Planting bulbs in pure pumice (plus compost)

8 years ago

I can't find coarse sand so easily. It is highly unusual to find it even in a hardware store. The closest thing I can find is aquarium sand, but this one comes in a small bag and is much more expensive than a truckload of regular (fine) sand. Perhaps it's a matter of geology: Being not very common in my country, it has to be imported, or maybe the process of making the sand usable for aquariums is behind the high price.

I've read how much pumice is good for bulbs. The ground pumice is not uniform, and it may contain a mix of particles mostly the size of sand grains and all the way up to 4mm size grains. My experience with sand is negative, as a result of the fine particles. Ground pumice, on the other hand, is a sand with grains of mixed size. My guess is that I have to separate the fine from the coarse particles and use the coarse ones. How can I do it to get the right size particle? Do you order sieves with a particular mesh size? Where do you get them?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
8 years ago
Which country are you in? Can you get grit? And which bulbs is this for?
asclepiad_fan
Original Author
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
I'm from Israel,

We have quarry sand in hardware stores, but I guess I can sift and wash it if i'm right? It is made-up of crushed stones with irregular grain size, but most is like fine silt.

I see lots of pictures of grit, but I can't tell the grain size just by looking at it. Which size do you use?
Related Discussions
Can you plant blueberries in pure peat?
Q
Comments (6)
I would probably add some fine bark, just to make sure your blueberries don't get wet feet. They do like to stay moist (our challenge here in S. California, besides having to grow them in containers due to our more alkaline soils), but they will love, love, love your peat. Great product, btw. I've included a link below you might find helpful. The second question in this Q&A page has the answer given about pure peat moss. Patty S. Here is a link that might be useful: NDSU Extension Service: Growing Blueberries
...See More
Sheet composting for future planting: Why bother?
Q
Comments (24)
Joli said: "PHD or not Scott is wrong on much of what she said. You should work up 4 square feet of soil for fruit trees & go at least 12-24 inches deep. I have planted burlap ball trees, potted trees, even dug them out of the woods & replanted them. I have never used more then 1/4 amendments in any hole, but think it is important to spread the amendments out over the 4 feet square. This has worked for me & I will stay with it, no matter how many papers are published for a University. Some of what she says is for bare root (hill in hole for roots), not burlap or potted plants. Yet she does not say that." Exactly correct IMHO. Scott is one of those people who likes to convince us that the sky isn't blue on a sunny day so to speak. She has made a living by being a contrarian. There is absolutely nothing wrong with layering your soil with organic matter. In fact, in the VAST majority of cases it is VERY beneficial. Period...end of story. Sure, don't go crazy with amending the planting hole soil for permanent plantings, but that is common sense. You seem to be doing FINE......keep it up IMHO.
...See More
Pumice vs truface for growing fruit trees
Q
Comments (12)
Hi, V - "Almost impossible to kill" doesn't mean "thrives on anything you throw at it". Simply put, if you want the best results, you need to eliminate limitations to the greatest degree possible. The factor responsible for the largest number of problems people arrive here seeking remedies for is soil choice, so unless you want to continually fight your soil for control of your plant's vitality, I suggest you use as a minimum standard that you can water properly w/o having to worry that you're killing roots and limiting root function. Do you have a OSH store near you? If so, check out what kind of bark products they have that could be used as the base for a medium. Let us know and we'll go to work on it. For now, use a utility knife to cut 4 vertical scores in the side of the root mass and an X on the bottom and pot up a size until you get the soil figured out. Al
...See More
Cactus deflating after planting in 100% Pumice
Q
Comments (24)
I think robin and palms gave you really good advice. I noticed my plants in claypots with turface soil in them seems to do very well. Manuel - to answer your question, any regular C&S peat type soil will work. I started using vermiculite at first, as it does promote health in the small feeder roots but I realized it still lacked the mineral holding capacity that the pumice/turface can't hold long enough - Meaning it still drains pretty quickly. I started using more mineral based loam soil that's very organic rich, the effects have been really promising so far, and I'm looking forward to pot all my other plants that needs repotting into it. I fertilize quite regularly, but I think the organic loam has certain rich minerals that my foilage pro can't provide. and it's producing pretty happy plants. Note: I did not really sieve my soil before adding into my inorganic gritty mix (maybe I should), but I only add very minimal. Like 10-20% max. Usually before I pot my plants, I grab a zip lock bag -- I then scoop all the components with the same spade equally to ensure its the same ratio. So it will go like -- 2 scoop turface, 2 scoop pumice, 2 scoop girt. I shake the bag, then I add about 1/4-1/2 scoop of loam and a spoonful of food grade diatomaceous earth powder (to combat any nasties or mealys in making the soil its home). Shake again, viola, my soil is ready to use. I must admit, it's alot more work and it gets really messy, but my plants react very well to this mix thus far. At your point, I would suggest to not disturb your cacti. It's probably stress from the repot. No hurry to make the "best" soil yet, but if you do have free time to kill and experiment, be my guest. Happy Growing!
...See More
floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
8 years ago
I don't use grit or sand or anything. I was just wondering what you had available. I just plant bulbs straight in the garden or, if in containers, in bagged container mix. That's why I asked what bulbs you were growing in case it was something unusual that needed special treatment. These tulips are just in a standard potting mix from the garden centre.
asclepiad_fan
Original Author
8 years ago
I noticed the grain size of soil garden does not have any ill effect on the bulbs. It is a bummer that most of the garden lies in a deep shade in the winter, when the sun is low behind trees, buildings and other construction. The end result is etiolation, and gladiolas are mostly affected because their stem does not stand well against the winter storms. Tulips do well in peat but I don't plant them because they need a much colder winter and the summer is just too hot. My experience shows they can't store enough nutrients and they divide into many tiny bulblets, losing mass overtime.

My targeted plants are mainly South-African bulbs, comprising Gladiolus species (not including the hybrids in European gardens), Ixia, Massonia, Geissorhiza and Daubenya. I'm exploring the market for more species. Other bulbs grow in peat and I'm not concerned about finding the correct potting mix. These include Crocosmia, Watsonia, Homeria and Ledebouria.

I'm also a member of the Cactus society, and the website has one recipe for cacti. Is that soil good for these bulbs? The soil make-up is:

1x dune sand or fine sand

1x perlite

3x peat

4x ground pumice

1x compost (This amount is for seed-starting, you can add more for mature plants)

All five components are readily available.
Michaela (Zone 5b - Iowa)
8 years ago
Wow floral. I am going to have to grow some tulips in a window box after seeing that photo!

Planting bulbs in pure pumice (plus compost)

Comments (5)

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

asclepiad_fan
Original Author

Related Discussions

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

asclepiad_fan
Original Author

Michaela (Zone 5b - Iowa)

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Planting bulbs in pure pumice (plus compost)

Comments (5)

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

asclepiad_fanOriginal Author

Related Discussions

floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK

asclepiad_fanOriginal Author

Michaela (Zone 5b - Iowa)

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

asclepiad_fan
Original Author

asclepiad_fan
Original Author