Six day old Beef Stew

10 years ago

Daughter just called to ask if her 6 day old Beef Stew was still okay to eat. She said it smelled fine, but wanted my reassurance. I said probably not, so she is throwing it out.

Want to know if what I did tell her was correct?

Featured Answer

nannygoat18

10 years ago

I have different standards for myself and others. I might decide take the risk but would never advise others to do the same. I feel people already know the answer to these kinds of questions but want someone else to take responsibility for the outcome.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

plllog
10 years ago
I'd say yes. And no. IF it was cooked well to begin with, and stored well, and IF it hadn't started to rot, and IF there were no incidental bad mold starting to grow but not seen, and IF it were thoroughly heated (simmered just below boiling for at least 20 minutes), or if she just has a strong stomach and immune system, it could have been fine. Smelling is a good way to judge actual rot, but since you weren't there yourself, saying yes to a smell test could be dangerous.

Basically, I'd rather send my daughter $20 and have her throw it out, just to be safe. It doesn't matter so much if it were objectively okay or not. We don't take risks with our babies, no matter how grown they are.
chas045
10 years ago
Well, I would have almost certainly eaten it, but I believe I'm one who '... has a strong stomach and immune system'. I almost always have leftover stew, and occasionally even end up with a third serving, although that is pushing it. However, we are usually 'eating', rather than 'dining' with the wine, candles and extended conversation that could lead to leaving it out for an inappropriately extended period.

