Can Aeration Actually Cause Soil Compaction?
danielj_2009
8 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (32)
Julian 6A
8 years agoUser
8 years agoRelated Discussions
Compacted clay soil?
Comments (1)How did you apply the shampoo? How long did you water after the shampoo? Would you characterize the hard soil as either a low spot or a high spot relative to the rest of the yard? or about the same? How long do you normally water? What kind of sprinkler system do you have? Have you checked the sprinklers in the hard spots with cans to be sure those areas are getting the same amount of water as the greener areas? Hard soil and compacted soil are different things. Compacted soil has had the air mechanically driven out by first soaking it and then repeatedly sticking a plunger of some sort into it. Adobe bricks are made this way. In nature this typically happens around a pond where cattle or other livestock drink. It can also happen in a pasture if a farmer forgets to move his livestock out during a heavy rain. In a lawn it can happen if the yard gets heavy traffic during or immediately following a soaking rainstorm. Heavy traffic might be a party or a football game. Hard soil is caused by a lack of beneficial fungi which normally soften the soil. That can be caused either by prolonged drought or by short term flooding. in one the moisture is cut of for weeks, and in the other air is cut off for just a few days. If you have seriously given up on shampoo and watering it back to health, then you could apply a thin layer of compost. Apply no more than 1 cubic yard per 1,000 square feet. Even bermuda can be smothered by too much compost....See MoreCompacted soil and need to do some leveling
Comments (3)If you are using actual "topsoil" - nice dark soil with lots of organic matter - I would aerate then topdress. It is OK if you fill the holes if you are filling them with loose soil that drains well. If your "topsoil" is basically just fill dirt taken from another site, you may as well level then aerate. No use filling the holes up with basically the same material you just punched holes in....See MoreWill mulching over hard compacted soil help it to soften?
Comments (30)I'm sure different areas and soil types vary but my experience with mulch here in Austin, TX has been very good. Trying to make good gardening soil here takes effort. We're on scrub land to begin with, not good for much except raising really hardy cattle. Vegetable gardening is what I'm working towards and it's a harsh learning curve when you've got 3" of soil on top of limestone bedrock if you're lucky. I like no till, I like the idea and concept. If you have time, it's great. Nothing will take patience like trying to build soil no till in our area. We have plentiful cedar mulch and I use it extensively on my yard. The best way I've found in our climate, soil type is to prep a garden by tilling the entire area well and then adding copious amounts of finished compost and tilling/mixing it. Then you lay out your garden plots and with a shovel, scoop that now refreshed/tilled soil onto what are the garden beds and leave the path bare. So you've taken that 3" of soil and Very quickly turned it into a workable 6" but only in the beds. I then go in and put mulch heavily in the paths. We're talking 6" at least, if not more. I pile it on, it makes an excellent path to walk on, it's good for your back and it holds a huge amount of moisture when it rains which is lacking in our area. Over time this organic matter will break down and several years later you could grow vegetables in the path if you wanted. No till will work, it just takes a huge amount of time. Green manure works wonders. Leguminous plants like clover, vetch, peas and the like can do wonders over time. Season after season you could turn poor soil with no compost very fertile. If you cut down the green tops you can use them as a mulch as well. Using daikon and root crops to open the soil works as well. Masanobu Fukuoka was a huge proponent of using radish like daikon for this purpose. It's fast growing and if you planted it repeatedly it'll open the soil the way a plow would. It takes time, but if you were working on a large area or acreage it's the slow steady pace of changing land. If you have issues with weeds you can put down cardboard underneath mulch in pathways to smother them. Several layers of cardboard will break down rapidly and in our area we use it to smother bermuda grass. Even if we get a bunch shooting up on top of mulch we've put down we'll put cardboard down and mulch heavily...again. In the garden beds themselves if we have issue I'll do the same thing on the beds but with newspaper. I cover the garden bed, then put 3" or so of compost on top of the bed to smother out the bermuda grass instead of trying to weed them. It's less work, works better long term and builds up the soil. So, long story short, mulch is great. Use lots of it. It takes time to break down but I've seen no downside to it. It improves soil, holds moisture, provides habitat for beneficial bugs and worms who do the work of improving soil for you....See MoreDifficult clay soil - is my garden a lost cause? Or what can I do?
Comments (18)I was thinking about this thread as I was doing some reading in various places about humus. Even wikipedia puts it this way about stable humus: " this is organic matter that has been protected from decomposition by microbial or enzyme action because it is hidden (occluded) inside small aggregates of soil particles or tightly attached (sorbed or complexed) to clays. Most humus that is not protected in this way is decomposed within ten years and can be regarded as less stable or more labile." It also refers specifically to lignin being one of the main precursors to humus, and that black carbon (e.g. biochar) also seems to contribute a lot to stability. Interesting the way that OM gets attached to clays. I don't know if this is actionable information or what it tells us exactly about what to do in this case; but I'd be tempted to place an emphasis on woody/pulpy inputs (or composts from them) in adding organic material, or at least plant material (stems? corn cobs/stalks? etc) or paper/cardboards that have fair amounts of lignin and get some charcoal/biochar in there too. Just speculating somewhat, but hopefully logically. This will have implications for nitrogen and other nutrient availability - i.e. it might make growing some types of plants or getting good yields harder, at least in short term - but might have benefits in getting there to more stable soil in long term. FWIW....See Morereeljake
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoUser
8 years agodchall_san_antonio
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoUser
8 years agoUser
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agoUser
8 years agoUser
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agoUser
8 years agoUser
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years agoreeljake
8 years agodanielj_2009
8 years ago
Related Stories
GARDENING GUIDESGardening Solutions for Heavy Clay Soils
What’s a gardener to do with soil that’s easily compacted and has poor drainage? Find out here
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESHow to Stop Worrying and Start Loving Clay Soil
Clay has many more benefits than you might imagine
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDES10 Solutions for Soggy Soil
If a too-wet garden is raining on your parade, try these water-loving plants and other ideas for handling all of that H2O
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESGet the Dirt on Your Garden’s Soil
Understand how your soil supports your plants so you can ensure your garden’s success
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESHow to Pick a Mulch — and Why Your Soil Wants It
There's more to topdressing than shredded wood. Learn about mulch types, costs and design considerations here
Full StoryCONTAINER GARDENSContainer Gardening Basics: The Dirt on Soil
Learn the types of potting soil available and the best mixes to help your containers thrive
Full StoryGARDENING GUIDESGreat Design Plant: Try Blue Bells for Blooms in Dry Soil
This shrub’s violet-blue flowers and silvery foliage brighten low-water gardens all year long
Full StoryNATIVE PLANTSWhy Aggressive Plants Might Actually Be Your Friends
Sometimes a garden thug is exactly what’s called for
Full StoryLANDSCAPE DESIGNSmall Garden? You Can Still Do Bamboo
Forget luck. Having bamboo that thrives on a wee plot just takes planning, picking the right variety, and keeping runners in check
Full StoryENTRYWAYS7 Design Ideas for a Small Entry
Banish the clutter — and the last-minute search for keys — with these ideas for organizing your entry
Full Story
reeljake