking pretty:)
...See More

Related Stories

PAINTING How to Hire a Painter to Do Your Interiors

Here’s what to know about hiring a painting contractor and what to expect during the job

EVENTS Happy Birthday, Rembrandt: Peek Inside the Dutch Painter’s Former House

By Mitchell Parker

The famous Dutch painter surrounded himself with expensive artwork and rare antiquities, which led to a foreclosure on his house

REMODELING GUIDES How to Hire a Contractor

By Affecting Spaces Design Studio

Follow these 8 steps to find the right contractor for you and your project

WORKING WITH PROS 6 Reasons to Hire a Home Design Professional

By Incite Design

Doing a construction project without an architect, a designer or a design-build pro can be a missed opportunity

KITCHEN CABINETS Cabinets 101: How to Work With Cabinet Designers and Cabinetmakers

By Matt Clawson

Understand your vision and ask the right questions to get your dream cabinets

MOST POPULAR 8 Great Kitchen Cabinet Color Palettes

By Jennifer Ott Design

Make your kitchen uniquely yours with painted cabinetry. Here's how (and what) to paint them

MOST POPULAR From the Pros: How to Paint Kitchen Cabinets

By Vanessa Brunner

Want a major new look for your kitchen or bathroom cabinets on a DIY budget? Don't pick up a paintbrush until you read this

WORKING WITH PROS How to Work With a House Painter

By Lisa Frederick

A professional house painter may be your best friend for refreshing rooms. Here's what you need to know to get the best result

KITCHEN DESIGN Get a Grip on Kitchen Cabinets With the Right Knobs and Pulls

Here's how to pair the right style, type and finish of cabinet hardware with your kitchen style

KITCHEN CABINETS Choosing New Cabinets? Here’s What to Know Before You Shop

By Ventana Construction LLC

Get the scoop on kitchen and bathroom cabinet materials and construction methods to understand your options

Sponsored

More Discussions

sw high reflective white or extra white on kitchen cabinets?

8

Please Help! Palette & Style Conundrum-Modern Tropical Glam vs Coastal

10

Anybody here use Benjamin Moore's Kitty Gray on their exterior?

6

Color ideas for a house with red brick accents or covering brick?

2

Paint/decor suggestions

1