Regarding the smell test: I would bet that your daughter (being younger) has a better sense of smell and therefore better equipped to detect odd odors.
Related Discussions
What, if anything, to do with old ram stew?
Q
Comments (14)
Sometimes digging around in my cookbooks is a strange and wonderful journey... I have an amazing number of recipes for beaver (?), bear (ew!) and squirrel. I found a lot of recipes that might be interesting starting points for you in two cookbooks in particular: Traditional Bulgarian Cooking and The LL Bean Game and Fish Cookbook (Bulgarian) (Bulgarian) (Bulgarian) (Don't ask me where the heck to find green almonds!) (LL Bean) (LL Bean) (LL Bean) (LL Bean) I honestly don't know how much of this will be relevant. Wild sheep is different than the domestic kind... it might be a source of inspiration though... Oh, and what about Alton Brown's Gyros recipe? Since this meat is going to be so, um, pungent, I might be tempted to use part sheep and part beef and/or pork to cut the flavor a little... I also might be tempted to google tagine recipes and try my luck with ones that used a lot of spices and dried apricots and/or cranberries... Your impulse to marinade is probably good... This might not be a definitive answer, but I hope it's food for thought! (And if anyone needs any other recipes for antelope, muskrat, possum or raccoon, it turns out I found the mother lode on my bookshelf!)
...See More
Beef Stew Recipe
Q
Comments (25)
I made up this recipe for stew one year during Milwaukee's Summerfest, so I call it Beef Festival. It's not quite traditional, but we like it. Beef Festival 2-3 Lbs beef chuck roast, cut into bite sized chunks. 2 good sized cloves garlic 3 or 4 onions, large dice 2-3 healthy sized tsp of Paprika, if you have smoked, you can replace some or all of the paprika with that. 1 healthy sized tsp of Bouquet Garni (Penzey’s) 1 tsp sugar 1 tsp plus a coupla shakes of Worshestershire salt to taste pepper to taste 1 or 2 bay leaves beef broth or water, about 4-6 cups, depending on how thick you like your stew 4 or so strips of bacon 3-4 good sized potatoes, cut to whatever size you’d like 8 carrots, cut in good sized chunks to cook at the same speed as the potatoes 4 ribs celery, large dice parsley Brown bacon, remove from pan. Then brown beef in bacon fat with the paprika, onion and garlic till the onion is just getting limp. Toss into a pot with the broth and add veggies and spices. Cook till everything is tender, adding water or broth to make it as soupy or thick as you like it. Thicken with flour/water if you prefer. This also works fine with pork. **If using a pressure cooker, cut the veg into larger pieces and leave the garlic whole. Bring to high pressure and cook for 15-20 minutes, less if your beef is cut into smaller chunks, more if it’s bigger. Turn off the heat and let the cooker depressurize naturally. This will result in a more tender beef. I know, this is contrary to Johnliu’s recipe for pressure cooker stew, but after reading and a little experimentation, I’ve found it to be a system that works for me. If the potatoes end up a little mushy, it really doesn’t bother me, but if it might bother you, cut them bigger or add them in stages. Reduce your broth if desired, or add thickener after pressure is released. Stew is such an individual thing�"I like lots of veggies, and I don’t care for peas. So there are lots of carrots and potatoes and no peas in mine. :-) I’ve been known to chuck in some green beans, cabbage, or whatever is in the fridge after the pressure is off, during broth reduction. Cj
...See More
Recipe help for elusive stewed beef?
Q
Comments (13)
When pressure cooking beef, you want something with a little fat in it like chuck; eye of round, for instance, might come out dry. Also, when pressure cooking beef, do NOT release the pressure with a valve or by putting the PC in the sink and running cold water over it; allow the PC's pressure to come down by itself after you turn off the heat. Releasing the pressure too quickly can make certain meats (especially beef) somewhat stringy. I posted this recipe in the past from Lorna Sass; it's a good starting point for timing for pressure cooking meats. It's for a curry, but if you leave out the curry paste you essentially have stewed beef. Here's a post for a great pressure cooker curry which uses Patak's curry paste. I find a equal parts of the mild and hot paste suits my palate just fine, but if I'm having a real yearning for hot-as-hades food I'll use all hot paste: CURRY IN A HURRY This recipe from Lorna Sass's Pressure Perfect is a quick and easy way to make a pretty tasty curry. You can make it with chicken, beef, lamb or pork, and vary the hotness by using mild or hot curry paste. 2 tablespoons of mild curry paste makes a pleasant-but-wimpy curry; 4 tablespoons of mild paste makes it pleasantly zingy; 4 tablespoons of hot curry paste makes it very hot, near my limit of tolerance (and I really like hot food). I generally use 2 tablespoons of hot and 2 tablespoons of mild curry paste. This is a recipe that's ridiculously easy yet produces delicious food. If you don't want to mess with the yogurt, peas and cilantro, don't bother--the dish will still be very tasty, but the sauce won't be as rich or velvety-smooth. ( I personally don't like cilantro, so I don't use it.) The recipe calls for 3 pounds of bone-in chicken; I find it easier to use about 2 or 2.5 pounds of boneless skinless chicken thighs. --Once you get the pressure cooker up to pressure, make a pot of rice. By the time the rice is done, so is this. 1 cup water 4 tablespoons Patak's Mild Curry Paste 1 medium onion, coarsely chopped 3 pounds bone-in skinless chicken thighs or breasts, or 2-2.5 lbs boneless skinless thighs, or 2 lbs. other meat (see chart below) 1 cup plain yogurt 1 cup frozen peas 3 tablespoons cilantro, chopped (optional) Pour the water into a 4-qt or larger pressure cooker and blend in the curry paste. Place on high heat and add the onion and meat of your choice. Lock the lid in place. Over high heat bring up to high pressure. Reduce the heat just enough to maintain high pressure and cook for the time indicated in the chart. Turn off the heat. Allow the pressure to come down naturally. (If cooking chicken, release any remaining pressure after 4 minutes.) Remove the lid, tilting it away from you to allow steam to escape. If the chicken or meat isn't tender, cover again and simmer until done. If necessary, skim off the fat that rises to the surface or degrease the broth in a fat separator. Blend the yogurt into 1 cup of the broth. Stir the peas into the curry and simmer until they are defrosted, about 1 minute. Turn off the heat and stir the yogurt mixture into the curry. Stir in the cilantro and salt to taste. Serve in bowls over rice. Meat choices Cooking times Chicken (see notes above) 8 minutes high pressure, 4 minutes of natural release, then quick release Beef (boneless chuck, 1" cubes) 8 minutes high pressure, then natural release Pork shoulder (1" cubes) 8 minutes high pressure, then natural release Lamb (boneless, 1" cubes) 12 minutes high pressure, then natural release
...See More
In Praise of Overcooked Stew
Q
Comments (10)
LOL! Jasdip, I was going to put in a jalapeño, but I kept forgetting, and saw the can of Ro-tel, which was left from a recipe, when I was looking for a can of tomatoes. ;). It's just diced tomatoes with a bit of kick. Vermouth is great in this kind of thing. I keep cooking quality port, sherry, madeira and marsala in a cupboard by the stove for deglazing and other winey tasks, and but I have't figured out how to fit the sake, and the vermouth is too tall. ;) They each have their uses. :). None of it matters for a stew. Use what you have, keeping in mind what flavors go well together, and It'll be great! Wednesday, I only grow herbs and lemons. The fat carrots come from my weekly farm boxes, but we get the regular carrots—longer and pointier— in the same colors where I shop locally. They come in bunches of orange or “rainbow”. The latter usually have red and orange as well as purple and yellow, and sometimes a true white, though I wonder if those are albinos. The rainbow bunches from the farm are whatever they have going, and reds are scarcer. Fennel is usually available here—a lot of things are—but this one also came from the farm box. Everybody, this is more a beef flavored root stew than a beef stew. There was only one pound of meat. :) I have a head of green kale which I think will make a nice contrast to the sweetness of the roots.
...See More
plllog
10 years ago
Good point, Chas! About the younger sniffer. I was only thinking about the experience to know what is the faint whiff of rot. :)
grainlady_ks
10 years ago
I'd get her some freezer containers ;-).

