And this is my previous thread on this topic.

We need to replace the existing sofa ASAP due to condition. The budget is tight due to ongoing remodeling--getting the kitchen and bathroom right take precedence ATM. We were happy with the existing sofa for comfort and quality given the price so we are going to order from clubfurniture again.

We definitely want another brown leather sofa. So the question is which brown leather sofa? And do we want another sleeper? We have basically always had a sleeper sofa. And it has seldom been used. But seldom isn't never. And for some styles the sleeper part only adds about $300-400 in cost. At that point if it gets used twice, it has probably paid for itself in hotel bills. On the other hand, the budget is tight and some styles are not available with a sleeper.

We definitely want a tight back. And I prefer a three cushion over a two cushion sofa because it makes it more comfortable for three people to sit.

This is what we have now.

It is comes with or without a sleeper. It is very comfortable for us. It fits okay with the style of the room, IMO. I'm a little over the big rolled arms, but I don't hate them.

And this is another possibility, but it does not come with a sleeper and it is a two cushion seat.

And here's The link to clubfurniture.

Again, sorry for the serial post. I couldn't seem to post more than one link or picture in a post for some reason.

Sorry, one more option. This also does not come with a sleeper.

First of all, I'm drooling over your house from the one photo. Would you show us a picture of your current sofa? It doesn't seem as bad as you say. Everything you currently own always starts to look old during a renovation. I would be inclined to make due until you save up for better quality. Maybe find a really interesting textile to throw over the sofa?

Yes, we have essentially decided on a brown leather sofa from club furniture. I posted pictures of three options so no one has to look at club furniture to express a preference for one of those three options. If someone wants to follow the link and make a different suggestion, that's fine too of course. And obviously other suggestions are just fine, but we aren't very likely to take them.

(Craigslist has some major drawbacks for us for buying a sofa. One is that we lack the time to invest in that kind of search and the ability to move a sofa ourselves which complicates the purchase and adds to the expense. I am also very reluctant to buy upholstered furniture used given the resurgence of bedbugs.)

1929spanish, thank you!

Here is the main reason for the ASAP.

This is is likely mostly due to our failure to take proper care of the leather. Lesson learned.

I should perhaps add that we have been covering it with a quilt from the local flea market, but it continues to get bigger and I'm just not up for duct taping it. Lol. The split is probably four or five inches long now. The sofa as a whole is dry and we should have conditioned it more often.

Well, there's no argument there. Having never had leather furniture, I can't speak two whether it's the quality of the leather or the upkeep. ;)

I might throw a cool Kilim rug over it for a bit to buy time. That being said, number two is the best but I really think they all look a little clunky.

Given the tight budget, I would tape the rip and keep a folded throw over the back of the couch, as shown in my3dogs photo. No one would be the wiser.

Another poster is using this company

http://cascobayfurniture.com/Studio%20Leather%20Collection/c82/p4062/Central%20Park/product_info.html?CDpath=11

We gave a leather sofa to DD for her apartment. When it developed a rip, DH bought a leather patch kit on Amazon and it is holding up well. That's another option to buy you some time.

I like your second option the most. I think it's rare to have three people sit on a couch, unless one is a child. Also, sleeper sofas are SO heavy to move, and generally not very comfortable. I'd get an Aerobed if you need it for guests :-)

I like the 2nd one best, then 3 (I like that the arms are a little more refined/smaller) and 1. I would probably pass on the sleeper sofa, but we don't usually have guests. I'd choose the one you like best and bonus points if it has the sleeper. Your room looks very nice!

I just saw this on Hometalk and thought I'd pass it along in case it's something that would work for you. It's a lot less than buying a new leather sofa.
http://www.hometalk.com/961473/repairing-and-refurbishing-leather

Thanks to everyone!

Dh vetoes the third sofa as he says it looks like it belongs in a government office. Well, okay then. He prefers to get the exact same sofa again because he prefers its looks and also thinks it is worth getting another sleeper at that small of an increase in price. I think he also knows that this one is comfortable so he'd rather not risk switching styles and getting one that is not as comfortable.

I prefer the second one for looks, but would rather have a three cushion seat and would rather have a sleeper. Dh says if we go with the exact same sofa again I can choose the leather color (he wants darker choices than I do). So there is that. Though truthfully, I am sure I could just do that anway, because he doesn't care all that much.

We will likely mull it over for a couple days and then order. I really appreciate the help with the decision!

It sounds like you've made the right decision for you & DH. However, I would find a cool throw for the back & use funds for your renovation. Then get the sofa of your dreams that will withstand a lively household.

I used brown packing tape on a leather cushion hole for over a year, a throw disguised it and no one ever noticed since the Kraft tape matched in color and feel.