Please critique plan: 1344 ft2, one story
Kathie Lofts
8 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (24)
Related Discussions
Please critique my floor plan
Comments (23)Garage/home walls have to be fire rated. It would function better if the garage was set apart from the main house with either a courtyard or breezeway between the two so that you could get more natural light into the house and still be able to utilize the visual connection between the two. A garage that needs to house two cars stacked on a lift will need to be taller than you are planning to account for not smashing the lighting on the ceiling. You might want to house something beyond lower height sports cars. Our 4 post lift in our garage won't allow a tall vehicle like a SUV on it and then raise to full height, and we vaulted our already 11' tall ceiling to 15' in the lift bay. Even with Corvette stacked on top of Corvette, it's really tight with the lighting when the lift is up enough to get that second vehicle under it. Only Formula cars without the wings would really work to have the double stack be comfortable at that height, and they have issues with the ramps, needing longer ones to get the ground clearance for the chassis. We also climate controlled our garage area, as that keeps the vehicles in much better shape, and it's a much more pleasant working environment. While you plan on having guests here, this isn't a very guest friendly house. There isn't enough room allotted for them, either in the public or private spaces. I might suggest the separate garage have a second floor guest suite(s) and make the main house more about your groundfloor space on one side, and the public space on the other, linking to the garage space visually through the breezeway. Double height space is very difficult to heat and cool, so I would suggest having hydronic radiant floor heating for winter comfort so that the people in the rooms are closer to the heating source.(We did that in our garage, so if you happen to need to be on a creeper under something, you don't have a giant cold mass of concrete sucking the warmth out of your body.) For summer, if you rarely get temperatures above 85, then I probably wouldn't do AC at all since you are in a low humidity climate. I would focus on doing some type of cupola with operable vent windows that will allow the hot air that rises to be vented externally. That's an old fashioned technique, but very effective in climates that don't heat and humidity to need full time AC. Overall, you really need a good architect to take these ideas and make them more functional and designed specifically for the site, to take advantage of it's positives. You will need that anyway for permitting, and in CA there are plenty of creative people who would love to be a part of an interesting build. Take a look at some back issues of Architectural Digest and see if you come across any designs that you like, Then contact a couple of those folks. This needs a large amount of technical expertise to wade through the red tape of building and permitting. So, you need someone local as a builder, well as an architect whose work you admire to work as a team to accomplish this build. Hire good people, and then listen to them. A good design is an interactive experience that makes the work better. Good design is "invisible" You don't even notice that things are where they need to be and work the way they "should". Bad design is obvious, especially if you live with it. It makes life harder. Don't make your life harder!...See MoreWhich 3000 sq ft 2 level plan would you rather live in?
Comments (24)Kirkhall, I actually agree with you, but I have heard that prep is 80% of the work. Plus DH, who is also in the kitchen, prepping, cleaning, etc likes the idea of facing the TV while washing dishes and prepping. Me, I like that I was able to shave 3 ft off the plan - and was a little worried having a 17 ft wide dining area - seems a little wide for a 6 seating table. Approx 14ish seems more reasonable (kind of like plan 1). I am kind of neutral to which way it faces actually and see advantages both ways. The only arrangement I am actually not that fond of is kitchen, dining and great room all in a row left to right. As far as fridge placement, I can work that out if it's not ideal. It was just a quick revision. Thanks for the link to CamG's house. I like the upstairs, and it could work with a few modifications. But both DH and myself do not want a WIC off the bathroom, we need a soaker tub as well as shower for the master, no water closet, and I would like a master 17-18 ft wide and a width of about 15 or so. The rest of the upstairs would be flexible I think. I would welcome any more opinions about the modified summerfield plan (hallway etc) vs plan 1 (no real utility hallway) . I think these are my 2 working choices at this point....See Morehouse plan critique. main level and 2nd story
Comments (25)Angled walls create dead and slivers of unusable space. Most people want to be able to use every square foot they pay for. The curved wall does not relate to anything, it is an oddity, and it a lot easier to draw than it is to build; and a 90 degree corner costs less that a rounded corner (if you can find someone to build it properly). My other comments from the previous thread still apply....See MoreCritique this plan for us please.
Comments (21)So, here’s my take.....since you do not have the option for a daylight basement and you want an expanded living space for family, I would really consider expanding your living room as well as the dining room. Why force yourself into a dark basement with no windows when you can have a much larger entertaining space on your main floor which also has windows. Although the dimensions for your living room are 20x20, you lose at least 3 feet for your walkway to the kitchen, and another 3 or 4 feet due to the fireplace and builtins. So, your 20x20 room is actually only 17x16 of usable floor space. I would basically pull out the living room wall to where the dining room wall is, and pull out the dining room wall to where the end of the patio comes. You would of course lose the patio door from your bedroom and your outdoor living space would be more exposed rather than set back. It all depends on how you live and what‘s important to you. Nine grandkids plus adults is a lot of people and I personally would want a space that could better accommodate a crowd. Obviously you’d need a ridiculously huge room to seat your entire family and I fully understand that is not feasible, but I would go as large as realistically possible for comfortable family entertaining rather than be forced down to a dark basement. My family room is 20x20 and also has builtins and a fireplace like your plan has, but that drastically cuts down on space and if there are 10 of us in the room, it’s crowded with not nearly enough seating....See MoreKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agolast modified: 8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agochelwa
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years agoKathie Lofts
8 years ago
Related Stories
HOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: A Three-Story Barn Becomes a Modern-Home Beauty
With more than 9,000 square feet, an expansive courtyard and a few previous uses, this modern Chicago home isn't short on space — or history
Full StorySUMMER GARDENINGHouzz Call: Please Show Us Your Summer Garden!
Share pictures of your home and yard this summer — we’d love to feature them in an upcoming story
Full StoryINSIDE HOUZZTell Us Your Houzz Success Story
Have you used the site to connect with professionals, browse photos and more to make your project run smoother? We want to hear your story
Full StoryARCHITECTURETell a Story With Design for a More Meaningful Home
Go beyond a home's bones to find the narrative at its heart, for a more rewarding experience
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNSoapstone Counters: A Love Story
Love means accepting — maybe even celebrating — imperfections. See if soapstone’s assets and imperfections will work for you
Full StoryLIFEGive Your Home a History by Telling Your Story
Share your family's epic saga — or even just kiddie doodles — for a home that's personal, meaningful and inspiring
Full StoryLIFEIs Cabin Fever Real? Share Your Story
Are snow piles across the U.S. leading to masses of irritability and boredom? We want to hear your experience
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: Curiosities Tell a Story
An interiors stylist uses her house as a 3D timeline of her tales and travels
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: Cinderella Story in Pittsburgh
Creative renovation turns radiator shop Into a contemporary gem
Full StoryHOMES AROUND THE WORLDSee the Home Where Charles Dickens Wrote Some of His Classic Stories
On December 17, 1843, ‘A Christmas Carol’ was published, and we’re celebrating with a tour of the famed author’s home
Full StoryColumbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations
annkh_nd