-Do they know if their refrigerator is even a food-safe temperature of 40°F or colder? If it's warmer than that, trash it - especially if they placed it in the refrigerator while still hot or really warm.

-Food that contains potentially deadly bacteria doesn't necessarily "smell bad", so that's not a good test.

-How was the food handled when it was placed into the refrigerator? Was it quick-chilled using an ice water bath in the sink (the prefered method), or was it left out at room temperature (the not-so-great method), or something else?

-Was it reheated in the pot several times and placed back in the refrigerator each time?

Too many variables for me to give it a clean bill of health - I'd trash it and call it one of life's lessons. If they are going to consume it, I would certainly follow pilllog's method, except it needs to come to a complete boil, not below boiling, in order to kill bacteria. By the time it's goes through a vigorous boil, there really isn't any real nutritional value left in it - so why bother wasting time and cooking energy?

-Grainlady
nannygoat18
10 years ago
When in doubt, throw it out.

Especially if DD is questioning:).
lindac92
10 years ago
Well....I would for sure have eaten it.....but I would have refrigerated it promptly after dishing out the first meal....
Started to rot??? Really? ROT?? as in become a host to maggots??
Yes bacteria can grow that you can't smell and they can kill you!! But most often those bacteria aren't found in leftover cooked beef stew. And boiling that stew for 20 minutes may kill the bacteria but not any toxins they create.
And "rotten" food I sure can smell....even slightly spoiled food.
However....since your daughter felt the need to ask...I am sure I would also have told her to feed it to the garbage disposer.

There are so many variables in food "longevity" and bacterial growth....besides the temperature of your refrig....things like how long you cooked it, the Ph of the gravy...wine? balsamic vinegar? lemon?....and how long it was at room temp before you put it away.
User
10 years ago
I would have told her throw it out. Technically it might still be safe, but as well as safe, I want it to taste as good as it did the first or second day. Six days old, no way.

~Ann
annie1992
10 years ago
I'd have eaten it without fear, but as Ann T mentions, the quality has most certainly suffered. And, if it doesn't taste delicious any more, why bother?

Annie
dedtired
10 years ago
I ate week old chicken pie for lunch yesterday. No problems and it tasted great. Still, I will chuck anything that is truly suspicious.
Terry Chute
6 months ago
last modified: 6 months ago
My mum used to make beef stew last ages at lea 5 days I'm 65 so didn kill me iI know she would add veg to it every day to bulk it up and rehea ever day till the new veg was cooked to be honest it tasted better each day iI still do it one in a while esspecially in winter and still hear to tell the tale
floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
6 months ago
last modified: 6 months ago
Thoroughly reheating every day for five days isn't the same as keeping for six days then reheating. I'm a skinflint but six days is too long imo. Unless it was kept very cold and chilled immediately after cooking.

Six day old Beef Stew

nannygoat18

Comments (12)

plllog

chas045

Related Discussions

plllog

grainlady_ks

nannygoat18

lindac92

User

annie1992

dedtired

Terry Chute

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US